The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Miami (Me) trades:
Zydrunas Ilgauskas
Joel Anthony
2011 1st Round Pick
2012 2nd Round Pick

for

Celtics (CPU) trades:
Kendrick Perkins
Luke Harangody
2011 2nd Round Pick

Also want to point out that the Celtics fell under the problem of having too many good players. Perk was behind both O'Neals on the roster and wasn't happy being a role player or whatever, so maybe that's why he was easier to pick up. Overall was way down.

I did something along those lines in season one of my Heat season, and made sure after the season to get Perkins back to them. I felt so guilty for taking him away from them, lol. Not a bad trade if he is unhappy though, except maybe another first round pick from you instead of that second rounder. Good luck.

[jrose57]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I cant play with players I dont want to either... exactly why I stopped my Bucks chise to start a different one... didnt like Jennings and Bogut is too fragile. Calderon is definitely an upgrade for the Lakers at PG and that Magic lineup looks really good. Ryan Anderson is a fun player to watch IRL... I love his work ethic... he isnt the fastest strongest or the biggest but gets the job done and has great range for his size. Good luck on your 'chise!

Wow man, can't believe I was 3-11 with Barg being leader, now just played 3 games with Bynum being leader, I am 2-1...Bynum plays both ends of the floor well, he basically control everything happen in the middle, allowing the guards to play up tight because him, amir, and anderson were beast at blocking shots...he just had a season-high game 20 points, 7 rebounds, 2 blocks, 2 assists, and I play 6 min per quarter, Bynum is definitely showing what he can do alone, no more relying on Kobe and Gasol!!!

[LastPoet]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

-LAC (cpu) offered Blake Griffin & Eric Gordon for
....ready....
-LAL (me) Lamar Odom & Shannon Brown!!!! str8 up, no picks!

Due to my integrity for the realism & authenticity of this game, I gracefully declined. This trade made absolutely NO sense for the cpu Clips in any way, shape or form. str8 up RIDICULOUS!!! SMH @ 2k!!!

Don't forget Shannon Brown is like the truth in this game.

[Brew]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Wow man, can't believe I was 3-11 with Barg being leader, now just played 3 games with Bynum being leader, I am 2-1...Bynum plays both ends of the floor well, he basically control everything happen in the middle, allowing the guards to play up tight because him, amir, and anderson were beast at blocking shots...he just had a season-high game 20 points, 7 rebounds, 2 blocks, 2 assists, and I play 6 min per quarter, Bynum is definitely showing what he can do alone, no more relying on Kobe and Gasol!!!

Bynum is top 5 C in the league when healthy.
Good to see its working out for you.

[amac360]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am 10-6 with the Bulls, D Rose is killin averaging just under 30 with 9 assists, Boozer is at about 18 and 9, while Noah is at about 10 and 10. I was messin with trades and the blazers excepted this:

I send:
Carlos Boozer
Joakim Noah
CJ Watson
'12 First Rounder

They send:
Brandon Roy
Greg Oden
Dante Cunningham
'11 First Rounder

Lineup with the trade:

Rose/Watson/Alston (Just signed as FA rated 72)
Brewer/Bogans/Cook
Terrence Williams/Korver
Boozer/Gibson/James Johnson
Noah/Thomas

With trade:

Rose/Alston/Cook
Roy/Brewer/Bogans
Williams/Korver/Cunningham
Gibson/Johnson/Hollins
Oden/Thomas

It is not realistic bc Boozer was just signed and Chicago would never trade Noah, not to mention Roys injury status now. What do you guys think?

[parker987]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am 10-6 with the Bulls, D Rose is killin averaging just under 30 with 9 assists, Boozer is at about 18 and 9, while Noah is at about 10 and 10. I was messin with trades and the blazers excepted this:

I send:
Carlos Boozer
Joakim Noah
CJ Watson
'12 First Rounder

They send:
Brandon Roy
Greg Oden
Dante Cunningham
'11 First Rounder

Lineup with the trade:

Rose/Watson/Alston (Just signed as FA rated 72)
Brewer/Bogans/Cook
Terrence Williams/Korver
Boozer/Gibson/James Johnson
Noah/Thomas

With trade:

Rose/Alston/Cook
Roy/Brewer/Bogans
Williams/Korver/Cunningham
Gibson/Johnson/Hollins
Oden/Thomas

It is not realistic bc Boozer was just signed and Chicago would never trade Noah, not to mention Roys injury status now. What do you guys think?

