Ultimate question

[oneamongthefence]

On Madden who would you rather have lead your franchise for one year? Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers? Its been discussed to death in real world. But now it needs to be discussed in Madden.

[ChicagoCubz]

I'd rather start Caleb Hanie.

[thekodinator]

A-Rodge!

With Rodgers at the helm, the Pack is gonna be the team of the 2010s!

[DoubleIt5]

Quote: Originally Posted by ChicagoCubz

I'd rather start Caleb Hanie.

**COUGH** Bullsh!t **COUGH**

My answer for one season is the same in Madden and the NFL. Aaron Rodgers. His arm is as good or better than Favre's in terms of accuracy and power and his mobility far exceeds Favre. In real life I trust Roger's decision making and ball protection more too (although this season Favre hasn't been his careless risk taking self). I think if you extend the question beyond one season it becomes a nobrainer.

[pointNumberOne]

Quote: Originally Posted by thekodinator

A-Rodge! With Rodgers at the helm, the Pack is gonna be the team of the 2010s!

Quote: Originally Posted by DoubleIt5

My answer for one season is the same in Madden and the NFL. Aaron Rodgers. His arm is as good or better than Favre's in terms of accuracy and power and his mobility far exceeds Favre. In real life I trust Roger's decision making and ball protection more too (although this season Favre hasn't been his careless risk taking self). I think if you extend the question beyond one season it becomes a nobrainer.

As long as you already have a good lead with < 2 min. left in the game I've yet to see him come through in the clutch.

[mrclutch]

When the Vikes win the Super Bowl this year this is really going to look like a dumb question.