The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • mvspree8
    Pro
    • Mar 2007
    • 580

    #1546
    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

    Originally posted by Las Vegas Ligers
    In association with the nuggets. My team needs rebounding and minnessota has publicly stated that they want to trade Love before he just leaves them so here.


    Wolves receive:
    Kenyon Martin 6'9 PF/C
    Gary Forbes 6'8 SF

    Nuggets Receive:
    Kevin Love 6'10 PF

    I know its my game and i can do whatever I want but does this seem realistic in the slightest? In real life, with the draft that Minnesota just had, they probably will trade Kevin Love before he leaves in the off season.

    BTW im also planning to avg about 34 mpg with him. Can anyone clue me in on whether he will be unhappy with that much? Cause the last thing I need is one more player complaining about lack of min even though they avg 30+.
    I don't think it's realistic for the Nuggets to get Love without trading their two best players and at least a first-rounder for him. In your trade the Wolves really get nothing at all.

    Comment

    • Suntan Superman
      ****
      • Feb 2009
      • 7135

      #1547
      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

      Originally posted by mvspree8
      I don't think it's realistic for the Nuggets to get Love without trading their two best players and at least a first-rounder for him. In your trade the Wolves really get nothing at all.
      If we're accounting for realism, then we have to remember he's trading with Kahn. Lol. Send Euros and Draft picks
      Support Local Sports

      Comment

      • 13
        Say whaaa?
        • Mar 2010
        • 778

        #1548
        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

        Originally posted by Las Vegas Ligers
        In association with the nuggets. My team needs rebounding and minnessota has publicly stated that they want to trade Love before he just leaves them so here.


        Wolves receive:
        Kenyon Martin 6'9 PF/C
        Gary Forbes 6'8 SF

        Nuggets Receive:
        Kevin Love 6'10 PF

        I know its my game and i can do whatever I want but does this seem realistic in the slightest? In real life, with the draft that Minnesota just had, they probably will trade Kevin Love before he leaves in the off season.

        BTW im also planning to avg about 34 mpg with him. Can anyone clue me in on whether he will be unhappy with that much? Cause the last thing I need is one more player complaining about lack of min even though they avg 30+.
        What a great trade for Denver. Not realistic at all, however. You need to give up much better players/picks then that.
        Celtics Bruins Sox Eagles Liverpool

        Retired U.S.A.F.

        Comment

        • Shade8780
          Banned
          • Dec 2010
          • 845

          #1549
          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

          So first I signed Michael Finley from the FA pool then........

          Chicago get: M. Finley

          Sonics get: K. Korver

          Comment

          • bichettehappens
            MVP
            • Jun 2010
            • 2547

            #1550
            Originally posted by Shade8780
            So first I signed Michael Finley from the FA pool then........

            Chicago get: M. Finley

            Sonics get: K. Korver
            Not realistic because if Chicago wanted Finley they simply could have signed him, but I suppose the trade is even.

            Comment

            • jlech1805
              Rookie
              • May 2011
              • 304

              #1551
              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

              So breaking this down in two parts, the first three-team trade was a little hard for me to swallow, if only because I think the 76ers thing Speights has a good future and they have all that money tied up in Elton Brand, so getting Al Jefferson doesn't help them much PLUS giving up a first round pick(if you catch my drift) Otherwise it's not too terrible of a trade, I think the Jazz made out the best of course getting the best player(everyone likes trading for Gay lol) and giving up arguably the least valuable in Jefferson. It works but not sure on realism there.


              I modified this trade in a couple of ways.

              1)76ers no longer give up a 1st rounder, the Jazz do

              2) I am still in the middle of the "off-season", I am acting as if the NBA has re-instated the amnesty clause from the previous lockout. Each team can release a single player (who they are not allowed to re-sign) and the contract will not count against the cap.

              In this scenario the 76ers would definitely rid themselves of Brands contract which makes it more likely that they would accept this trade.