I don't think its a good trade for ya dude, you have lost 2 great rebounders in return for only Oden who is good at rebounding, but his injury rate is really high also B Roys, I advice you change their durabilty ratings

[thaone08]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I am 10-6 with the Bulls, D Rose is killin averaging just under 30 with 9 assists, Boozer is at about 18 and 9, while Noah is at about 10 and 10. I was messin with trades and the blazers excepted this:

I send:
Carlos Boozer
Joakim Noah
CJ Watson
'12 First Rounder

They send:
Brandon Roy
Greg Oden
Dante Cunningham
'11 First Rounder

Lineup with the trade:

Rose/Watson/Alston (Just signed as FA rated 72)
Brewer/Bogans/Cook
Terrence Williams/Korver
Boozer/Gibson/James Johnson
Noah/Thomas

With trade:

Rose/Alston/Cook
Roy/Brewer/Bogans
Williams/Korver/Cunningham
Gibson/Johnson/Hollins
Oden/Thomas

It is not realistic bc Boozer was just signed and Chicago would never trade Noah, not to mention Roys injury status now. What do you guys think?

umm i could see u trading boozer for like bosh or amare but roy i would have to say no only because u have someone that can do what he can do but better. trading noah for oden is not a good look because u get noah now and he's worth the money u have to pay and the money goes with his overall as in oden goes up to maybe a 78 or 77 and u gotta pay him 12mil next year if u want to resign him which u would cause if u dont then u traded noah for nothing. u in the same postion they was in last year with no inside scoring.

[D-MAC©®]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Don't forget Shannon Brown is like the truth in this game.

Isn't Paul Pierce "The Truth"?
So ur saying Brown is like Pierce but minus the $$$ contract?

Maybe I should give LAL, or Brown a try on my chise/next chise.
(I'm a noob to this game.)

[Amare]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Knicks trade:

Anthony Randolph

Pacers trade:

Roy Hibbert


I needed a big body to put next to Amare who can rebound the ball.

They both only had 1 year left on their contract so it's basically a rental.

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Knicks trade:

Anthony Randolph

Pacers trade:

Roy Hibbert


I needed a big body to put next to Amare who can rebound the ball.

They both only had 1 year left on their contract so it's basically a rental.

They're both restricted free agents though, so if you want Hibbert back, you can get him back.

Anyways, Pacers wouldn't do this in real life as he is one of the very few good post-up big guys in the game today and one of the young pieces they are building around right now, but in the game that's pretty much fair, though including an '11 or '12 first round pick to trade to them would make it a little more fair in my opinion.

[gottibino]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Ultimate Knickerbockers;
pg-brandon jennings
sg- steven curry
sf- melo
pf- amare
c- mozgov

[ammofan]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Bobcats franchise....After 2 games of playing terrible mainly because I had to post defense, I made 2 trades:

Trade 1: Boris Diaw, 2nd rd pick for Joel Pryzbilla
-I get rid of Diaw(contract and player) and I get a good big man and a big expiring deal.

Trade 2: Stephen Jackson, Desagana Diop, future 1st rd pick for Danilo Gallinari, Eddy Curry.
-I did this one because I do just as good with Gerald Henderson as I do with Stephen Jackson(Even tho in real life Jack is a beast!). This one isnt realistic because the Knicks give up Gallo and cap space but in the game they agreed to it. Gallo has been fire for me lately too.
Also I may try to bring Melo to Charlotte in FA, so the cap space is going to really help.

[Bretlicious]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

T-Wolves (me) trade: S. Telfair, 2011 1st rounder

Pistons trade: W. Bynum, 2011 1st

This was one of those Trade Finder trades. I was getting rid of Telfair because he wasn't happy with the team and wanted to go into free agents. I think Detroit wanted to get rid of Bynum's bigish contract. The 1st for 1st seems fair since they probably expect us to do just as bad as last year, but I'm hoping we do better.

[Zastrin]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

November, I made two trades with the Nets:

Nets: Devin Harris, Terrence Williams, Derrick Favors, 1st Round Pick

for

Nuggets: Carmelo Anthony, Ty Lawson

Denver is first place in their division, so I think the trade was fair plus Devin Harris is now an 81 overall, T-Will 80, and Derrick Favors 78. Also, they have 2 First Round picks...

Next trade, Troy Murphy had very low morale he wasn't the starter anymore since Melo became Power Forward. so I dealt him in a 3 way trade:

Nets (Kings): Troy Murphy

Kings (Lakers): Hassan Whiteside, Dontrell Jackson

Lakers (Nets): Sasha Vujacic, Theo Ratliff

Sasha Vujacic is my 6th man, he is great. I only traded for him cause he is my girlfriend's favorite but he went from a 62 to a 71 overall and it is now April.

[thaone08]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

November, I made two trades with the Nets:

Nets: Devin Harris, Terrence Williams, Derrick Favors, 1st Round Pick

for

Nuggets: Carmelo Anthony, Ty Lawson

Denver is first place in their division, so I think the trade was fair plus Devin Harris is now an 81 overall, T-Will 80, and Derrick Favors 78. Also, they have 2 First Round picks...

Next trade, Troy Murphy had very low morale he wasn't the starter anymore since Melo became Power Forward. so I dealt him in a 3 way trade:

Nets (Kings): Troy Murphy

Kings (Lakers): Hassan Whiteside, Dontrell Jackson

Lakers (Nets): Sasha Vujacic, Theo Ratliff

Sasha Vujacic is my 6th man, he is great. I only traded for him cause he is my girlfriend's favorite but he went from a 62 to a 71 overall and it is now April.

the melo trade is not something that would happen in real life but ok trade for u i guess. As being a laker fan i know the lakers wouldnt take sasha back since they had problems with him and he wasnt worth having.