The Top 3 QB's in Madden 10 should be _________?

[Exonerated]

Hey Donny, If you wanna know the top 50 CB in the 2008 season here they are:

http://www.operationsports.com/forum...0-cbs-nfl.html

You'd be surprised that A. Cromartie was the worst starting corner in the league last year!

No prizes for who was the best.

[SouthernBrick]

The second list of yours donny...Brady has been hurt therfore stats should drop, Thats what happened to merriman. They both only played one game in 09 and Brady bunch kept his stats while merriman dropped from 97 to 94 I think.

I would really like to know what you based this off or are you not in control of the 09 rosters? If you compare merrimans stats to D ware's stats in real life merriman is just as good if not better. Its not like Merriman came off a busted season before he was hurt. The only major factor between merriman and ware now is the season merriman didn't play, but one game.

Here are the links to compare the stats. Not to mention they both were drafted the same year thats another reason why I compare Merriman to D ware. Alot of people might say he wouldn't have got 20 sacks like ware this year, but the proof is in the pudding people so you can't doubt that he's not as good just b/c he didn't play one season.

http://www.nfl.com/players/demarcusw...e?id=WAR350675

http://www.nfl.com/players/shawnemer...e?id=MER568200

Peyton, Brees, brady, Warner, (Rivers)

Rivers should at least be top 5-7 at the most.

[ghostlight85]

Peyton and Brady in a virtual tie for first and Drew Brees just a touch behind in... something. Hahah, but please don't give any of the three 99 throwing power. It's just ridiculous to see them get that just because they are the best at the position. There are clearly guys in the league with stronger arms, just not nearly as good at making reads or accuracy.

[Hooe]

I'd be hard-pressed to say Manning is better than Brady or vice-versa. I'd have them tied for the top spot, with Brees behind them both.

[SouthernBrick]

Quote: Originally Posted by Exonerated

Hey Donny, If you wanna know the top 50 CB in the 2008 season here they are: http://www.operationsports.com/forum...0-cbs-nfl.html You'd be surprised that A. Cromartie was the worst starting corner in the league last year! No prizes for who was the best.

I'm not surprised he definitly came off a busted year. i mean from 10 interceptions to only 2. I'm not saying he's not a good corner, just not a good season for cromartie compared to last season.

Hope he's not just a one year wonder, but hey even the great ball hawk ed reed has came off a busted year with 1 interception so i think cromartie will bounce back next year and do better.

[SouthernBrick]

Quote: Originally Posted by ghostlight85

Peyton and Brady in a virtual tie for first and Drew Brees just a touch behind in... something. Hahah, but please don't give any of the three 99 throwing power. It's just ridiculous to see them get that just because they are the best at the position. There are clearly guys in the league with stronger arms, just not nearly as good at making reads or accuracy.

Agreed...About the arm strength it definitly should not be 99 just because of who they are and being the best in the game.

[jvaccaro]

1. Brady (obviously)
2. Peyton
3. Brees

[Cnada]

Quote: Originally Posted by Donny_Moore

Should it go (this is in terms of OVR rating for QBs in Madden 10) 1) Peyton 2) Tommy Ballgame 3) Dr. Drew OR 1) Peyton 2) Dr. Drew 3) Tommy Ballgame Don't worry Zona fans, Old Man Warner is locked in at #4 currently.

Second Choice Donny, Drew had amazing season almost breaking the best yards in a season ever, brady will need to heal up first before overtaking Drew