              The second trade isn't bad though, I don't think it would ever happen, but as far as value of player goes, I think it fits nicely. Jimmer and Burks are about equal, Harris and Thornton are kinda equal Millsap is better than Thompson, but throwing in Dalembert moderately negates that, and the 2nd round pick is likely to be someone who doesn't make the team anyway, so yeah.


              I took out Millsap, Thompson, Dalembert and the pick.
              Path to the Hall of Fame: Guts, Glory and Gangrene:
              http://www.operationsports.com/forum...d.php?t=705636

              Comment

              • Biistli
                Rookie
                • Apr 2011
                • 11

                #1552
                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                Originally posted by Biistli
                Jameer Nelson, Jason Richardson and Daniel Orton <-------> Amare Stoudemire, Renaldo Balkman and Andy Rautins
                Nobody has noticed, so I how to quote my own post. What do you guys think, was this realistic? You gotta now that J-Rich had contract year so Knicks get 15M + free salary cap from J-Rich´s contract and of course Billups contract. So now they can build all up to Melo cos they got so much free cap at summer, maybe they could snap up even better player than STAT.

                Comment

                • bichettehappens
                  MVP
                  • Jun 2010
                  • 2547

                  #1553
                  Originally posted by Biistli
                  Nobody has noticed, so I how to quote my own post. What do you guys think, was this realistic? You gotta now that J-Rich had contract year so Knicks get 15M + free salary cap from J-Rich´s contract and of course Billups contract. So now they can build all up to Melo cos they got so much free cap at summer, maybe they could snap up even better player than STAT.
                  I don't see any scenario where New York trades Amare as being realistic, nor do I think they got remotely fair value in that deal. Only fair trade scenario with Amare going to Orlando would have Dwight headed to New York under the guise of him not being willing to resign with the Magic

                  Comment

                  • Rhyster95
                    Rookie
                    • Jun 2011
                    • 132

                    #1554
                    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                    If you want to see My Lineup, Just Ask:

                    Blazers Recieve:
                    PG Boogie Gibson

                    Cavs Recieve:
                    1st Round Pick
                    Trade 2:
                    Blazers Recieve:
                    K.Korver
                    1st Round Pick
                    Bulls Recieve:
                    N.Batum
                    You Mad Bro?

                    Comment

                    • vstro
                      Rookie
                      • Jan 2011
                      • 325

                      #1555
                      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                      Originally posted by Rhyster95
                      If you want to see My Lineup, Just Ask:

                      Blazers Recieve:
                      PG Boogie Gibson

                      Cavs Recieve:
                      1st Round Pick
                      Trade 2:
                      Blazers Recieve:
                      K.Korver
                      1st Round Pick
                      Bulls Recieve:
                      N.Batum
                      Let me get this straight... You gave up a 1st round pick for Daniel Gibson? I don't know if there's a GM in the league that would do that one...

                      Comment

                      • Cairns_baller
                        Rookie
                        • May 2011
                        • 95

                        #1556
                        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                        For my current association:

                        Magic (me) trade : Jameer Nelson and JJ Reddick

                        Atlanta trade: Josh Smith

                        Or

                        Magic (me) trade: Gilbert Arenas and Hedo

                        Atlanta Trade: Josh Smith

                        Which trade is more realistic, i think it's the first but wanted some more opinions. Howard is gone, so trying to get Smith as the new face of the franchise. Given the rumors that he is being shopped around I think it's realistic. Opinions?

                        I'm basically rebuilding after Howards departure to the Lakers. I did a 3 team trade which may not be 100% realistic but I created it on the basis that Howard and CP3 demanded trades from their teams (eg. Carmelo)

                        Magic trade: Howard and Arenas

                        Magic recieve: P Gasol, Okafor, Caracter

                        Lakers trade: P Gasol, Bynum, Artest and Caracter

                        Lakers receive: CP3, D12, Trevor Ariza

                        Hornets trade: CP3, Ariza, Okafor

                        Hornets receive: Arenas, Artest and Bynum

                        I have put this up earlier on a different association, I know it's probably unrealistic but as I said I based on the fact that they demanded a trade. Its a hell of a deal for LA, but makes me enjoy the game more trying to beat them.

