The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Houndy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Even though the Mavs got 4 draft picks, they would never do this trade

Pleas help just re did and really took a deep look into the trade. I'm the Sonics

Sonics get;
Dirk
Novak
12' 2nd round pick

Kings get:
Marvin williams
11' 2nd round pick hawks
11' 2nd round pick mavs

Mavs get:
Caral Landry
John Thompsom
11 1st round pick kings
11 1st round pick celtics
11 2nd round pick kings
11 2nd round pick nuggets

would really like some input

[ROABS]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Blockbuster trade i made yesterday with my Knicks association

Knicks trade:
Raymond Felton
Roger Mason
Ronny Turiaf
11' 1st round

Wolves trade:
Kevin Love
Darko Milicic
Lazar Hayward

knicks win that deal by far.. doubt the wolves would move him that cheap.

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

knicks win that deal by far.. doubt the wolves would move him that cheap.

Yeah, i win, wolves wouldn't move love that easily, as it is there best player, i needed some big men, because a lot of big man are injured in my team

Now my lineup looks like this

PG: Stephen Curry (injured, he needs to play because, i have no backup pg)
SG: Landry Fields
SF: Carmelo Anthony
PF: Amare (injured)
C: Kevin Love

Bench
Marcus Thornton
Thabo Sefolosha
Wilson Chandler
Lazar Hayward
Serge Ibaka
Darko Milicic
Anthony Randolph.

[knicksfan8]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Started a Cavs franchise, looking to rebuild. Made one big trade so far:

Thunder get: Antawn Jamison, Joey Graham, Leon Powe, 2012 1st round pick
Cavs get: Serge Ibaka, Morris Peterson, Nenad Kristic

Main reasons for this trade for me was to get rid of cap and I wanted Ibaka. Thoughts? Suggestions?

Also, should I do one of these trades? ( Main purpose is to free up cap space) Any others in mind?
Mo Williams, Anderson Varejao, and 2011 2nd round pick for Greg Oden and Joel Pryzbilla.
Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao for Troy Murphy and Damion James.
Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao for Rodrigue Beaubois and Tyson Chandler.
Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao for Michael Redd and Chris Douglas-Roberts

[LHSLax_D24]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Took someone's advice. In my 30 team Association, Richard Jefferson went down for the year 6 games in.

<b>Spurs</b> get:
<font size="1">G/F</font> Tracy McGrady
<font size="1">F/C</font> Chris Wilcox

<b>Pistons</b> get:
<font size="1">F/C</font> Matt Bonner

The Spurs need a wingplayer and McGrady (nor Wilcox) were playing in Detroit. Wilcox was getting more frustrated than McGrady.

[Houndy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Took someone's advice. In my 30 team Association, Richard Jefferson went down for the year 6 games in.

<b>Spurs</b> get:
<font size="1">G/F</font> Tracy McGrady
<font size="1">F/C</font> Chris Wilcox

<b>Pistons</b> get:
<font size="1">F/C</font> Matt Bonner

The Spurs need a wingplayer and McGrady (nor Wilcox) were playing in Detroit. Wilcox was getting more frustrated than McGrady.

Like it, makes sense

[tteeebooooow]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Started a Cavs franchise, looking to rebuild. Made one big trade so far:

Thunder get: Antawn Jamison, Joey Graham, Leon Powe, 2012 1st round pick
Cavs get: Serge Ibaka, Morris Peterson, Nenad Kristic

Main reasons for this trade for me was to get rid of cap and I wanted Ibaka. Thoughts? Suggestions?

