Madden NFL 10 - 2010 NFL Draft CAPs for the Xbox 360

[bigtxambition]

Quote: Originally Posted by thesublime

He's so hard to realistically create...he and Mays. Berry has such a unique skill set. We're takling 4.35 speed and hits like a track...above average tackler for position and shown that he is a definate ball hawk...also has a knack for taking picks and really turning the field. so its hard not to give his a decent ELU and BCV. A lot of folks think he could even play CB in the NFL, which makes me want to boost his MCV. I just can't realistically make him and not have him at atleast an 83...which is a bit unrealistic for on disc rookies.

There's no rule that says you can't make him an 83. Heck, Reggie Bush was rated an 85 as a rookie.

[lil jon]

Quote: Originally Posted by CPL_6492

All I am saying is all the other college quarterbacks in college football (most if not all are doing worse than him) have the same "players that can play at a totally different level" to deal with when they get to the NFL. Most of those guys can't even stand up to an SEC defense and Tebow does it all year every year. In my opinion based on this he has a better chance to succeed in the NFL than anyone else in college right now. Really he reminds me of a more agile Big Ben when he was in college. But I think we have beaten this horse enough. Thanks for the argument. I'll check back later though if you wanna continue.

sarcasm?

[AnthonyPhillips]

Quote: Originally Posted by lil jon

sarcasm?

The one issue with his CAP of Tebow that i see is his THP. He has it at 90 when in my opinion it should be more like an 81-84.

[lil jon]

and the whole not being a 1st round pick/possibly qb thing too

[AnthonyPhillips]

Quote: Originally Posted by lil jon

and the whole not being a 1st round pick/possibly qb thing too

Oh yeah but that goes with the fact that hes different from the typical QB. Hes not fast enough to be a scrambling QB like Mike Vick and doesn't have the arm strength of a Pocket QB. Hes somewhere in the middle. I think hes worthy of a 2nd round pick and if he's picked by a team that builds a system around him then he should do well. I could see a rating of 75 overall for him for Madden. Maybe his awareness should be lowered also from 65 to maybe 50 because he doesn't come from a Pro System and doesn't read defenses from under center.

[bigtxambition]

About THP ratings its really hard to set it accurately. If you think it should be an 84 then I'll set my CAP's THP to it.

[bigtxambition]

Quote: Originally Posted by AnthonyPhillips

Oh yeah but that goes with the fact that hes different from the typical QB. Hes not fast enough to be a scrambling QB like Mike Vick and doesn't have the arm strength of a Pocket QB. Hes somewhere in the middle. I think hes worthy of a 2nd round pick and if he's picked by a team that builds a system around him then he should do well. I could see a rating of 75 overall for him for Madden. Maybe his awareness should be lowered also from 65 to maybe 50 because he doesn't come from a Pro System and doesn't read defenses from under center.

are you referring to Tim Tebow?

[AnthonyPhillips]

Quote: Originally Posted by bigtxambition

are you referring to Tim Tebow?

Yes i am. I think Tebow is underrated by the NFL right now but the CAP is a little unreal. Tebow throws with great accuracy but his arm strength is questionable and he has primarily played out of the Shotgun so his ability to read defenses from under Center is still up in the air.

Also when i said he wasn't fast enough to be a scrambling Qb like Mike Vick i mean that his speed isn't as good as Vick's. He can run and run you over but his speed is not on par with Vick's.