                        As I said I'm rebuilding the Magic post D12 era, I'm hoping to model the team after the Thunder side. Hoping I can land Josh Smith as the face of the franchise with the trades I put up earlier, however I'm wondering whether Okafor and Orton is a better offer. Okafor would allow Horford to return to centre and Orton is a better prospect then what the Hawks have at SF or PF.

                        I'm undecided on Pau Gasol, my first though it to get Marc from Memphis and reunite them but then again I wouldn't mind a younger PF such as Jefferson or Thomas.

                        It's going to be a fire sale and pretty much no one is untouchable, I know it's also very unrealistic for teams to completely rebuild their roster but hey this is a video game after all.

                        I'm interested in getting Lou Williams from Philly. Don't know how realistic the move would be but they have Holiday their who i think may be a little better. The move would give Williams the chance to start. I don't know who I could trade for him though..maybe JJ Redick is a even trade. I will sign Iverson as a back - up, last chance kind of deal.

                        Monta Ellis is another high priority and given the rumours I don't think it's that far fetched. Brendan Bass and Richardson might be good enough to get him, GS can better defensively at the guard position however they do get older. Bass is a slight upgrade at Center for GS in my opinion.

                        Role playing targets include T-Mac, Sessions, Sean Williams (FA), Sean May (FA) and R Lopez.

                        Any opinions? Is reuniting the Gasol brothers a good move for the Magic?
                        Last edited by Cairns_baller; 06-27-2011, 04:01 AM.

                        Comment

                        • Rhyster95
                          Rookie
                          • Jun 2011
                          • 132

                          #1557
                          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                          Originally posted by vstro
                          Let me get this straight... You gave up a 1st round pick for Daniel Gibson? I don't know if there's a GM in the league that would do that one...
                          I don't really use draft Picks, Because i can get someone better By trading them.
                          You Mad Bro?

                          Comment

                          • dray8theman
                            Rookie
                            • Oct 2010
                            • 34

                            #1558
                            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                            I'm running a 30 team Association. It's my first time doing this and I gotta say it's a lot of fun. I have so much control it's great. Anyway I am at the trade deadline and I've made some trades, some of them are sort of questionable, but I can see them all happening in RL except for one and I'll let you know which one. Just let me know what you guys think.

                            Also I don't know if I have to differentiate between 2k10 and 2k11, but this is my 2k10 Association with updated rosters.

                            Minor Trades
                            The Detroit Pistons trade G Tracy McGrady to Miami for F Udonis Haslem.
                            (This is the trade I don't really see happening in real life. I don't believe the Heat would ever trade Haslem, especially not for a declining wing player.)

                            The Golden State Warriors trade G Jerry Stackhouse to Dallas for F Shawne Williams.
                            (Jerry is old and probably has only one year left. Shawne Williams is a good prospect forward.)

                            The Denver Nuggets trade G Raymond Felton to Portland for Andre Miller.
                            (This trade actually happened in real life, so )

                            The Sacramento Kings trade G Rashad McCants to Minnesota for their current 1st round draft pick.

                            Major Trades
                            3 Team trade involving the Bobcats, the Celtics, and the Trailblazers.

                            The Bobcats receive: G Delonte West (BOS) and C Greg Oden (POR)

                            The Trailblazers receive: C Jermaine O'Neal (BOS)

                            The Celtics receive: F Stephen Jackson (CHA) and G Raja Bell (CHA)
                            Also in the game the rumor mill has Rondo being traded. That's ridiculous.

