The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • AgaliareptX
    Rookie
    • Dec 2009
    • 116

    #406
    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

    Originally posted by thaone08
    because the nuggets made it clear with any trade involvin melo goin to the bulls they would HAVE to get noah back. if you doing it based on real life than noah wouldnt be in the red and black.
    Not exactly true. I'm a Nuggets fan, and the Noah thing only applied on a straight up trade where the only players of value the Nuggets were receiving were Bulls players. Iguodala + Boozer/Gibson would be more possible. Nugs just didn't want a deal centered around Deng.

    Comment

    • jclem92
      Rookie
      • Jun 2007
      • 272

      #407
      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

      Alright guys I haven't done this trade yet but I started an Assoc. with the Bulls and I want to trade for a "good" SG.

      Here is a proposed trade that I think will probably go through. Tell me now, is this fair/realistic. I'm more looking for fair.

      Bulls get:

      Jrue Holiday

      Sixers get:

      '11 First Round Pick
      '12 First Round Pick
      '12 Second Round Pick
      Keith Bogans

      If it's me that's getting ripped off, I'm willing to make the sacrifice. I plan on moving Jrue to SG and having he and D. Rose run the backcourt.
      Tell your line to protect on this play. Heck, tell your line to protect on every play; not just here.

      Pacers. Dolphins. Buckeyes.
      Reds

      Comment

      • JBH3
        Marvel's Finest
        • Jan 2007
        • 13506

        #408
        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

        Originally posted by thaone08
        dude i just said it do make since in this one the other one was a mistake wtf lol. calm down and i know u wrote it in both of them
        Calm down? I'm perfectly calm. Its not like there were CAPs and !!!!! in my post.

        Look at my replies in this thread. I give some logic to ALL my "ratings" of people's trades, so it annoys me when I get crap responses back like "Its unrealistic" without any insight as to why you feel that way.

        Come with more information/insight or don't come at all...at least in response to my posts.
        Originally posted by Edmund Burke
        All that is needed for the triumph of evil, is for good men to do nothing.

        Comment

        • Ferrari997
          Pro
          • Mar 2008
          • 667

          #409
          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

          Originally posted by AgaliareptX
          Not exactly true. I'm a Nuggets fan, and the Noah thing only applied on a straight up trade where the only players of value the Nuggets were receiving were Bulls players. Iguodala + Boozer/Gibson would be more possible. Nugs just didn't want a deal centered around Deng.
          I thought that was true.

          To get everyone else caught up, this was my "proposed trade"

          Bulls (Me) get:

          Melo

          76ers get:

          Deng
          1st Rounder
          James Johnson

          Nuggets get:

          Iguodala
          1st Rounder
          Boozer (or Gibson)

          I'll admit....IF I did decide to do this trade, only way to pull it off is to trade override it because Melo is almost impossible to trade for (at least with the Bulls) because the only players they ask for in return are superstars and frankly in real life, I highly doubt that will happen.

          However, I wouldn't feel as bad doing it if it was a fair trade and its something I feel would happen in real life. That is where you guys come in....thoughts?

          Comment

          • J-Clutch1
            MVP
            • Sep 2008
            • 2448

            #410
            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

            I hate Travis Outlaw, so I decided to trade him back to Portland, who accepted this offer:

            To the Nets:

            Rudy Fernandez
            Joel Pryzbilla

            To the Blazers:

            Travis Outlaw
            3 2nd Round Picks (I got some from separate trades)

            Comment

            • thaprodigyisback
              Rookie
              • Oct 2010
              • 180

              #411
              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

              I'm the Knicks

              Knicks. Trade:
              Tony Douglas and 2012 1st Rd Pick

              Pistons Trade:
              Tracy McGrady and 2011 1st Rd Pick
              Milwaukee Bucks Dynasty:
              http://www.operationsports.com/forum...sociation.html

              Comment

              • thaone08
                Rookie
                • Oct 2010
                • 488

                #412
                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                Originally posted by AgaliareptX
                Not exactly true. I'm a Nuggets fan, and the Noah thing only applied on a straight up trade where the only players of value the Nuggets were receiving were Bulls players. Iguodala + Boozer/Gibson would be more possible. Nugs just didn't want a deal centered around Deng.
                yeah its true cause they not just goin take deng back or anyone eles unless they cant get noah. they want someone young back that why they almost did the trade with the nets and bobcats. they sure as hell not goin take iggy back because he cant get points like melo and plus only reason they even thought about chicago was because of noah. since the bulls said they not tradin noah the nuggets said no. so that why you still got melo in a nugget uniform for the time being and o yeah thanks espn for infomation

                Comment

                • jclem92
                  Rookie
                  • Jun 2007
                  • 272

                  #413
                  Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                  Originally posted by jclem92
                  Alright guys I haven't done this trade yet but I started an Assoc. with the Bulls and I want to trade for a "good" SG.

