Madden 18 All Time Rosters

[sheredia]

anyone doing all time rosters for madden 18 similar to what 2K is offering in 2K18?

[Spartan Warrior]

I've started working on a "Best Teams Since 1980" roster. 2007 Pats, 1996 Packers, 1989 49ers.

Here are the teams I'm going with:

Arizona Cardinals-2008
Atlanta Falcons-1998
Baltimore Ravens-2000
Buffalo Bills-1990
Carolina Panthers-2015
Chicago Bears-1985
Cincinnati Bengals-1989
Cleveland Browns-1987
Dallas Cowboys-1992
Denver Broncos-1998
Detroit Lions-1991
Green Bay Packers-1996
Houston Texas-2012
Indianapolis Colts-2006
Jacksonville Jaguars-1999
Kansas City Chiefs-2002
Miami Dolphins-1984
Minnesota Vikings-1998
New England Patriots-2007
New Orleans Saints-2009
New York Giants-1986
New York Jets-1998
Oakland Raiders-1983
Philadelphia Eagles-1981
Pittsburgh Steelers-2008
San Diego Chargers-2006
San Francisco 49ers-1989
Seattle Seahawks-2013
St. Louis Rams-1999
Tampa Bay Buccaneers-2002
Tennessee Titans-1999
Washington Redskins-1991

I'd like to do at least two rounds of post-1990 teams and at least one round of pre-1980 teams. Lombardi's Packers, Steel Curtain, 1972 Dolphins, ect.

[apollo1980]

If I may ask ...

Did you mean 1988 Bengals vs. 1989? 1980 Eagles instead of 1981?

Requests for alternate teams if making pre 1980:

1969 or 1975 Vikings
1975 or 1978 Steelers
1979 or 1993 Oilers in place of Titans
1968 Jets
1969 Chiefs
1962 or 1966 Packers
1981 Bengals
1972 Dolphins

Thanks for the work

[sheredia]

Quote: Originally Posted by Spartan Warrior

I've started working on a "Best Teams Since 1980" roster. 2007 Pats, 1996 Packers, 1989 49ers. Here are the teams I'm going with: Arizona Cardinals-2008 Atlanta Falcons-1998 Baltimore Ravens-2000 Buffalo Bills-1990 Carolina Panthers-2015 Chicago Bears-1985 Cincinnati Bengals-1989 Cleveland Browns-1987 Dallas Cowboys-1992 Denver Broncos-1998 Detroit Lions-1991 Green Bay Packers-1996 Houston Texas-2012 Indianapolis Colts-2006 Jacksonville Jaguars-1999 Kansas City Chiefs-2002 Miami Dolphins-1984 Minnesota Vikings-1998 New England Patriots-2007 New Orleans Saints-2009 New York Giants-1986 New York Jets-1998 Oakland Raiders-1983 Philadelphia Eagles-1981 Pittsburgh Steelers-2008 San Diego Chargers-2006 San Francisco 49ers-1989 Seattle Seahawks-2013 St. Louis Rams-1999 Tampa Bay Buccaneers-2002 Tennessee Titans-1999 Washington Redskins-1991 I'd like to do at least two rounds of post-1990 teams and at least one round of pre-1980 teams. Lombardi's Packers, Steel Curtain, 1972 Dolphins, ect.

NICE. once i pick up 18, i'll be looking for your roster.....

[Spartan Warrior]

Yes, 1980 Eagles and 1988 Bengals. Super Bowl teams. Bengals are a tough call between 1981 and 1988. The 2004 Eagles are more fun than the 1980 Eagles but I think the 1980 team was better.

04 Eagles and 81 Bengals should both be on the second round.

[apollo1980]

I used computer sim software Second and Ten, which is a number cruncher, and sim the 1980 and 2004 Eagles in 100 head to head matchups, and did the same for the 1981 and 1988 Bengals, to see which team won the most.

The 2004 Eagles and 1988 Bengals won the majority of their matchups, respectively. The 2004 Eagles won 55 of 100 games, and the 1988 Bengals won 2/3 games.

[Spartan Warrior]

Interesting. Going by Pro Football Reference's Simple Rating System (point differential net of opponent point differential) there's no comparison. 1980 Eagles were borderline dominant, best in the league that year. The 2004 team finished ranked 9th. The 04 Eagles had a super easy schedule.

I was wondering if TO's injury had a big effect but it turns out he only missed the last two regular season games (would have sat week 17 anyway I think) and the first two playoff games.

[adembroski]

Quote: Originally Posted by Spartan Warrior

I've started working on a "Best Teams Since 1980" roster. 2007 Pats, 1996 Packers, 1989 49ers. Here are the teams I'm going with: Arizona Cardinals-2008 Atlanta Falcons-1998 Baltimore Ravens-2000 Buffalo Bills-1990 Carolina Panthers-2015 Chicago Bears-1985 Cincinnati Bengals-1989 Cleveland Browns-1987 Dallas Cowboys-1992 Denver Broncos-1998 Detroit Lions-1991 Green Bay Packers-1996 Houston Texas-2012 Indianapolis Colts-2006 Jacksonville Jaguars-1999 Kansas City Chiefs-2002 Miami Dolphins-1984 Minnesota Vikings-1998 New England Patriots-2007 New Orleans Saints-2009 New York Giants-1986 New York Jets-1998 Oakland Raiders-1983 Philadelphia Eagles-1981 Pittsburgh Steelers-2008 San Diego Chargers-2006 San Francisco 49ers-1989 Seattle Seahawks-2013 St. Louis Rams-1999 Tampa Bay Buccaneers-2002 Tennessee Titans-1999 Washington Redskins-1991 I'd like to do at least two rounds of post-1990 teams and at least one round of pre-1980 teams. Lombardi's Packers, Steel Curtain, 1972 Dolphins, ect.

'94 49ers were better.