Also, should I do one of these trades? ( Main purpose is to free up cap space) Any others in mind?
Mo Williams, Anderson Varejao, and 2011 2nd round pick for Greg Oden and Joel Pryzbilla.
Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao for Troy Murphy and Damion James.
Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao for Rodrigue Beaubois and Tyson Chandler.
Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao for Michael Redd and Chris Douglas-Roberts

i like the greg oden trade or the chandler trade the best. im doing a cavs franchise too and im also looking to trade mo williams.
but so far i trade antwan jamison and jawad williams for azibuike and curry then i traded joey graham and eyenga for chris duhon. Duhon is out performing Mo so im trying to trade him for good value and i might do the oden or chandler trade thanks for the idea lol

[Happy29]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm using the Bulls and have Jordan, Pippen, Rodman, and Armstrong from the 92 team on my roster. Noah went down and I needed a big man so I used the trade finder with Rodman being the main part of the trade. I was offered Bynum and a 2012 2nd round pick for Rodman and Armstrong. I thought it was a okay deal.

[eye guy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

This is weird, let me start with my starting lineup...

pg. Miller - 74
sg. Roy - 93
sf. G. Wallace - 86
pf. J. Smith - 86
c. Hibbert - 78

I'm in the middle of the '11 - '12 season and the Lakers offered me Kobe for Roy and my first round rookie pg (rating - 69, potential 93). I haven't accepted it yet, and I know it's unrealistic and some will jump at it, but Kobe (as good as he'll continue to stay) is aging. I really want to keep Roy until he retires but this is tempting. My rookie pg has a positive upside with comparisons to JKidd before I drafted him so he'd be a big loss in the next 2 years considering Miller decides to stick around.

Suggestions?

Note: I traded for Wallace before the start of my first season, and acquired Smith for Oden and Aldridge before the trade deadline. As of right now, Oden although healthy is only averaging 6ppg with 6rpg., Aldridge is averaging 17ppg and 8rpg both are still with the Hawks.

Smith is getting better as a big-man, but I originally wanted him because he had a better upside defensively than Aldrige who's averaging 1.8bpg...

[THE POLISH HAMMER]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I wouldn't do it. there's not a huge drop-off from Kobe to Roy, and Miller will almost assuredly retire after your current season (he retired after my first season).

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Yepp, don't do it, Kobe will retire in the next season or 2

[ROABS]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

i wouldnt trade for kobe if you have a young up and coming guard and brandon roy. would stink to see kobe retire then a year later your old guard being the top guard in the league lol..

[Houndy]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Dont do it, keep a young nucleus

[con100]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I made a few trades and they looked good at the time. What do you guys think? I'm the Cavs to let you guys know.
Trade 1:
Me: Mo Williams, Antawn Jamison, Ramon Sessions, 2012 1st round pick
Nets: Devin Harris, Troy Murphy, Jordon Farmar, Travis Outlaw
Trade 2:
Me: Anthony Parker, 2011 1st round pick, Ryan Hollins
Knicks: Kelenna Azubuike, Shawne Williams
Trade 3:
Me: Jawad Williams
Clippers: Jarron Collins
Trade 4:
Me: Troy Murphy, JJ Hickson, Christian Eyenga
Nuggets: Nene, Shelden Williams, Arron Affalo

Heres my starting lineup after the trades. The only original player in the lineup that wasn't traded is Powe.
PG: Devin Harris
SG: Arron Affalo
SF: Travis Outlaw
PF: Leon Powe
C: Nene

I got Nene and Azubuike because I had them in my 2k10 association and played pretty good with them. Trade 3 was a mistake I somehow selected the wrong player and didn't pay attention and they accepted the trade right away.

[knicksfan8]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

i like the greg oden trade or the chandler trade the best. im doing a cavs franchise too and im also looking to trade mo williams.
but so far i trade antwan jamison and jawad williams for azibuike and curry then i traded joey graham and eyenga for chris duhon. Duhon is out performing Mo so im trying to trade him for good value and i might do the oden or chandler trade thanks for the idea lol

Thanks for the feedback, I liked those two trades as well. I'm still not sure which one I'm going to take. Anybody have any other Cavs franchise moves? And by the way, I got that trade offer by putting Mo Williams and Anderson Varejao in the trade finder, just to let you know. Theres also trades available for bigger players (ex. Gerald Wallace, Kevin Garnett, Zach Randolph, Gilbert Arenas, Chauncey Billups, Tony Parker, and others ) but im looking to sign Melo so I need to get big salaries off of the team.