How would you rate your team in Madden 10?

[ElDoceHombre]

Seattle Seahawks:

Offense:

Walter Jones LT 95
Mike Wahle LG 85
Chris Spencer C 77
Rob Sims RG 80
Sean Locklear RT 82
Ray Willis RT/LT 75 < 79/80
Matt Hasselbeck QB 90
Seneca Wallace QB 80 < 84 he really proved himself last year
Julius Jones RB 75 < 81
T.J. Duckett RB 75
T.J. Houshmanzadeh WR 90 < 93 the surest hands in the NFL.
Nate Burleson WR 80 < 83
Deion Branch WR 80 < 88 did you watch the end of the season?
John Carlson TE 85 < 90 dude...come one.
John Owens TE 75
Owen Schmidt FB 70 < 79

Defense:

Patrick Kerney DE 88 < 94 (are you serious?)
Craig Terrell DE 80 < not on the team anymore i thought?
Red Bryant DT 80
Brandon Mebane DT 75 < 86 considered a sleeper and a monster against the run
Corry Redding DT/DE 85
Lawrence Jackson 75
Colin Cole DT 80
Darryl Tapp DE 75
Lofa Tatupu MLB 94
Leroy Hill OLB 93 < 88-90, he's not that good
D.D. Lewis OLB 75
Marcus Trufant LCB 92
Josh Wilson RCB 85
Deon Grant SS 80
Brian Russell FS 75
Jordan Babineaux SS/CB 80

Special Teams:

Olindo Mare K 85
Jon Ryan P 75
Justin Forsett RB/PR 80
Josh Wilson CB/KR 90

I only named the players that play the most. How would you rate your team and do you agree with my list for the Seahawks?
[/quote]

It's funny, for the most part a lot of your rating changes like the ones to Wilson, Russell, and Cole, I did to my 09 roster at home. But come on man...Before Kerney was injured, he already tied everyone else on the team for sacks for the entire season, and he got double digits the year before that. Being injured doesn't mean someone should take a hit in ratings, like Branch. He was a freak show when he was finally 100%.

[williampenn]

QB
C. Pennington - 89
C. Henne - 83
J. Beck - 75

RB
R. Brown - 92
R. Williams - 88
P. Cobbs - 80

FB
L. Polite - 82

WR
T. Ginn - 85
G. Camarillo - 83
D. Bess - 81
B. London - 77
E. Wilford - 76

TE
A. Fasano - 88
D. Martin - 82
J. Haynos - 74

LT
J. Long - 93
B. Frye - 74

LG
J. Smiley - 88
A. Alleman - 77

C
J. Grove - 85
J. Berger - 76

RG
D. Thomas - 80
I. Ndukwe - 76

RT
V. Carey - 90
N. Garner - 70

LE
K. Langford - 85
T. McDaniel - 76
R. Wright - 75

RE
P. Merling - 88
R. Starks - 83

DT
J. Ferguson - 86
P. Soliai - 80
L. Dotson - 74

LOLB
M. Roth - 83
C. Wake - 80
Q. Moses - 76

ILB
C. Crowder - 88
A. Ayodele - 84
R. Torbor - 79

ROLB
J. Porter - 92
C. Anderson - 78

CB
W. Allen - 87
E. Green - 84
J. Allen - 81
N. Jones - 78

FS
G. Wilson - 89
E. Kilmer - 75

SS
Y. Bell - 88
T. Culver - 76

K
D. Carpenter - 89

P
B. Fields - 83

[Aso21Raiders]

You gotta take into account the new ratings philosiphy.

[MelMan1486]

Quote: Originally Posted by masterkembo

I'll give the Bills a go: QB - Edwards - 78 (high potential though...for now) RB - Lynch - 86 RB - Jackson - 83 WR - Evans - 88 WR - Owens - 90 WR - Josh Reed - 75 LT - who knows? LG / C - Hangartner - 78? (Carolina fans, help me out here) LG / C - ?? RG - Butler - 78 RT - Walker - 82 RE - Schobel - 82 LE - Kelsey / Denney / Rookie - 70 ish (who cares) DT - Stroud - 81 DT2 - Kyle Williams - 75 MLB - Poz - 84 OLB - Kawika Mitchell - 77 OLB - Ellison - 68 CB - McGee - 85 CB - McKelvin - 80 FS/SS - Whitner - 83 FS/SS - George Wilson - 70 K - Lindell - 77 P - Moorman - 91 KR - McKelvin 90+ PR - Parrish 90+ Man - the Bills OLine is in sad shape right now with 2 1/2 unknowns.

Those are the changes I would make... I agree the Bills line is in need of some serious help. I'm hoping T.O. isn't rated to high because he's steadily on the decline (I don't expect him to be over a 90). I also agree Edwards should be rated low with a high potential.

