All Pro difficulty out the box

[nml11287]

You will get used to All Pro very quickly and start destroying the computer on a routine basis. I started out just like you and had some really close games against the CPU for about 12 games, then I had to switch to All-Madden

[meep316]

It's different for everyone. I think it's the best difficulty. All Madden the CPU cheats/unrealistically inflates attributes, but on All Pro in a Fantasy Draft I went like 14-2 and then lost by 30 points in the AFC Championship game to a team that I beat in the regular season.