The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I don't like that deal for the Raptors or Lakers, a steal for the Magic though.

The Raptors trade good young talent that they are developing for two decent veterans who they don't need since they aren't contending.

The Lakers are contending, yet they send a extremely versatile and talented veteran forward for a decent veteran point guard when they already have two good point guard's, and add 3 young guys to a roster that wants to win now.

Good trade for the Magic though, they send two decent, at best, players for a talented power forward like Lamar Odom.

In summary, the deal just doesn't make much sense all around, but if you like the trade that's all that matters.

Because Fisher ain't happy, and hes old, Blake is old, but getting Calderon who is better than both of them will be solid, he is also a half court set pg and also spanish which is great to work with Gasol, i am sure Calderon is very happy going there finallly playing for a team that can win championship~ Barg is like a younger but better version of Odom, him and gasol's front court seems pretty solid and barg is like second leading scorer in my asssocation and he willl be in the allstar game while bynum isn't doing too well never get a chance to show he can be a 20, 10 guy so yeah, good for both centers, and lakers just need to get younger fresher, ed davis is someone they love and want all along, so is bayless~

[Shield]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Main reason is I don't want to play with Barg anymore, hes very good in the game, much much better in real life he never misses a midrange nor 3pt shot, but I am so bored of running his plays, so I want to trade him for a big, and Bynum is the one I want because of his trade value, he is like the second most valuable center in the league after Dwight Howard....and I need to upgrade the PG, but most likely I am going to draft a superstar rookie PG and trade Nelson in the off-season, but the trade makes a lot of sense for Orlando, maybeee Lakers~

Did i miss something? Was Bynum included in this trade?

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Did i miss something? Was Bynum included in this trade?

Yesss he isss

[Shield]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Yesss he isss

OK, you forgot him in your original post, just checkin'

[Brew]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Did i miss something? Was Bynum included in this trade?

Yesss he isss

Bynum makes it a little better for the Raptors but I dont think the Lakers want to have 4 PGs in Blake, Fisher, Bayless, and Calderon.
Also, with Bynum's durability concerns I'd much rather keep Bargnani who is a huge threat on 2k and a young talent in Ed Davis who could develop into a very solid player at the 4 spot.

If Bynum didnt have injury concerns and could stay on the court than I think its a decent trade for the Raptors.

Its your assoc. so have fun and do what you like!.. this is just my opinion.

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

OK, you forgot him in your original post, just checkin'

Oppps sorry!!!

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Bynum makes it a little better for the Raptors but I dont think the Lakers want to have 4 PGs in Blake, Fisher, Bayless, and Calderon.
Also, with Bynum's durability concerns I'd much rather keep Bargnani who is a huge threat on 2k and a young talent in Ed Davis who could develop into a very solid player at the 4 spot.

If Bynum didnt have injury concerns and could stay on the court than I think its a decent trade for the Raptors.

Its your assoc. so have fun and do what you like!.. this is just my opinion.

Yea I just dont' want Barg because I played with him the most ever since I got the game, so yeah wanna try using someone new, and I like Bynum and I also think he has won enough rings already now, he needs to show what he can do himself more, a 20-10 guy every night isn't hard for him, so raptors is the place where he can do that~ and yea I love Davis man, but Amir is doing great for me, so I wanna develop him instead, and also Lakers always trade away Blake or Fisher, so I see them making a move before the deadline, but I have to say, Magic's line up is soooo good now after this trade, Arenas, Rich, Turk, Odom, Dwight, they are back to having a 4 man that can do everything on the court like Lewis, but he has a way better contract...and I also like Ryan Anderson, he should work well with Bynum for me...

[Brew]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Yea I just dont' want Barg because I played with him the most ever since I got the game, so yeah wanna try using someone new, and I like Bynum and I also think he has won enough rings already now, he needs to show what he can do himself more, a 20-10 guy every night isn't hard for him, so raptors is the place where he can do that~ and yea I love Davis man, but Amir is doing great for me, so I wanna develop him instead, and also Lakers always trade away Blake or Fisher, so I see them making a move before the deadline, but I have to say, Magic's line up is soooo good now after this trade, Arenas, Rich, Turk, Odom, Dwight, they are back to having a 4 man that can do everything on the court like Lewis, but he has a way better contract...and I also like Ryan Anderson, he should work well with Bynum for me...

