The Official Rate My Trade Thread

[convince]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Firstly it was two first round picks and Bogans and secondly I didn't use trade override. Never have and never will. I offered out both my first round picks for '11 and '12 and that's what came up in the trade finder. Maybe before you start accusing you should try it out yourself. Johnson is rated a 73 on the rosters I downloaded too.

Okay so when I typed 1st rounders you thought i meant one? Look i have problem apologizing when i'm wrong and didn't mean to jump to conclusions like that. But i did take you advice and tried the trading myself. When i went to just regular trade, I offered the two 1st rounders and bogans, they declined but kept countering w/ by adding Boozer and Love to the deal. I personally would have jump on it. I then went to trade finder and select the 1st rounders alone and the timberwolves kept trying to give me Ridnour, and after i added Bogans to the equation same results. So i just went to their team and selected Wesley to see what it would take. Three name kept coming up Rose, Noah and Deng. They always wanted one. So let me just say if you got what what you said you def. got one of the steals on the year.

[x_NBA_x]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Okay so when I typed 1st rounders you thought i meant one? Look i have problem apologizing when i'm wrong and didn't mean to jump to conclusions like that. But i did take you advice and tried the trading myself. When i went to just regular trade, I offered the two 1st rounders and bogans, they declined but kept countering w/ by adding Boozer and Love to the deal. I personally would have jump on it. I then went to trade finder and select the 1st rounders alone and the timberwolves kept trying to give me Ridnour, and after i added Bogans to the equation same results. So i just went to their team and selected Wesley to see what it would take. Three name kept coming up Rose, Noah and Deng. They always wanted one. So let me just say if you got what what you said you def. got one of the steals on the year.

I apologise if I came off a bit harsh but I don't like to be accused of cheating the CPU as such.

It may be something to do with the rosters I'm using but the final trade was the deal I stated. Johnson was the 6th man and only rated 73, so I'm not sure if that had something to do with it. I'll have a look the next time I load it up.

[fhhs63]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Are these two trades realistic and/or fair?

Carmelo Anthony to the Nets for Zach Randolph, the Spurs' 1st, and 2 Nets' 1st rounders

I think it is, because Zach Randolph is on a HORRIBLE contract, so they get rid of that, and bring in a superstar to put them in a win-now mode.

Then the other one is Zach Randolph to Charlotte their 1st rounder and Boris Diaw

Zach Randolph is on a bad contract, however, he is s till a great player, thus making him worth a 1st (because the Bobcats would assume that this trade makes it so their pick wouldn't be lottery). Plus Diaw's contract is horrible as well, except he just sucks.

[BattalionBlazer]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the lakers.

Lakers: Bynum, Brown
for
GSW: Monta Ellis, Ekpe Udoh.

I love Bynum but I like Ellis more.
I love Brown but I needed someone (Udoh) to replace Bynum.

[jonmchugh007]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

i just started an association with Cleveland and would like to get a scorer at either the 2 or 3 spot. don't really like paker's game. He's gotta great stroke but gets buned on defense alot.

thanks for the help

[J-Clutch1]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Are these two trades realistic and/or fair?

Carmelo Anthony to the Nets for Zach Randolph, the Spurs' 1st, and 2 Nets' 1st rounders

I think it is, because Zach Randolph is on a HORRIBLE contract, so they get rid of that, and bring in a superstar to put them in a win-now mode.

Then the other one is Zach Randolph to Charlotte their 1st rounder and Boris Diaw

Zach Randolph is on a bad contract, however, he is s till a great player, thus making him worth a 1st (because the Bobcats would assume that this trade makes it so their pick wouldn't be lottery). Plus Diaw's contract is horrible as well, except he just sucks.

I think it's fair for the Nets... are you Denver??

Diaw sucks though.

[fhhs63]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I think it's fair for the Nets... are you Denver??

Diaw sucks though.

No, I'm a made up team. My file got corrupted though, so nevermind.

[Dr.Evil]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

GSW trade David Lee, 1st round pick

ATL trade Josh Smith

[matthewj]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I like the Lee for Smith trade if you're GS I think his skill set would fit in great with their offensive philosophy. Currently I'm contemplating pulling off this trade as well seeing as Smith has become unhappy in ATL and I can get him in a straight swap.
I don't really think it works out as well for ATL cause. They have Horford who they want to move back to PF and adding Lee for 6 years means that won't happen.

[xnametaken1515x]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I'm the lakers.

Lakers: Bynum, Brown
for
GSW: Monta Ellis, Ekpe Udoh.

I love Bynum but I like Ellis more.
I love Brown but I needed someone (Udoh) to replace Bynum.

Is Monta your PG now? Don't think you can keep him happy if he's coming off the bench behind Kobe. Unless you traded Kobe.

[Freak123]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

I like the Lee for Smith trade if you're GS I think his skill set would fit in great with their offensive philosophy. Currently I'm contemplating pulling off this trade as well seeing as Smith has become unhappy in ATL and I can get him in a straight swap.
I don't really think it works out as well for ATL cause. They have Horford who they want to move back to PF and adding Lee for 6 years means that won't happen.

The Hawks actually came out and said they don't plan on moving Al Horford from center any time soon. I can see why too, he's one of the best defensive centers in the league. Undersized but very smart with his body and can rebound well.

[BattalionBlazer]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Is Monta your PG now? Don't think you can keep him happy if he's coming off the bench behind Kobe. Unless you traded Kobe.

Uh...dude he's my PG now o_O I wouldn't bench him for Kobe or vice.
I just put Fishy as backup and Lamar as PF.

[TheWarMachine13]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Wilson Chandler for Nets 2011 1st Round Pick

Figured I didn't need the extra depth, I've got Gallo and Dominic McGuire to use at SF and next year I plan on getting Melo. If I don't, I'll just move Landry Fields to backup Gallo. If I do that I can try and get Harrison Barnes in the draft and start him at SG.

So it's not a great trade, but I think it's a smart and calculated one? Anyone agree?

[WG5516]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Sup fellas?

I need some help w/ a decision. I'm in the 2nd yr of my Wizards Association and The 76ers offered me Evan Turner (rated an 80) and their 1st rd Pick for George Hill (78) & JaVale McGee (73). Seems like a no brainer right, I accept that offer... He's upset because he's playing behind Iggy. However, my Wizards are playing better than even I expected at 10-3 w/ chemistry currently at 31%. Hill's contract is up at the end of the season and honestly, I'm not too fond of him, but it's working right now. McGee is dominant down low w/ Thompson. I have no plans on giving him up. I have back to back games both against the 76ers. I would like to make my decision before the 2nd game.

My Current Wizards Lineup:
Starters, Backups
PG - J. Wall, Michael Conley, Janero Pargo
SG - George Hill, Shannon Brown, Garrett Temple
SF - Trevor Booker, Derrick Brown, Austin Daye
PF - Jason Thompson, Sean Williams
C - JaVale McGee, Spencer Hawes

[mushyman167]

Re: The Official Rate My Trade Thread

Hows this trade? Im the Hornets btw

Hornets- Iguodala

Sixers- Thornton, Peja, 1st round pick 2012

Im not sure if thats fair but I saw that as a possible trade irl. also since the Hornets can use another star for sg, I was wondering if there are any other fair trades I can make for a good sg.