The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[MIWOLVERINE]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

IMO you got robbed. i'm pretty sure you could have got more for those 2 players and a 1st round pick. i know with barnes if you give him around 21 or 22 minutes a game he is happy and brown no matter if you make him happy still tries FA.

I dont think so..i didnt use trade finder..i wanted harangody and parker
i gave up the 1st round pick becuase i knew i wouldnt need it..there wouldnt be any caps space to sign a first rounder anyway

[thedukejr]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I dont think so..i didnt use trade finder..i wanted harangody and parker
i gave up the 1st round pick becuase i knew i wouldnt need it..there wouldnt be any caps space to sign a first rounder anyway

i have simmed my association 3 times and parker retires at the end of the season 2 out of 3 times. also brown and barnes have been really good for me. barnes rebounds, plays killer defense and can also score. brown plays good defense, can score especially now that his shooting improved, and can play PG. that's why i think you were robbed. also you don't need cap space to sign your picks. you just need to be under the hard cap.

[sgt pepper]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I need to know if this 3 way deal is fair.

Boston gets:
Montae Ellis(85 ovr)
Wesley Matthews(74 ovr)
Marcus Camby(76 ovr)

Golden State gets:
Gerald Wallace(81 ovr)
Greg Oden(74 ovr)

Portland gets:
Kevin Garnett(83 ovr)
Paul Pierce(82 ovr)
Charlie Bell(66 ovr)

I'm afraid the Warriors are getting jobbed a li'l bit here. I want it to be as realistic as possible .

[tteeebooooow]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I need to know if this 3 way deal is fair.

Boston gets:
Montae Ellis(85 ovr)
Wesley Matthews(74 ovr)
Marcus Camby(76 ovr)

Golden State gets:
Gerald Wallace(81 ovr)
Greg Oden(74 ovr)

Portland gets:
Kevin Garnett(83 ovr)
Paul Pierce(82 ovr)
Charlie Bell(66 ovr)

I'm afraid the Warriors are getting jobbed a li'l bit here. I want it to be as realistic as possible .

I assume you are the Celtics but I believe in this trade both the Blazers and the Warriors are getting ripped off. You are giving up an aging Garnett and and aging Pierce. The Blazers are giving up a Oden who even though he hasn't lived up to expectation is young and still can be the cornerstone of the franchise and they are getting two old players in return. The Warriors are giving up one of the best scorers in the league for a not so good Gerald Wallace and an unproven player. While the trade looks good for you IMO I don't find this trade realistic at all.

[Nabz]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

loser is clearly warriors in that trade, celtics BIG win in this trade for future too. Portland meh not that much of a win

[rc1882]

I was thinking of starting an assosciation w/ the lakers and starting off with these trades

Odom/bynum to minnesota for beasley/love/2nd rounder

Artest to 76ers for louis williams

Caracter/walton/2nd rounder to rockets for thabeet/carrol

Which sets the lineups this way

Williams/blake/fish
Kobe/brown
Beasley/barnes/ebanks
Love/gasol
Gasol/thabeet

I know if I was the sixers or minnesota, I wouldn't touch the trades, but forget it, its not real life. What do you think of the new look lakers?

[Magic642]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I was thinking that David Lee won't progress as far as his potential rating says (A), so I put him in the trade finder and got Kevin Love (B+ potential) and Luke Walton in return.

[thaprodigyisback]

Made this trade in my association w/ the Nets is it fair?

Nets (me) Get:
Roy Hibbert
Paul George

Pacers Get:
Brook Lopez
Quinton Ross

[SuperNoVa27]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Which of these would be more realistic

Chi-Town Receives
J.R. Smith 75 Ovr
Timofey Mozgov 63 Ovr

Denver Receives
Joakim Noah 81 Ovr
Ronnie Brewer 71 Ovr

or

Chi-Town Recieves
Wes Johnson 72 Ovr
Darko Milicic 69 Ovr

Minnesota Recieves
Joakim Noah 81 Ovr
Ronnie Brewer 71 Ovr

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Which of these would be more realistic

Chi-Town Receives
J.R. Smith 75 Ovr
Timofey Mozgov 63 Ovr

Denver Receives
Joakim Noah 81 Ovr
Ronnie Brewer 71 Ovr

or

Chi-Town Recieves
Wes Johnson 72 Ovr
Darko Milicic 69 Ovr

Minnesota Recieves
Joakim Noah 81 Ovr
Ronnie Brewer 71 Ovr

You definitely cannot give up Joakim Noah, him and DRose are franchise players, Noah is a beast defensively although he doesn't produce much offensively but you can still use him as a pick n roll option

[SuperNoVa27]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

All Noah does for me is get rebounds and fouls, he cant make a bucket even when he is wide open, Plus he is an *** in real life.