I cant play with players I dont want to either... exactly why I stopped my Bucks chise to start a different one... didnt like Jennings and Bogut is too fragile. Calderon is definitely an upgrade for the Lakers at PG and that Magic lineup looks really good. Ryan Anderson is a fun player to watch IRL... I love his work ethic... he isnt the fastest strongest or the biggest but gets the job done and has great range for his size. Good luck on your 'chise!

[MagicSuns]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I made these two deadline deals with my Magic Association:

-Chris Duhon to the Spurs for Tiago Splitter and a 2011 2nd round pick
-Quentin Richardson & Malik Allen & Jason Williams to the Kings for Omri Casspi, Luther Head & Darnell Jackson

My lineup:
PG: Nelson, Arenas, Head
SG: Richardson, Redick
SF: Turkoglu, Casspi, Clark
PF: Bass, Anderson, Jackson
C: Howard, Splitter, Orton

[petersondagreat]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

what do you think about trading Igoudala and tony battie to the wizards for josh howard and Andray Blatche BTW i have the pistons roster minus rip and Charlie V

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I made these two deadline deals with my Magic Association:

-Chris Duhon to the Spurs for Tiago Splitter and a 2011 2nd round pick
-Quentin Richardson & Malik Allen & Jason Williams to the Kings for Omri Casspi, Luther Head & Darnell Jackson

My lineup:
PG: Nelson, Arenas, Head
SG: Richardson, Redick
SF: Turkoglu, Casspi, Clark
PF: Bass, Anderson, Jackson
C: Howard, Splitter, Orton

Just very small trades I see you did there, umm for some reason 2k thinks Orton will be a great great player he has 4 stars in trade value so I don't think Spiltter will be needed, and Casspi is a shooting big you already have Anderson, no need~ but gettin rid of Duhan is good, though hes a great on-ball defender, but his contract doesn't look too good I rmb, so yea, not much you did in these moves~

[Brew]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I made these two deadline deals with my Magic Association:

-Chris Duhon to the Spurs for Tiago Splitter and a 2011 2nd round pick
-Quentin Richardson & Malik Allen & Jason Williams to the Kings for Omri Casspi, Luther Head & Darnell Jackson

My lineup:
PG: Nelson, Arenas, Head
SG: Richardson, Redick
SF: Turkoglu, Casspi, Clark
PF: Bass, Anderson, Jackson
C: Howard, Splitter, Orton

Both trades are really good for the Magic... though I doubt the Spurs would really go for that especially giving up the pick with it.
I cant believe Orton has the trade value that he does...
It baffles me that a guy like Orton has 3-4 star trade value but a guy like DeAndre Jordan only is a 1-2 star. Gotta love Living Rosters!
Like that you didnt blow the team up... something I have a tendency to do and ultimately regret!

[AgaliareptX]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Miami (Me) trades:
Zydrunas Ilgauskas
Joel Anthony
2011 1st Round Pick
2012 2nd Round Pick

for

Celtics (CPU) trades:
Kendrick Perkins
Luke Harangody
2011 2nd Round Pick

Also want to point out that the Celtics fell under the problem of having too many good players. Perk was behind both O'Neals on the roster and wasn't happy being a role player or whatever, so maybe that's why he was easier to pick up. Overall was way down.

[LastPoet]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Is this trade realistic? My 2011 Hawks had just won the Championship, and the Nets had the #1 pick. Draft starts, they offer:

#1 Pick
Travis Outlaw

for

Josh Smith
Mike Bibby

It seems really unrealistic to me. What do you think?

Miami (Me) trades:
Zydrunas Ilgauskas
Joel Anthony
2011 1st Round Pick
2012 2nd Round Pick

for

Celtics (CPU) trades:
Kendrick Perkins
Luke Harangody
2011 2nd Round Pick

Also want to point out that the Celtics fell under the problem of having too many good players. Perk was behind both O'Neals on the roster and wasn't happy being a role player or whatever, so maybe that's why he was easier to pick up. Overall was way down.

Seems reasonable, since you're giving up 2 draft picks and Anthony. I dunno if I'd wanna give up so many draft picks, and the CPU was always killing me with Z, but not crazy.

[gottibino]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

-LAC (cpu) offered Blake Griffin & Eric Gordon for
....ready....
-LAL (me) Lamar Odom & Shannon Brown!!!! str8 up, no picks!

Due to my integrity for the realism & authenticity of this game, I gracefully declined. This trade made absolutely NO sense for the cpu Clips in any way, shape or form. str8 up RIDICULOUS!!! SMH @ 2k!!!