Madden NFL 16 Player Ratings - Top 6 Quarterbacks

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by iLLWiLL

DB, question about your ratings -- when you say that Kaepernick is a 77, and Peyton Manning is a 73, you're not actually saying Kaep is a better QB than Peyton are you? Will this actually make the game play with Kaep as the better QB and Peyton less of a factor in his team's wins & losses? We all know Peyton is as valuable to this Broncos team's success as any player in the league.

It's all based on the talent of the player. Manning has huge deficiencies compared to Kaepernick in Arm strength, running ability, and injury. However, Manning has major gains over Kaepernick in just about every other category. Really, it comes down to the value of each in the OVR calculation. In Madden, arm strength is paramount, so having a lesser arm but having a good release will mean less than having a crappy release with a great arm. Get it?

Manning has an injury hold of 1.4, which is one of the biggest I have seen. I think that after he plays and camp opens that will be modified and his total OVR will go up, but I won't know for sure until it happens.

[lowndsy]

Dan,
Maybe in a separate thread you could do top 5 attributes per position and top 5 players for each ie top 5 QB in on actual used ability thp, awr, maybe a top 5 of each ability would show that yes kaep is rated higher than some as his sod is 90 and manninged is 5, does not make kaep better QB but gives him better Ovr.

Hope I explained myself!