Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

Collapse

Recommended Videos

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • SchruteFarms
    Rookie
    • Dec 2008
    • 87

    #1

    Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

    By implementing the wishbone or using it sometimes? The spread was once an unusual offense and now it seems there are more teams using the spread than not. Will the same thing happen with the old under center triple option that Paul Johnson has had success with?

    I don't think it will as much because I think a lot of casual fans would complain and say it's too boring, particularly the students and younger fans. What do you think?
  • legendkiller5
    The Lord of #Hashtags
    • Jun 2008
    • 7731

    #2
    Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

    Personally, I hope not.
    Rice Owls - Houston Astros/Dynamo/Rockets/Texans - Arsenal - PSG

    Comment

    • SchruteFarms
      Rookie
      • Dec 2008
      • 87

      #3
      Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

      Originally posted by legendkiller5
      Personally, I hope not.
      Why?

      Comment

      • BigDofBA
        B**m*r S**n*r!
        • Aug 2002
        • 9066

        #4
        Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

        Originally posted by SchruteFarms
        Why?
        Most of the top athletes do not want to play in that system.

        If you're really good and want to go pro, playing in an option offense isn't what you want to do.

        If you're a top QB or WR would you want to play for Ga. Tech?
        ***My Teams***
        NCAA - Oklahoma Sooners
        MLB - St. Louis Cardinals
        NFL - Dallas Cowboys
        NBA - Oklahoma City Thunder

        Comment

        • EHSheadhunter09
          Rookie
          • Jun 2008
          • 155

          #5
          Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

          Originally posted by SchruteFarms
          Why?
          Also, if everyone starts to do it, that takes away from why it is so effective... Having only a week to prepare for an offense that is so different is one of the key advantages to running it... If everyone started doing it all the preperation would be personnel-based... Then again, I could be wrong and then the offense would just mutate even more...

          Comment

          • SchruteFarms
            Rookie
            • Dec 2008
            • 87

            #6
            Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

            Originally posted by BigDofBA
            Most of the top athletes do not want to play in that system.

            If you're really good and want to go pro, playing in an option offense isn't what you want to do.

            If you're a top QB or WR would you want to play for Ga. Tech?
            What about teams that don't bring in top athletes? Mid-Majors or bad BCS teams? Does Georgia Tech not have top athletes?

            Comment

            • BAMJ6
              Banned
              • May 2003
              • 1533

              #7
              Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

              The point is nobody wins national titles anymore with those offenses

              Comment

              • SchruteFarms
                Rookie
                • Dec 2008
                • 87

                #8
                Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                Originally posted by BAMJ6
                The point is nobody wins national titles anymore with those offenses
                But not every teams goal is to win a national title. Also, couldn't the same have been said about spread offense teams 5-10 years ago?

                Comment

                • legendkiller5
                  The Lord of #Hashtags
                  • Jun 2008
                  • 7731

                  #9
                  Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                  Originally posted by SchruteFarms
                  Why?
                  I find the spread entertaining and the wishbone boring and stale.

                  Originally posted by SchruteFarms
                  But not every teams goal is to win a national title.

                  Rice Owls - Houston Astros/Dynamo/Rockets/Texans - Arsenal - PSG

                  Comment

                  • SchruteFarms
                    Rookie
                    • Dec 2008
                    • 87

                    #10
                    Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                    "I find the spread entertaining and the wishbone boring and stale."


                    Thanks for the honest answer. That's why I think many coaches and AD's will hesitate to implement this scheme and hire coaches who do. Because of backlash from young fans. I wonder what students at Georgia Tech think of the offense.

                    Comment

                    • BigDofBA
                      B**m*r S**n*r!
                      • Aug 2002
                      • 9066

                      #11
                      Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                      Originally posted by SchruteFarms
                      But not every teams goal is to win a national title.
                      LOL. If I'm a top recruit, I definitely want to goto a school that runs the wishbone and has no aspirations of playing for championships. NOT!

                      To answer your question, Ga. Tech does not have top athletes. They have good athletes and are very well coached for the system their coaching staff runs.

                      Ga. Tech will never win a championship running that offense.
                      ***My Teams***
                      NCAA - Oklahoma Sooners
                      MLB - St. Louis Cardinals
                      NFL - Dallas Cowboys
                      NBA - Oklahoma City Thunder

                      Comment

                      • SchruteFarms
                        Rookie
                        • Dec 2008
                        • 87

                        #12
                        Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                        Originally posted by BigDofBA
                        LOL. If I'm a top recruit, I definitely want to goto a school that runs the wishbone and has no aspirations of playing for championships. NOT!

                        To answer your question, Ga. Tech does not have top athletes. They have good athletes and are very well coached for the system their coaching staff runs.

                        Ga. Tech will never win a championship running that offense.
                        Florida, Texas, and USC will probably never use it, but what about mid majors and schools who will likely never play for the national championship. I mean Paul Johnson has taken his team to the ACC championship. Wouldn't you say that the offense has served them well?

                        Comment

                        • Cebby
                          Banned
                          • Apr 2005
                          • 22327

                          #13
                          Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                          Originally posted by SchruteFarms
                          I wonder what students at Georgia Tech think of the offense.
                          Georgia Tech plays in the ACC. That's like saying in 2007 "I wonder what Hawaii fans think of the "throw the ball 90% of the time" offense."

                          Being the ACC champion means absolutely nothing.

                          Statistically, the ACC champion is the worst performing champion in BCS bowls. It's significantly worse than the other 5 BCS conferences, the MWC, and the WAC, and the CUSA, MAC, and Sunbelt at least have no data as opposed to the 2-9 record of the ACC.

                          Comment

                          • SchruteFarms
                            Rookie
                            • Dec 2008
                            • 87

                            #14
                            Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                            I'm not saying that Georgia Tech is a national contender. I'm saying that this offense helped that team to go from an average team in it's conference to a potential champion.

                            If I'm New Mexico or E. Michigan and am getting kicked around by teams in my own conference why wouldn't I try this offense?

                            Comment

                            • K-train
                              Rookie
                              • Oct 2005
                              • 253

                              #15
                              Re: Will teams start copying Ga. Tech & Navy

                              It wouldn't be a good sell for some of the programs. Wouldn't be good for QB's and WR's.
                              I don't feel Myself, Call it Paralysis.

                              Comment

                              Working...