The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[thaprodigyisback]

Jennings always goes on to average a consistent 28 over his career in my 2k11 seasons... he averaged 35.8 ppg one year

[matthewj]

I wouldn't say jennings has regressed. Injuries slowed him down and it seems like he is having a sophmore slump. He still shows lots of potential. This trade wouldn't happen because the clippers already have a pg of the future in bledsoe.

I dunno though cause I see alot of potential in Bledsoe but I dunno how good he can really be. He sometimes looks like he just doesn't belong at the point. If they could get a PG they would probably be very willing its giving up Griffin that would ruin it.

Irl could you imagine a guy like Nash or Paul paired with Griffin...that'd be so dirty.

[Steven123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Griffin is by far one of the most untouchable NBA players right now.

[matthewj]

Alright I came up with this win now trade

R. Hamilton, T. Prince, W. Bynum

For

B. Davis and C. Kaman

I like the post scoring from Kaman need a passing guard in Davis and want to play Stuckey at the 2

LA gets 11 mil off their books. A good 6th man for them in Hamilton and Bynum to hold over the PG spot till Bledsoe develops a little more.

Thoughts?

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Alright I came up with this win now trade

R. Hamilton, T. Prince, W. Bynum

For

B. Davis and C. Kaman

I like the post scoring from Kaman need a passing guard in Davis and want to play Stuckey at the 2

LA gets 11 mil off their books. A good 6th man for them in Hamilton and Bynum to hold over the PG spot till Bledsoe develops a little more.

Thoughts?

Give the Clippers a first round pick as well and I'd say it's fair. Only reason I say that is Baron Davis is playing pretty well right now and Chris Kaman is a top 5 center. Other than that good enough for me.

[romaldinho]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im the Knicks and i was just seeing what id have to give up for Carmelo in a matter of interest because i think im going to sign him in FA.
This is the best deal i came up with.

Knicks trade
Eddy Curry-warriors
Wilson Chandler-warriors
Anthony randolph-nuggets
1st rd 2011-nuggets
1st rd 2012-warriors

Nuggets trade
Carmelo Anthony-knicks
Renaldo Balkman-warriors

Warriors trade
Monta Ellis-Nuggets

I mite do this before the deadline il see but do you think its a fair trade?

[Shield]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I should give some background first, I'm TOR and needed help up front due to a myriad of injuries to my bigs. Calderon,Odom,Tayshaun were all unhappy customers riding the pine so trades were inevitable. Walton and W.Bynum were fillers. FYI pick from MIL likely to be lottery b/c injuries have derailed them.

TOR trades
Calderon>>>DET
J.Dorsey, MIL '11 1st>>>LAL
TOR '12 1st>>>DET

LAL trades
Odom>>>TOR
Walton>>>DET

DET trades
Prince>>>LAL
W.Bynum>>>TOR

[thedukejr]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I should give some background first, I'm TOR and needed help up front due to a myriad of injuries to my bigs. Calderon,Odom,Tayshaun were all unhappy customers riding the pine so trades were inevitable. Walton and W.Bynum were fillers. FYI pick from MIL likely to be lottery b/c injuries have derailed them.

TOR trades
Calderon>>>DET
J.Dorsey, MIL '11 1st>>>LAL
TOR '12 1st>>>DET

LAL trades
Odom>>>TOR
Walton>>>DET

DET trades
Prince>>>LAL
W.Bynum>>>TOR

it's a fair trade but i don't see the lakers making this trade since they would still have artest, ebanks and barnes at the SF position. so they wouldn't need prince.

[thedukejr]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

since there are talks of howard wanting to join the lakers if the magic don't win. i was looking for fair trades for howard that would include bynum. any suggestions?

[Cod]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Loaded my association this morning and got this offer from New Orleans:

Hawks (me) get: Emeka Okafor, '11 First Round Pick
Hornets get: Josh Smith, Maurice Evans

I didn't accept the trade because I like Smith's style, he's still young, and use him sporadically at SF. Looking back, I probably should have accepted it because I could have moved Horford to the PF, where he's better suited, and picked up a decent SF in the draft (or free agency).

What do y'all think? Did I do the right thing declining or should I have accepted?

