Madden 16,17 or 18?

[foe84]

How is the roster sharing? I currently am playing Madden 16 Xbox 360 but may be getting Xbox one...is it worth waiting for 18? I casually play xbox a couple times per week and stick to NHL, fifa, Madden sometimes.

I'd like somewhat accurate rosters

[GisherJohn24]

Quote: Originally Posted by foe84

How is the roster sharing? I currently am playing Madden 16 Xbox 360 but may be getting Xbox one...is it worth waiting for 18? I casually play xbox a couple times per week and stick to NHL, fifa, Madden sometimes. I'd like somewhat accurate rosters

I tried getting roster sharing on madden 25 and I never could get any community files. Not sure about official roster updates. I'd assume they disable it because they would you rather buy 18. 17 you can still download rosters , not sure about 16.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

[foe84]

ok

dont feel like dropping $60 on a game i know is very similar year to year...i'll look into 17 if i decide to move on from '16 cause right now i have a majority of the rookies...a bummer you can't take files and transfer them like on 360 using horizon.

[ATLBrayden]

Quote: Originally Posted by foe84

ok dont feel like dropping $60 on a game i know is very similar year to year...i'll look into 17 if i decide to move on from '16 cause right now i have a majority of the rookies...a bummer you can't take files and transfer them like on 360 using horizon.

Madden on the 360 and Xbox One are massively different.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Black Bruce Wayne]

Quote: Originally Posted by foe84

ok dont feel like dropping $60 on a game i know is very similar year to year...i'll look into 17 if i decide to move on from '16 cause right now i have a majority of the rookies...a bummer you can't take files and transfer them like on 360 using horizon.

I've been waiting for someone to crack it so Modio and or Horizon would be possible, but it never happened.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

[gr18]

I like 16 more than 17 because the qb AI is better but if youre looking for updated rosters and don't want to fork out the money 17 is your best option because you can likely still get the last roster update and can fully edit.

The new one always saves you alot of time though since there's no roster sharing.

[BigPuhnoDevilDoc]

Stick with 16, 18 has minimal changes at best.

[foe84]

"The new one always saves you alot of time though since there's no roster sharing."[/quote]



There's no roster sharing? (side note: is that all ea sports games?)

I know 360 and xbox one are massively different..seems like there is much more that can be done with roster edits and sharing on 360.