FBGRatings Seeks to Recalibrate Madden Ratings, Change Game

[SiNsinNatti]

Just came here to add my 2 cents to your ratings. Clearly you guys don't favor The Giants. Seriously rated Eli Manning worst than (just to name a few) Christian Ponder and Matt Moore? You guys seem bias. Patrick Chung... I like the guy but he's equal to Antrel Rolle... How so? What season? Looked at it some more and notice Geoff Schwartz rated lower than Brewer? Smh. I wanted to give you guys a try but you prove to be worst than Danny Moore at this point. Keep trying tho I believe one day you guys will figure it out. I like the idea of lowering ratings but it seems to be little consistency.

[BigGee55]

Quote: Originally Posted by SiNsinNatti

Just came here to add my 2 cents to your ratings. Clearly you guys don't favor The Giants. Seriously rated Eli Manning worst than (just to name a few) Christian Ponder and Matt Moore? You guys seem bias. Patrick Chung... I like the guy but he's equal to Antrel Rolle... How so? What season? Looked at it some more and notice Geoff Schwartz rated lower than Brewer? Smh. I wanted to give you guys a try but you prove to be worst than Danny Moore at this point. Keep trying tho I believe one day you guys will figure it out. I like the idea of lowering ratings but it seems to be little consistency.

I notice that as well, threre are ATLEAST 53 QBs rated higher then Eli Manning.

[MajorSupreme]

Quote: Originally Posted by SiNsinNatti

Just came here to add my 2 cents to your ratings. Clearly you guys don't favor The Giants. Seriously rated Eli Manning worst than (just to name a few) Christian Ponder and Matt Moore? You guys seem bias. Patrick Chung... I like the guy but he's equal to Antrel Rolle... How so? What season? Looked at it some more and notice Geoff Schwartz rated lower than Brewer? Smh. I wanted to give you guys a try but you prove to be worst than Danny Moore at this point. Keep trying tho I believe one day you guys will figure it out. I like the idea of lowering ratings but it seems to be little consistency.

I think it may be you showing bias. Why, by any means, should Eli not be rated so low after last season? And there is still no reason to not at least try these before you write them off as blasphemy. They have a consistent system that works, based upon more than basic stats and youtube scouting, unlike Mr. Moore.

[BigGee55]

Quote: Originally Posted by MajorSupreme

I think it may be you showing bias. Why, by any means, should Eli not be rated so low after last season? And there is still no reason to not at least try these before you write them off as blasphemy. They have a consistent system that works, based upon more than basic stats and youtube scouting, unlike Mr. Moore.

I love the ratings BUT you think Pat Develin should be rated higher then Eli Manning bcuz Manning had a bad year?

[BigGee55]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

Yeah, I actually didn't see those posts until today. Thought I would address it.

Have you guys or anyone else that you know of actually download rosters with these ratings? If so, whats the file name foe XBox1 ?

Thanks in advance

[charter04]

Quote: Originally Posted by BigGee55

Have you guys or anyone else that you know of actually download rosters with these ratings? If so, whats the file name foe XBox1 ? Thanks in advance

I have a roster file on roster share that has about 8-10 teams done.

[BigGee55]

Quote: Originally Posted by charter04

I have a roster file on roster share that has about 8-10 teams done.

Oh yeah, whats the name on it? I wanna give it a try.

[SiNsinNatti]

Quote: Originally Posted by MajorSupreme

I think it may be you showing bias. Why, by any means, should Eli not be rated so low after last season? And there is still no reason to not at least try these before you write them off as blasphemy. They have a consistent system that works, based upon more than basic stats and youtube scouting, unlike Mr. Moore.

Quote: Originally Posted by BigGee55

I love the ratings BUT you think Pat Develin should be rated higher then Eli Manning bcuz Manning had a bad year?

It's not so much bias as it's the fact that I knew they were going to severely under rate him. He had 27 INTs I doubt that they rated Favre a 62 when he threw 29 INTs. Why are 53 QBs better than Manning? I'm not saying he needs to be a 90 but when he plays behind a solid line he wins Super Bowls. I mean Geoff Schwartz isn't better than James Brewer? That makes no sense either. I know I'm a Giants fan, I also know most football fans hate us especially Eli. And I see it clearly on FBG. McBride was rated the number one corner in real life but has incredibly low man and zone coverage skills on FBG. Where did they get they're suppose research on that?