[SMK121]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So I'm the Knicks (default rosters) and I'm trying to get CP3. Is this a realistic trade?

Knicks receive:

Chris Paul (9? Ovr)
Marcus Thornton (69 Ovr)
Sean Marks (59 Ovr)

Hornets receive:

Kelenna Azabuike (72 Ovr)
Raymond Felton (71 Ovr)
Eddy Curry (6? Ovr)
2011 1st round pick


I had to include Curry, since I assume in real life the Hornets may like that expiring contract. Assuming CP still wants out, I don't see what else the Hornets can do. They get a decent wingman in Azabuike, and a replacement for Paul in Felton. I'm hoping for my sake that the 1st round pick won't be in the lottery. The only thing the Hornets give up who still wants to be there is Thornton. He has a A- potential if I remember correctly. That would be a steal for me, since he would gradually improve to be better then Azabuike.

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So I'm the Knicks (default rosters) and I'm trying to get CP3. Is this a realistic trade?

Knicks receive:

Chris Paul (9? Ovr)
Marcus Thornton (69 Ovr)
Sean Marks (59 Ovr)

Hornets receive:

Kelenna Azabuike (72 Ovr)
Raymond Felton (71 Ovr)
Eddy Curry (6? Ovr)
2011 1st round pick


I had to include Curry, since I assume in real life the Hornets may like that expiring contract. Assuming CP still wants out, I don't see what else the Hornets can do. They get a decent wingman in Azabuike, and a replacement for Paul in Felton. I'm hoping for my sake that the 1st round pick won't be in the lottery. The only thing the Hornets give up who still wants to be there is Thornton. He has a A- potential if I remember correctly. That would be a steal for me, since he would gradually improve to be better then Azabuike.

Not a fair trade at all, you cannot get CP3 in 2k11 unless there are more trade slots. you either have to give up amare or something

[Raider131]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

So I'm the Knicks (default rosters) and I'm trying to get CP3. Is this a realistic trade?

Knicks receive:

Chris Paul (9? Ovr)
Marcus Thornton (69 Ovr)
Sean Marks (59 Ovr)

Hornets receive:

Kelenna Azabuike (72 Ovr)
Raymond Felton (71 Ovr)
Eddy Curry (6? Ovr)
2011 1st round pick


I had to include Curry, since I assume in real life the Hornets may like that expiring contract. Assuming CP still wants out, I don't see what else the Hornets can do. They get a decent wingman in Azabuike, and a replacement for Paul in Felton. I'm hoping for my sake that the 1st round pick won't be in the lottery. The only thing the Hornets give up who still wants to be there is Thornton. He has a A- potential if I remember correctly. That would be a steal for me, since he would gradually improve to be better then Azabuike.

This is kinda like when the Grizzlies gave up Pau Gasol for absolutely nothing so could it happen? Yeah I guess it could, but at least leave them Marcus Thornton

[UndeniableSkillz9]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

year 2 playing player lock with mcgee from the wizards i picked up (requested) lamar odom, damon jones, mills, nenad kristic, landry fields all in free agency

ronnie brewer from free agency trade with bulls for 2nd round sf

traded damion jones and 2nd round pick '13 for omri casspi 2nd round pick '13

traded ronnie brewer for tyler hansbrough

received michael beasley, 2nd round pf, '13 2nd round pick for landry fields and 1st round pick pf

traded lamar odoms and '13 2nd round pick for kings '12 1st round pick and Beno Udrih

so my lineup is

john wall- beno udrih-patrick mills
nick young- Jordan crawford
Michael beasley- omri casspi
rookie pf-taylor hansbrough-rookie pf
McGee-Kristic

i'm pretty happy with this team so i'm keep it the same unless the cpu makes adjustments

since i'm playing player lock on mcgee i let the cpu do mostly everything

I only training Mcgee with the seven points might train others.

Made the trades myself since I got McGee playing like Howard so since it's not myplayer and they don't ask for trades in association.

Just got hurt for two weeks with McGee so simulated until I'm back in action