                  Here is a proposed trade that I think will probably go through. Tell me now, is this fair/realistic. I'm more looking for fair.

                  Bulls get:

                  Jrue Holiday

                  Sixers get:

                  '11 First Round Pick
                  '12 First Round Pick
                  '12 Second Round Pick
                  Keith Bogans

                  If it's me that's getting ripped off, I'm willing to make the sacrifice. I plan on moving Jrue to SG and having he and D. Rose run the backcourt.
                  No one?
                  Tell your line to protect on this play. Heck, tell your line to protect on every play; not just here.

                  Pacers. Dolphins. Buckeyes.
                  Reds

                  Comment

                  • HARLEE23
                    MVP
                    • Jun 2010
                    • 1174

                    #414
                    Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                    Originally posted by jclem92
                    Alright guys I haven't done this trade yet but I started an Assoc. with the Bulls and I want to trade for a "good" SG.

                    Here is a proposed trade that I think will probably go through. Tell me now, is this fair/realistic. I'm more looking for fair.

                    Bulls get:

                    Jrue Holiday

                    Sixers get:

                    '11 First Round Pick
                    '12 First Round Pick
                    '12 Second Round Pick
                    Keith Bogans

                    If it's me that's getting ripped off, I'm willing to make the sacrifice. I plan on moving Jrue to SG and having he and D. Rose run the backcourt.
                    Dude you are getting raped in this trade, two first rounds picks?!
                    MLB- Reds
                    NFL- Colts
                    NBA- Cavs
                    NCAAF- Ohio State
                    NCAAB- UK
                    Wrestling Fan

                    The Ace- Coaching Career of Jordan James

                    Comment

                    • jclem92
                      Rookie
                      • Jun 2007
                      • 272

                      #415
                      Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                      Originally posted by HARLEE23
                      Dude you are getting raped in this trade, two first rounds picks?!
                      Ehh maybe you're right. For some reason, I believed that Jrue was worth it.
                      Tell your line to protect on this play. Heck, tell your line to protect on every play; not just here.

                      Pacers. Dolphins. Buckeyes.
                      Reds

                      Comment

                      • Rocboyz101
                        MVP
                        • Aug 2009
                        • 1550

                        #416
                        Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                        Originally posted by jclem92
                        Ehh maybe you're right. For some reason, I believed that Jrue was worth it.
                        Jrue can't even play sg really..thats who you're trying to move to sg right? He can't even shoot. lol
                        "I'm so far ahead of my time, I'm bout to start another life
                        Look behind you, I'm bout to pass you twice
                        Back to the future and gotta slow up for the present
                        I'm fast, dudes can't get past my past
                        How they supposed to deal with my perfect present?"

                        Comment

                        • jclem92
                          Rookie
                          • Jun 2007
                          • 272

                          #417
                          Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                          Originally posted by Rocboyz101
                          Jrue can't even play sg really..thats who you're trying to move to sg right? He can't even shoot. lol
                          Well on that note, I will accept the Kevin McHale award for worst GM of the year.
                          Tell your line to protect on this play. Heck, tell your line to protect on every play; not just here.

                          Pacers. Dolphins. Buckeyes.
                          Reds

                          Comment

                          • vtcha
                            MVP
                            • Nov 2009
                            • 2180

                            #418
                            Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                            Wizards (me) get:
                            - Greg Oden
                            - Joel Przybilla

                            Trailblazers get:
                            - Kirk Hinrich
                            - Yi Jianlian
                            - 2012 Second-round Pick

                            What do you guys think of that?

                            At the moment, I'm trying to get Carmelo Anthony for Gilbert Arenas, Andray Blatch and some First-round draft picks, but it is almost near impossible to trade for franchise players.

                            Comment

                            • UndeniableSkillz9
                              Banned
                              • Jul 2009
                              • 487

                              #419
                              Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                              what are some suggestions i want to trade david west for love.
                              really i want to move the hornets from a half court offense to a run n gun offense who should i add to make that happen (not much of a nba fan so i really don't know who is who)

                              Comment

                              • fnz
                                Banned
                                • Mar 2010
                                • 28

                                #420
                                Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

                                In my just started Pacers franchise...
                                Trade #1
                                IND receives F Josh Smith and F Marvin Williams
                                ATL receives F/G Paul George, G TJ Ford, F Solomon Jones, F Josh McRoberts

                                Trade #2
                                IND receives G Jason Richardson, 2011 1st round Pick, F Gani Lawal
                                PHX receives G Brandon Rush, G Dahntay Jones, F Jeff Foster, F Marvin Williams

                                Comment

                                Working...