NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

[blkrptnt819]

Makes no since. My Mountaineers have made 3 BCS bowls in 6 years and won them all.

2005 Sugar Georgia 38-35 W
2006 Gator Georgia Tech 38-35 W
2007 Fiesta Oklahoma 48-28 W
2008 Meineke Car Care North Carolina 31-30 W
2009 Gator Florida State 21-33 L
2010 Champs Sports N.C. State 7-23 L
2011 Orange Clemson 70-33 W

There has to be something else to it.

Big East, your conference is what's holding you back.

[blkrptnt819]

LOL...If ND doesn't deserve it? Um, ND hasn't done anything in the last 20 years. That's a pretty bad comparison. Especially when Auburn has won a NC in 2010, gone undefeated in 2004, and has had one losing season in the last 10 years.

Not that it even matters anyway. Prestige in the game is PURELY a recruiting attribute. That is all that it matters about in the game.

Auburn's recruiting under Chizik has been Top 10 every single year he's had a full year to recruit. This coming class will be yet another Top 10 class as well.

The 6* prestige is fine for AU.

You dont compare recents compare overalls. And recruiting class mean nothing til they produce. Prestige is earned on the field though and if it's purely recruiting Boise wouldn't be a 5*. They don't recruit that level of player. And before the NC what were u guys doing? Cam Newton, one player doesn't make you a 6*.

[LucasWVU]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

Big East, your conference is what's holding you back.

We are now in the Big 12 sir.

[Melo_man28]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

please tell me this is fake... what ******* has teams like texas ( maybe a top 20 team) with a better rating then bama and the same as LSU and USC.... i think they are trying to make us NOT want to buy the game now...

[LucasWVU]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

You dont compare recents compare overalls. And recruiting class mean nothing til they produce. Prestige is earned on the field though and if it's purely recruiting Boise wouldn't be a 5*. They don't recruit that level of player. And before the NC what were u guys doing? Cam Newton, one player doesn't make you a 6*.

So if im right, these are the 6 stars?

Alabama - Worthy
Auburn - Unworthy
Florida - Worthy
LSU - Worthy
Michigan +1 - Unworthy
Notre Dame +1 - Unworthy
Ohio State - Worthy
Oklahoma - Worthy
Oregon - Worthy
Texas - Worthy
USC - Worthy

My opinion.

[blkrptnt819]

So if im right, these are the 6 stars?

Alabama - Worthy
Auburn - Unworthy
Florida - Worthy
LSU - Worthy
Michigan +1 - Unworthy
Notre Dame +1 - Unworthy
Ohio State - Worthy
Oklahoma - Worthy
Oregon - Worthy
Texas - Worthy
USC - Worthy

My opinion.

Oregon just won it's first BCS game last year. They have no history. If losing in the BCS gams stands for something the OSU jokes should stop then.

[blkrptnt819]

We are now in the Big 12 sir.

But for years you were in the Big East. You can't move up prestige before you have played a game. You haven't shown you can compete.

[LucasWVU]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

please tell me this is fake... what ******* has teams like texas ( maybe a top 20 team) with a better rating then bama and the same as LSU and USC.... i think they are trying to make us NOT want to buy the game now...

[gator3guy]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

Notre Dame and Michigan are always going to be 6*. They are always going to be prestigious programs. Just look at the recruits they get each year. There is more history factored into prestige then anything and those two schools certainly have a storied history.

[AuburnAlumni]

You dont compare recents compare overalls. And recruiting class mean nothing til they produce. Prestige is earned on the field though and if it's purely recruiting Boise wouldn't be a 5*. They don't recruit that level of player. And before the NC what were u guys doing? Cam Newton, one player doesn't make you a 6*.

IN THE GAME... Prestige is a recruiting attribute. Boise gets it for their 10+ win seasons every year so yes. But what does prestige affect in the game?

Recruiting. As I said, AU recruits at an elite level under Chiz so in that regard, the rating is fine.

If you don't like the rating, that's your prerogative. But regarding it's major functionality in the GAME, recruiting, it's very plausible.

Auburn has a NC and a boatload of 4 and 5 star talent on the depth chart (all underclassmen it seems as well). I don't see the reason for the hate.

UF has been mediocre to bad the last 3 years.

Ohio State isn't exactly in tip top shape right now BTW.

[LucasWVU]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

But for years you were in the Big East. You can't move up prestige before you have played a game. You haven't shown you can compete.

So you are telling me that over the past 6 years that West Virginia has not been on the level of teams like Arkansas, Boise, Clemson, Miami, Nebraska, Oklahoma State, Penn State, Stanford, TCU, VT, and Wisconsin?

Well bless your heart.

The fact of the matter is, there are 4 stars that can be argued as 5 stars and some 5 stars should be 4 stars.

[The Kid 24]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

What are you trying to show?

[LucasWVU]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

What are you trying to show?

The Bama fan at the top of this page wondered why the Longhorns team ratings were so good that they were up there with Bama and LSU and I was just showing him the top ten players from UT and LSU so that he could compare if he had not already seen them.

[The Kid 24]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

The Bama fan at the top of this page wondered why the Longhorns team ratings were so good that they were up there with Bama and LSU and I was just showing him the top ten players from UT and LSU so that he could compare if he had not already seen them.

Oh I only saw the pic of LSU ratings.

[LucasWVU]

Re: NCAA Football '13-Team Ratings

Oregon just won it's first BCS game last year. They have no history. If losing in the BCS gams stands for something the OSU jokes should stop then.

Here is the difference between Auburn and Oregon, Oregon has been consistent over the past 3 years.

No offense to Auburn fans, great recruiting with Chizik, but they only had one great year.

I never said anything about OSU.