                            (May not actually happen in real life, but it seems to be a realistic trade. Note: Greg Oden is actually good when he's not hurt. )

                            The Chicago Bulls trade F Carlos Boozer to Golden State for G Monta Ellis.
                            (I moved Ellis to the two guard position and have him and Rose on the floor at the same time. They are turning out to be the best backcourt in the league. Since he's been traded the Bulls have won 7 in a row and 9 of the last 10 now standing at 29-23)

                            The Oklahoma City Thunder trade G Nate Robinson, C Etan Thomas, and their 1st round draft pick to Atlanta for F Josh Smith and C Zaza Pachulia.
                            (I don't know about this one. I think Atlanta's getting a little slated since Zaza is better than Etan. Nate probably will do ok backing up Hinrich, and they do get a draft pick, so it may work...I don't know.)

                            Also in the offseason I'm probably gonna trade Lamar Odom and possibly Ron Artest and my 1st and 2nd round draft pick to the Sixers for Andre Iguodala and possibly Jrue Holiday or Mareese Speights.

                            So what you guys think.
                            Last edited by dray8theman; 06-27-2011, 09:09 AM.
                            USC Trojans - Greatest Football Program
                            *2004* USC Trojans - Greatest College Football TeamReggie Bush is innocent...ha ha yeah right!! :)
                            "If it doesn't matter who wins then why do they keep score"

                            Comment

                            • dray8theman
                              Rookie
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 34

                              #1559
                              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                              To Rhyster95

                              Why do you have Josh Smith and Lamarcus Aldridge on the same team? They play the same position. Just a suggestion it'd be better to keep only one of them and trade to better your bench. That's like having Deron Williams and Chris Paul on the same team.
                              USC Trojans - Greatest Football Program
                              *2004* USC Trojans - Greatest College Football TeamReggie Bush is innocent...ha ha yeah right!! :)
                              "If it doesn't matter who wins then why do they keep score"

                              Comment

                              • Suntan Superman
                                ****
                                • Feb 2009
                                • 7135

                                #1560
                                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                                Ok, time to brain digest some trade SNAFU lol I'll try to be clear and concise.
                                Originally posted by Biistli
                                Nobody has noticed, so I how to quote my own post. What do you guys think, was this realistic? You gotta now that J-Rich had contract year so Knicks get 15M + free salary cap from J-Rich´s contract and of course Billups contract. So now they can build all up to Melo cos they got so much free cap at summer, maybe they could snap up even better player than STAT.
                                If the Knicks were ever in a position to get rid of Amare for whatever reason, this isn't a horrible trade, I'm not sure on that being a realistic scenario though especially since the only player I'd really replace Amare with in the next few FA's is Dwight Howard and you're keeping him.

                                They could do better in terms of getting more long-term assets(young players), but I suppose cap room isn't always the worst thing to get.
                                Originally posted by Rhyster95
                                If you want to see My Lineup, Just Ask:

                                Blazers Recieve:
                                PG Boogie Gibson

                                Cavs Recieve:
                                1st Round Pick
                                Trade 2:
                                Blazers Recieve:
                                K.Korver
                                1st Round Pick
                                Bulls Recieve:
                                N.Batum
                                I don't even know why you would want to do these trades.

                                Originally posted by Cairns_baller
                                For my current association:

                                Magic (me) trade : Jameer Nelson and JJ Reddick

                                Atlanta trade: Josh Smith

                                Or

                                Magic (me) trade: Gilbert Arenas and Hedo

                                Atlanta Trade: Josh Smith

                                Which trade is more realistic, i think it's the first but wanted some more opinions. Howard is gone, so trying to get Smith as the new face of the franchise. Given the rumors that he is being shopped around I think it's realistic. Opinions?
                                Well it would depend on the Hawks thinking, I mean first of all the question in my mind would be, would two inter-division rivals trade star players(I consider Smith a star, not a superstar, but still a very good player), and if they were what would the other teams demands be. I mean if I'm the Hawks getting rid of Josh Smith only benefits me if I'm getting someone to replace him, and fill another hole on the roster. I'm not sure Hinrich counts as a hole at PG, so Arenas/Nelson doesn't help them much, and my issue with the second trade is that the Hawks would take on TWO horrendous, albatross contracts, that wouldn't make them terribly better. Perhaps if you threw in Orton and picks, I can see it.