[c dizzy m baby]

Quote: Originally Posted by pigspigs76

Everyone seems very generous with there team... Raiders: ===== ......................-=overall=- -=particular rating=-...................... QB JaMarcus Russell - 70 THP= 97 (which should be the best or tied for the best in the lg) HB Darren McFadden - 83 SPD= 94 (using Chris Johnson as a benchmark at 97spd and Hester at 98spd) Michael Bush - 80 TRK=91 Justin Fargas - 73 WR IDK TE Zack Miller - 87 CTH=89 (the Raiders best offencive player by far last year) O-line, there are way to many changes being made to it during the off season for there to be any kind of accurate rating assumptions. D-Line Garbage with the exception of Burgess being hurt all year so you can't blame him to much... and Trevor Scott who produced with what little playing time he was given. LOLB-MLB-ROLB Ricky Brown - 70 Kirk Morrison - 87 Thomas Howard -88 SPD= 89 (i feel he one of the fastest if not the fastest LB's in the league) CB Nnamdi Asomugha - 99 (nuff said here, he better have a solid tackle rating tho) Chris Johnson - 86 (waaay underated last year) Stanford Routt- 75 DB Tyvon Branch -73 (has yet to prove anything at this position but was hurt all last year and only played minor rolls yet still played beter then Huff) Michael Huff -75 Special Teams Sebastian Janikowski -96 (should have the most powerfull leg in the game... although his accuracy might take a hit this year) Shane Lechler -98 KR/PR Justin Miller and JLH - IDK everyone seemed to be a 99 last year which I hope gets changed this year to actually mean something... but seriously these dudes are beasts and I would put them in the same category has Hester and Washington for KR and PR's.

This is actually not that bad, but you are WAY underrating Justin Fargas. By your system I'd rate him a 79.

I'd like to do this but I cant do it effectively enough without seeing some sort of reference point as to what Donnie's Systems will look like. I can only rate effectively using last years system and other players in the league and what they were rated as a starting point.

[ShimSham]

Offense
Aaron Rodgers QB - 90
Ryan Grant RB - 85
Brandon Jackson RB - 82
Chad Clifton LT - 84
Daryn Colledge LG- 86
Scott Wells C - 83
Jason Spitz RG - 86
Josh Sitton RT- 82
Greg Jennings WR - 95
Donald Driver WR - 90
James Jones WR - 83
Jordy Nelson WR - 82
Donald Lee TE - 83


Defense
Ryan Pickett NT - 86
Cullen Jenkins DE - 94
Justin Harrell DE - 80 (Injured a lot, but does well when on the field.)
Johnny Jolly DE - 80
Aaron Kampman OLB - 92 (Big ? since I'm not sure how he'll do as an OLB)
Brady Poppinga OLB - 80
AJ Hawk ILB - 89
Nick Barnett ILB - 90
Desmond Bishop ILB - 74
Charles Woodson CB - 96
Al Harris CB - 89
Tramon Williams CB - 83
Nick Collins FS - 91
Aaron Rouse FS - 79
Atari Bigby SS - 84
Anthony Smith SS - 75

I tried to take off several points from what players were last year if they looked bad, and added points to players I thought deserved it, most notably Rodgers, who definitely performed like a top-5, top-10 QB.

[da bucs gm]

Quote: Originally Posted by Aso21Raiders

Raiders Offense QB - Jamarcus Russell - 75 HB - Darren McFadden - 78 HB - Michael Bush - 78 HB - Justin Fargas - 82 WR - Johnnie Lee Higgins - 74 WR - Chaz Schilens - 65 WR - Javon Walker - 75 TE - Zach Miller - 86 LT - Mario Henderson - 75 LG - Robert Gallery - 85 C - Samson Satele - 83 RG - Cooper Carlisle - 80 RT - Eric Pears - 74 T - Khalif Barnes - 75 Raiders Defense LE - Derrick Burgess - 82 DT - Tommy Kelly - 85 DT - Gerard Warren - 75 RE - Jay Richardson - 70 LOLB - Ricky Brown - 72 MLB - Kirk Morrison - 92 ROLB - Thomas Howard - 90 CB - Nnamdi Asomugha - 99 CB - Chris Johnson - 85 FS - Michael Huff - 70 SS - Hiram Eugene - 75 I like your ratings, you might have Tra Thomas a bit low though.

tommy kelly 85!!!!! 55 tackles and 4.5 sacks equals an 85 overall with the new rating system??? I think you need to drop that.

[Aso21Raiders]

Quote: Originally Posted by da bucs gm

tommy kelly 85!!!!! 55 tackles and 4.5 sacks equals an 85 overall with the new rating system??? I think you need to drop that.

Ok, maybe an 83. He's a pretty good defensive tackle.

btw 55 tackles and 4.5 sacks isn't bad at all for a defensive tackle.