Madden NFL 11 Player Ratings: Top 10 WR's

[WFColonel56]

Quote: Originally Posted by warrior7807

I agree VJ needs a higher rating 93ish, but Marshall has the edge when comparing the two. And last season Moss clearly had the better season. actually since White burst onto the scene 3 years ago, moss bested him 2 of the 3 seasons with his one down year being when Cassel started.

So ur saying that moss bested White 2 out of the 3 years. Think about what you are saying. Moss is in a Pass 1st offense. White is in a runn1st offense. Moss has the luxury of Welker to take heat off of him. White is the only pass threat so he is doubled every game all game.... and 1 of the years that u say moss bested white is the best year ever for a wr...WHEN IS A SEASON LIKE THAT GUNNA HAPPEN AGAIN. And about this past year half of the ATL offensive starters were hurt (Ryan, Turner, Norwood, 3 of the OLman)....So white was doubled with the 3RD STRING RB IN THE GAME, WITH CHRIS REDMAN THROWING THE BALL IN SOME GAMES... Moss isnt better than white. and last year moss had a little over 100 over white.....so that isn't CLEARLY better when you factor in what ATL had to fight through last year

[theant1h3ro]

Quote: Originally Posted by Joeyland

One Steve Smith was 2nd in catches, 4th in yards, and a rising star, with hes first pro bowl in his 3rd year. The other is a former great who hasn't had a great season in years, and my be done with hes 2nd broken arm in 8 months. Which should be more effective in Madden11?

Eli Manning >>>> Jake Delhomme

You sound pretty foolish now....

Also in 2008 Smitty had over 1,400 yards (averaging over 18 yards per catch) despite missing the first two games of the season.....now you really look foolish....

[warrior7807]

Quote: Originally Posted by WFColonel56

So ur saying that moss bested White 2 out of the 3 years. Think about what you are saying. Moss is in a Pass 1st offense. White is in a runn1st offense. Moss has the luxury of Welker to take heat off of him. White is the only pass threat so he is doubled every game all game.... and 1 of the years that u say moss bested white is the best year ever for a wr...WHEN IS A SEASON LIKE THAT GUNNA HAPPEN AGAIN. And about this past year half of the ATL offensive starters were hurt (Ryan, Turner, Norwood, 3 of the OLman)....So white was doubled with the 3RD STRING RB IN THE GAME, WITH CHRIS REDMAN THROWING THE BALL IN SOME GAMES... Moss isnt better than white. and last year moss had a little over 100 over white.....so that isn't CLEARLY better when you factor in what ATL had to fight through last year

Most of what you say is exactly right, but do you seriously think this is all taken into consideration when making player ratings? White is rated lower because Moss had a better season than him statistically. Donny Moore doesnt take into consideration that since ATL had 3 o-linemen hurt and a backup QB playing(who had almost an identical comp% and Passer Rating as Ryan) and White still had a great season, than he must get a boost. Also i'd like to point out that ATL had fewer rushing attempts than NE and only 20 or so fewer passing attempts. White was also thrown at more than Moss, so the run-first/pass-first statement holds little water.

The post i responded to stated that White was better than Moss the last two years, when in reality, that is not the case. You also help my point proving Moss has been better when stating that he did have one of the best seasons ever. I'm not a fan of Moss, and do like White alot, but Moss is the better receiver of the two.

[Scottdau]

What no S Rice from the Vikings!?! Come on Madden he had one great year he should be in the top 5, what gives.

[packabacka19]

Quote: Originally Posted by WFColonel56

the last 2 years white has 18 TD and 2535 yds and 173 catches. Jennings has 13 TD 2405 yds and 148 catches....ATL's run yds were 4319 & 38 TDs, GB had 3690 yds and 31 TDs....so there is no excuse that GB ran better than ATL. That means they were passing more. Roddy White just plain out preformed him over the last 2 years.... hell Roddy bested him in 07 (his 1st year as a starter)

It helps that Roddy was the only decent receiving option on the team in '08, and was 1 of only 2 in '09.

Whereas Jennings has to compete with Finley, Driver, Jones, and Nelson.

[packabacka19]

Quote: Originally Posted by G-Men_in_Mass

Have you ever watched a Pats game in your life? Wes Welker is pretty much unstoppable and Jennings as been nothing but a little above average the past two season..

Did you mean to say: "Have you ever watched a Pats game in your life? The Patriots offensive scheme is SO good at exploiting defenses and getting Welker the ball. And Jennings has an excellent season in 2008, but in 2009 he drew heavy coverage due to the fact that he doesn't have the luxury of having Randy Moss on the opposite side of the field."

[bballsoccergreg]

Quote: Originally Posted by G-Men_in_Mass

Wes Welker is so much better the Jennings. The man caught 123 balls in 13 games last year!! No one can cover him, CB/LB/S. When he is all done he will be one of the best WR to ever play the game of Football.. And I hate the Pats.. Giants Fan Here!!

EXACTLY. That packers dude is biased as heck

[bballsoccergreg]

Quote: Originally Posted by MrSkagTrendy

And maaan when is calvin gonna get some love?!

I know right. This junk is ridiculous.