Madden NFL 11 Rookie Ratings

[kcarr]

Wow, can it possibly be? So far jason worlids ratings have not been raised at all on average by the community and this is in enough time for 2 more picks to be made. Will there finally be a player who the fans don't want a boost for just because he is on their team or they are a fan of him or whatever?

Edit: Nevermind, should have known it was too good to last. The average is now up a point on awareness and even elsewhere

[cdk10]

IMHO a lot of the ratings are being nerfed or boosted to make the overall rating look good. They need to ditch the overall rating altogether and just rate a guy based on skill set.

I also believe we really need a consistency rating to determine how well a player plays up to his skill ratings. That would keep players who have extreme measureables but questionable motors/inconsistant play from dominating.

[cdk10]

Quote: Originally Posted by kcarr

Wow, can it possibly be? So far jason worlids ratings have not been raised at all on average by the community and this is in enough time for 2 more picks to be made. Will there finally be a player who the fans don't want a boost for just because he is on their team or they are a fan of him or whatever? Edit: Nevermind, should have known it was too good to last. The average is now up a point on awareness and even elsewhere

I'm not even concerned with the ratings anymore. I'm just going to re-rate all the players once I get my hands on the game.

[kcarr]

Quote: Originally Posted by cdk10

I'm not even concerned with the ratings anymore. I'm just going to re-rate all the players once I get my hands on the game.

I plan on doing that too. That is why I hope they will actually allow us to edit ratings in a franchise this year like they said we would be able to last year. That would go a long ways in terms of fixing problems because then for those of us that for instance feel ratings don't matter enough we could adjust the scale and keep that going throughout a franchise. Another thing, look at all the inaccuracies caused by the sim engine and how it reads the ratings and gives output. There were a lot of solutions to those problems that only worked for one or two years because they involved adjusting the scale for certain ratings but you couldn't keep that up over the course of a franchise.

[oneamongthefence]

They'll have them rerated when the game ships cause a roster update comes out same day as game comes out.

[SouthernBrick]

I have a question.

What rating is SPI and PBK? This is for a running back.

[T3B0W]

It's all debatable though if anything, I think Suh and Berry at 85 is about right as the highest rookies. Both will make impacts in their first season and play right away.

[jeremym480]

Quote: Originally Posted by jbooc13

-5 on their overall an that should be their ovrl rating.wayy to high

I completely agree. I guess that the stretched rating's they were going for last year is out the window.