                                Originally posted by Cairns_baller
                                I'm basically rebuilding after Howards departure to the Lakers. I did a 3 team trade which may not be 100% realistic but I created it on the basis that Howard and CP3 demanded trades from their teams (eg. Carmelo)

                                Magic trade: Howard and Arenas

                                Magic recieve: P Gasol, Okafor, Caracter

                                Lakers trade: P Gasol, Bynum, Artest and Caracter

                                Lakers receive: CP3, D12, Trevor Ariza

                                Hornets trade: CP3, Ariza, Okafor

                                Hornets receive: Arenas, Artest and Bynum

                                I have put this up earlier on a different association, I know it's probably unrealistic but as I said I based on the fact that they demanded a trade. Its a hell of a deal for LA, but makes me enjoy the game more trying to beat them.
                                The confusing parts of this trade is Ariza back to LA, and personally if I'm Orlando, I want Bynum in return, not Gasol, I'm not sure on cap figures, but I think I'll try a three-team trade see if I can figure out something that is more beneficial to the teams giving up the superstars

                                Originally posted by Cairns_baller
                                As I said I'm rebuilding the Magic post D12 era, I'm hoping to model the team after the Thunder side. Hoping I can land Josh Smith as the face of the franchise with the trades I put up earlier, however I'm wondering whether Okafor and Orton is a better offer. Okafor would allow Horford to return to centre and Orton is a better prospect then what the Hawks have at SF or PF.
                                Personally, I'd rather have Horford at PF, and Orton is a decent developmental project, so my personal opinion, especially in re-build mode is use Orton, because Okafor declines quickly.


                                Originally posted by Cairns_baller
                                I'm undecided on Pau Gasol, my first though it to get Marc from Memphis and reunite them but then again I wouldn't mind a younger PF such as Jefferson or Thomas.

                                It's going to be a fire sale and pretty much no one is untouchable, I know it's also very unrealistic for teams to completely rebuild their roster but hey this is a video game after all.

                                I'm interested in getting Lou Williams from Philly. Don't know how realistic the move would be but they have Holiday their who i think may be a little better. The move would give Williams the chance to start. I don't know who I could trade for him though..maybe JJ Redick is a even trade. I will sign Iverson as a back - up, last chance kind of deal.
                                I think Philly would deal Lou Williams in a heartbeat if given the right offer, it doesn't even have to be a stellar offer, just one that would potentially fill a need, and add to potential players. Reuniting the Gasol brothers is fun, but really if you have two slashers, because you get a nice inside-out game with guys driving and dishing to either Gasol in the high post.

                                Originally posted by Cairns_baller
                                Monta Ellis is another high priority and given the rumours I don't think it's that far fetched. Brendan Bass and Richardson might be good enough to get him, GS can better defensively at the guard position however they do get older. Bass is a slight upgrade at Center for GS in my opinion.
                                Again, I think they'd want a prospect as well, Ellis is arguably one of the better shot-creators(even if it takes all 24 seconds of the shot clock) in the league, and Rich/Bass seems a little light. Prospect or pick added, and it's not bad.

                                Originally posted by Cairns_baller
                                Role playing targets include T-Mac, Sessions, Sean Williams (FA), Sean May (FA) and R Lopez.

                                Any opinions? Is reuniting the Gasol brothers a good move for the Magic?
                                TMac always wants too much money. I love Sessions and Lopez off the bench though, two phenomenal players off the bench.(READ: OFF THE BENCH)
                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                I'm running a 30 team Association. It's my first time doing this and I gotta say it's a lot of fun. I have so much control it's great. Anyway I am at the trade deadline and I've made some trades, some of them are sort of questionable, but I can see them all happening in RL except for one and I'll let you know which one. Just let me know what you guys think.

