Lets Dialouge - Ian's gangtackling challenge revisited

[PantherBeast_OS]

It looks good to me. No complaints here. It looks real and it makes the game feel real aswell.

[Pandemonium00]

None of the videos look real yet, save for the new running animation video with the Jets player. They're still "tweaking," so there's hope.

[JerseySuave4]

Quote: Originally Posted by Entiel

in this vid he talks about how great the ball strip is but look at how dumb the RG & RT look when they pull, when he does the 1st replay it looks like they turn around are are running to tackle the RB or something.

[Carolina Panthers]

Quote: Originally Posted by Entiel

thats what im talkin bout real football helmet hits ball and cause fumble!!

[JerseySuave4]

Quote: Originally Posted by Carolina Panthers

thats what im talkin bout real football helmet hits ball and cause fumble!!

yea but when linemen pull they dont turn and run 3 yards deep in the backfield.

[TheCreep]

That was cool. I like Madden 09s strip animation better though. Its more visceral.

[TheCreep]

Reference that first video. Let me ask the 2k fans something. Now, let me state before hand, that I like 2k also, but I dont downplay Madden either.

Ok, when lewis makes that tackle, he clearly "warps" around the ball carrier for the animation to start. Now...if that had been a Madden video, folks would be throwin hissy fits "You see how lewis warped, they need to fix that crap!", all I'm saying is, if your going to nitpick at the flaws for one game, do it for the other, just to keep it 100% k?

I'm not insulting anyones intelligence when I say this but, Madden and 2k are VIDEO GAMES mayne, I think them boys at 2k did a wonderful job with 2k5 but as I just pointed out, I and you did to, observed that warping during that tackle.

I trust that Ian and the rest of the devs are trying to model the game as realistically as possible, but **** like warping and little weird **** here and there is GOING to happen until they implement a dynamic engine, euphoria is a good example.

If your going to look at everything under a microscopic lens like some type of nutty *** mad scientist, you aint never going to enjoy these VIDEO GAMES. Let that **** rest in piss, the game is raw (Madden 09) and I know 10 is going to be the **** already.

[lendog691]

Keep in mind it is early May and there still working on this and thing is this is a big step in the right direction and i'm sure we all can agree on that. The only thing that worries me is it'll have a serious bug or glitch to start so if they need to delay it 2 weeks to month than by all means they should. We do not want another MLB The Show on are hands.