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Loaded my association this morning and got this offer from New Orleans:

Hawks (me) get: Emeka Okafor, '11 First Round Pick
Hornets get: Josh Smith, Maurice Evans

I didn't accept the trade because I like Smith's style, he's still young, and use him sporadically at SF. Looking back, I probably should have accepted it because I could have moved Horford to the PF, where he's better suited, and picked up a decent SF in the draft (or free agency).

What do y'all think? Did I do the right thing declining or should I have accepted?

You definitely did the right thing by not accepting it. I cannot stress enough how talented Josh Smith is on the defensive end, and hey, he isn't bad at putting the ball in the bucket either, as well as his above average rebounding ability.

Also, Horford is more suited for center, not power forward. Looking at the numbers, on the defensive end of course, Horford is a top five center in the league defensively. That's why the Hawks have said they have no intention of moving Al Horford to power forward, because he can handle big men down low because of his big body and his intelligence on the defensive end.

Really I don't know why the Hawks aren't better with all of this said, they have two terrific big men and a all-star shooting guard, as well as a great scorer off of the bench, but I digress.

[mushyman167]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Im the Toronto Raptors and Im in my 2nd year. I made one trade in my 1st season which was trading Peja for Antawn Jamison. In the draft, I drafted Kyrie Irving. Now in the start of the season, the Nuggets r rebuilding with no Melo and, Nene and J.R. are unhappy like real life. So this is a trade I came up with since I needed a better backup sg and a center. With this trade, Im planning to move Bargnani to PF so he can be more effective.

Nuggets receive:
Antawn Jamison (expiring)
Barbosa (expiring)
1st round pick 2012 Toronto

Rapters receive:
JR Smith
Nene

[Senator Stone]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Not one particular trade, but curious what you guys think about my roster in year 3. I completely gutted the Cavs roster for prospects and picks.

PG: Mario Chalmers (8ppg, 6apg)
SG: Evan Turner (19ppg, 5rpg, 5apg)
SF: Wesley Johnson (13ppg, 5rpg)
PF: Jared Sullinger (6th pick, 16ppg, 8rpg)
C: Anthony Randolph (12ppg, 6rpg)
6: Michael Redd (signed as FA; 8ppg)
7: Marvin Williams (7ppg)
8: Daniel Gibson (only leftover; 4 ppg)
9: Brandan Wright
10: Tiago Splitter

I think all the trades were fair - I traded Varejao, Sessions and a couple picks for Serge Ibaka, who was an 80 OVR when I ended up trading him for Evan Turner (he was on Indy at the time)

[free7694]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Not one particular trade, but curious what you guys think about my roster in year 3. I completely gutted the Cavs roster for prospects and picks.

PG: Mario Chalmers (8ppg, 6apg)
SG: Evan Turner (19ppg, 5rpg, 5apg)
SF: Wesley Johnson (13ppg, 5rpg)
PF: Jared Sullinger (6th pick, 16ppg, 8rpg)
C: Anthony Randolph (12ppg, 6rpg)
6: Michael Redd (signed as FA; 8ppg)
7: Marvin Williams (7ppg)
8: Daniel Gibson (only leftover; 4 ppg)
9: Brandan Wright
10: Tiago Splitter

I think all the trades were fair - I traded Varejao, Sessions and a couple picks for Serge Ibaka, who was an 80 OVR when I ended up trading him for Evan Turner (he was on Indy at the time)

I'm trying to do the same thing, though I'm only at the start of year 2, here's what I've got:

PG - Ramon Sessions
SG - Kelenna Azubuike (free agent)
SF - Carmelo Anthony (free agent)
PF - J.J. Hickson
C - Anderson Varejao
6 - Chris Douglas-Roberts (free agent)
7 - Perry Jones (#2 overall pick)
8 - Jimmer Fredette (#13 overall pick)
9 - Leon Powe
10 - Daniel Gibson

I basically traded Antawn Jamison and Mo Williams for about $28 million in expiring contracts (Michael Redd, Nazr Mohammed, Kwame Brown) and the Bobcats 1st round pick.

[jonmchugh007]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I just started with the Bulls and I am 1-1 and just got blown out by the freaking Kings. Yah I know I suck at this game lol. I'm looking to get a stud SG. Don't really care about getting rid of Noah but I know that the Bulls would never trade Noah in real life but I need another guy that can help take preasure of of Rose. The only guy I would like to keep is Boozer. Everyone else is expendable.