How would you rate your team in Madden 10?

[Americas Team1]

Quote: Originally Posted by salbowski

Holy cr*p!!! Only 2 players below 80 on a team that went 6-10 last year?? Either i'm incredibly biased (vikes fan) or this is incredibly generous.

I agree looks like he over rated quiet a few players.

[masterkembo]

Quote: Originally Posted by Maelstrom-XIII

masterkembo, As a Panther fan, I must say that I believe Hangartner will be serviceable on the Bills OL. With that said, I do think they should draft someone (maybe Wood from Louisville?) in the 2nd round to compete for starting C. Hangartner filled in nicely while we had our OL injury problems early on, but I don't know if he's a consistent starter, or just able to come off the bench and be decent. A 78 seems a LITTLE high...maybe 75-77. So, we'll average and say 76.

Unfortunetely for the Bills right now, we don't have a LG or an LT either so I'm pretty sure Hangartner will be starting (at either gaurd or center). I'm hoping they take Mack with 28 for Center and Hangartner can play LG but we'll see. Unger or Wood in the 2nd would both be good picks as well, if Mack is gone by 28.

I'll go with your 76 though!

[PackersFan127]

Quote: Originally Posted by ShimSham

I didn't go into depth guys that much, aside from those I was more familiar with. Packers have mostly solid starters, and some real stars. But they have pretty awful depth at almost all positions aside from WR, and that showed up a lot in 2008. And yeah they went 6-10 but it's not like they got blown out every game. Seven losses were of 4 points or less and came down to the final seconds. They could have easily been a 10+ win team, with a little better depth and a little better luck.

Well said fellow Packers Fan, you also have to remember that the team had a TON of injuries that hurt as well.

[PackersFan127]

Quote: Originally Posted by CapnKill

NY Jets QB: K. Clements - 79 OVR QB: B. Ratliff - 74 OVR HB: T. Jones - 90 OVR HB: L. Washington - 85 OVR FB: T. Richardson - 95 OVR TE: D. Keller - 83 OVR (would be higher but he can't block) WR: J. Cotchery - 92 OVR WR: Clowney - 79 OVR WR: Stuckey - 77 OVR WR: B. Smith - 74 OVR WR: W. Right - 72 OVR LT: D. Ferguson - 88 OVR LG: A. Faneca - 89 OVR C: N. Mangold - 96 OVR RG: B. Moore - 87 OVR RT: D. Woody - 86 OVR DE: S. Ellis - 88 OVR NT: K. Jenkins - 97 OVR DE: K. Coleman - 85 OVR OLB: B. Thomas - 80 OVR OLB: V. Gholston - 72 OVR OLB: C. Pace - 91 OVR ILB: D. Harris - 90 OVR ILB: B. Scott - 92 OVR CB: D. Revis - 97 OVR CB: L. Sehppard - 85 OVR CB: D. Lowery - 80 OVR S: J. Leohnard - 86 OVR S: Elam - 82 OVR S: K. Rhodes - 92 OVR

Ummm, okay
Kellen Clemens, Washington, and Cotchery are too high

[ImReady77]

Quote: Originally Posted by da bucs gm

guess I'll do it too. luke mccown-77 derrick ward-83 BJ askew-82 antonio bryant-89 micheal clayton-77 kellen winslow jr-92 donald penn-88 arron sears-83 jeff faine-86 davin joseph-90 jeremy trueblood-84 greg white- 79 chris hovan-82 ryan sims-78 gaines adams-84 angelo crowell-85 barrett ruud-89 jermaine phillips-84 aqib talib-84 ronde barber-87 elbert mack-77 tanard jackson-87 sabby piscitelli-80 Also if anyone from the dev team is look at this thread yes jermanie phillips is penciled in as our starting WILL backer. I'd be real disappointed if he's a SS in M10

yea me too.

[CapnKill]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackersFan127

Ummm, okay Kellen Clemens, Washington, and Cotchery are too high

Uhmm... dunno, seemed fine to me... but I don't really know how all the new stats will effect everything... but I never thought 79 would be "too high" for a starting QB. And no I don't think a QB should get special treatement because he is a starter... but I just feel that 79 fits for him.... he isn't exactly the worst QB in teh league.

Cotch is fine at 92... he has good AWR, very good Route Runnig and some of the best hands in the league... the only drawback on him is speed.... but I'd say he is one of the best possesion WRs in the game... I can drop him down to 90 but I don't think he should go bellow that.

L. Washington at 85... dunno, he is very explosive, very quick, agile, etc..etc...

What would you rate these 3 at?

[PackersFan127]

Clemens has never played a full season in the NFL and according to Donny, people with 79 rating will not be scrubs, these people will be solid starters, which Clemens is not. He is between a 72-75 in my book. Washington should be between an 80-82 because, once again, an 85 in Madden 10 is different, this is a person who could be a very good starting back which Washington is not, he's more like a "special" back that could take the majority of the carries but has big play ability. Cotchery is a very good WR, but he is not 90+ material, I'd give him an 88-89

[PackersFan127]

you guys have to keep in mind that the ratings scale is DRASTICALLY different this year. A person in the high 70s is now a solid starter.