As I've already stated Smoke, I play ball IRL with a passion, so when it comes to Madden you already know it can't be passed off as true simulation. Hell, I've always said, if you plan on playing Madden as if it authentically replicates what you see on Sunday, you WILL NOT be successful online against the "Madden Ballers", I digress back to the topic.
Yes, you're correct, the makeup speed at the safety position was as unrealistic as it could get the past few years, I would know, I've played with my Ravens since before the Hit Stick was an idea in EA Tiburon's minds. But along with that, you could say the makeup speed of ALL the defenders has been pretty ridiculous..the play-making ability period has been ridiculous. I've had Haloti Ngata making 1 handed INT's in Madden 10, Ray Lewis outrunning WR's on INT returns in 09', and Ed Reed is actually Superman only he wears purple.
HOWEVER, this year, the ability to cover anyone with anyone is gone. I stand behind that and applaud it fully. But with that step forward, comes the 2 steps back. As I already said, the fact that people have to adjust their ENTIRE defensive concept to stop ONE or TWO things is ridiculous, any multi-faceted attack is unstoppable. I saw a poster the other day post in pretty much these exact words,
" Well, if you're good on defense and know what you're doing you should be able to hold the opponent in the 20's"
Now...I remember when holding the opponent to 10 or less was the norm in Baltimore IRL, and I routinely held friends and the non-cheese online players to nearly the same standard. ( My best game ever was actually a 13-16 defensive struggle loss to some Denver Bronco guy, Madden 06) The fact that it is essentially IMPOSSIBLE to play defense to that level against those that know what their doing is crazy. Now before you mention IRL, I'll also state that Madden has yet to implement successful enforcement of the penalties and things that make this possible, so the only other place to look is the gameplay correct? As I already stated, until EA correctly programs the nuances of the game INTO the videogame, people will do whatever they can do to survive/win, and if that means taking advantage of their FS to alleviate the bs of playing defense on Madden well then get the ballhawk gloves ready cuz I plan on breaking records out dis bitch.
Now yes, there are alot of variables to consider here...unlike past Maddens, LB's can't cover WR's, joe schmo DB can't outjump Randy Moss by 5 feet to get a pick (for the most part) etc, etc. And of course, the various skill levels of the folks you face online. And hell yeah, if I play against seomone that's playing straight up and not deliberately taking advantage of EA's programming shortcomings, then I'll gladly user somewhere else. But on the whole, in Madden 13', if you find yourself in NE with Baltimore, and you think you're gonna hold them to 20!? Nah....because this ain't you're older bros Madden anymore....