Madden NFL 11 Rookie Ratings

[NoFear]

Every rookie is being rated really high, and the fans are voting them even higher.

These ratings are going to suck.

[Potatoes002]

No player is even getting voted down, kinda dumb how everyone is jacking up everybodys ratings.

I do like the old school Seahawks logo they have on their page, I LOVE that logo.

[RogueHominid]

Interesting that the first round seems to be more highly rated than the custom draft classes created for last year's game. It was pretty hard to come out of the end of the 1st with a guy rated 80 OVR, at least in the OF.

[pezone]

Keep hating on Tebow!!

the one guy on this draft you really can't bet against!

[trick02]

You guys have to remember over all ratings mean jack **** because of all the pointless numbers that get thrown into each player along with the 4 or 5 that matter.

Mathews may only be a 77 but he has a trucking of 88, Stiff arm of 92 and Speed is 92. The guy is a power house and will be just fine.

[kcarr]

so we made it through the entire 1st round without the fans voting for a single individual rating being lower than what donnie originally had them

[theDude47]

Quote: Originally Posted by kcarr

so we made it through the entire 1st round without the fans voting for a single individual rating being lower than what donnie originally had them

Clausen hasn't been drafted yet... just wait.

[stux]

I agree to high. Maybe what they need to do is go back the last 5 years of the draft and see what they think of those first rounders now.

I bet if we go back we could come up with an average of what first round picks should be rated with the new lower rating system.

KEEP the rating spread out and make a difference between players.

Otherwise, these ain't much difference from one players to another.

The ratings HAVE to matter and be felt on the field or you might as well not have them at all. You might as well drop the player's names as well because they will all play the same so what is the difference.