                                Also I don't know if I have to differentiate between 2k10 and 2k11, but this is my 2k10 Association with updated rosters.

                                Minor Trades
                                The Detroit Pistons trade G Tracy McGrady to Miami for F Udonis Haslem.
                                (This is the trade I don't really see happening in real life. I don't believe the Heat would ever trade Haslem, especially not for a declining wing player.)

                                Much like you say irl, I don't see this happening, not enough benefit for the Heat vs Cost. I'd hardly see the Pistons doing this even if they get the best player in the trade

                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                The Golden State Warriors trade G Jerry Stackhouse to Dallas for F Shawne Williams.
                                (Jerry is old and probably has only one year left. Shawne Williams is a good prospect forward.)

                                I.. uhh.. I... uhh, don't know what to even say. I'm not sure I've ever seen Shawne Williams and good forward prospect together, at least not since draft day. lol.
                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                The Denver Nuggets trade G Raymond Felton to Portland for Andre Miller.
                                (This trade actually happened in real life, so )

                                (Shhh, but there were more moving parts in the deal too )

                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                The Sacramento Kings trade G Rashad McCants to Minnesota for their current 1st round draft pick.

                                I have so many issues with this trade, first off, McCants isn't worth a first round pick and Minnesota of all teams would know that. Unless Minnesota is beast, that first round pick is likely to be a high overall pick, and well, I just don't even.

                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                Major Trades
                                3 Team trade involving the Bobcats, the Celtics, and the Trailblazers.

                                The Bobcats receive: G Delonte West (BOS) and C Greg Oden (POR)

                                The Trailblazers receive: C Jermaine O'Neal (BOS)

                                The Celtics receive: F Stephen Jackson (CHA) and G Raja Bell (CHA)
                                Also in the game the rumor mill has Rondo being traded. That's ridiculous.

                                Not terrible, Not sure how SJax would like coming off the bench though, I wouldn't see the TBlazers trading Oden unless they got a decent young big in return(ala Roy Hibbert)

                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                The Chicago Bulls trade F Carlos Boozer to Golden State for G Monta Ellis.
                                (I moved Ellis to the two guard position and have him and Rose on the floor at the same time. They are turning out to be the best backcourt in the league. Since he's been traded the Bulls have won 7 in a row and 9 of the last 10 now standing at 29-23)

                                Great trade for the Bulls, not so much for the Warriors, They need more for Ellis, especially if they're still stacked at the 4 with David Lee, Ekpe Udoh and having Louis Amundson as a bench player

                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                The Oklahoma City Thunder trade G Nate Robinson, C Etan Thomas, and their 1st round draft pick to Atlanta for F Josh Smith and C Zaza Pachulia.
                                (I don't know about this one. I think Atlanta's getting a little slated since Zaza is better than Etan. Nate probably will do ok backing up Hinrich, and they do get a draft pick, so it may work...I don't know.)

                                I just have issues with this trade, I can't point them out because it's all in my gut. Josh Smith just doesn't seem like an OKC guy. Not too mention Zaza is way more valuable than Etan Thomas at this point. Zaza is a great energy/glue guy off the bench IRL. I just can't see this happening. In terms of value it's not like it's lopsided it's just well... yeah.

                                Originally posted by dray8theman
                                Also in the offseason I'm probably gonna trade Lamar Odom and possibly Ron Artest and my 1st and 2nd round draft pick to the Sixers for Andre Iguodala and possibly Jrue Holiday or Mareese Speights.

                                So what you guys think.
                                I can see getting Iggy/Holiday for Artest/Odom/1st/1st. I don't know why, and maybe it's just in my head but I swear I read somewhere that Philly likes Speights. If they still have Lou I can see them parting with one of Holiday/Williams.
                                Support Local Sports

                                Comment

                                Working...