Madden NFL 09 RB Ratings Analysis

[Ceothachosen1]

barber is rated higher then clinton portis which is a complete joke call me when he carries a whole offense on his back

[Sigma4Life]

Quote: Originally Posted by Ceothachosen1

barber is rated higher then clinton portis which is a complete joke call me when he carries a whole offense on his back

LOL, call me when Portis does the same.

[LosWorld]

Granted, there are always too many highly rated players in Madden. But at this point Barber is a top 5 back in the NFL. Don't take that as a huge deal, as that list changes each and every year with the exception of Tomlinson. I'm sure 3 years ago we would have all liked Alexander on our team. Hell, even Larry Johnson makes you feel iffy after last season. Nature of the position.

[cdronm]

THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU... for pointed out how B. Jacobs got the shaft. #3 in the NFL in rushing yards per/game last season, also had the 3rd best average per carry among rusher with over 1,000 yards last season. That's not worth at least a 91 or so???

[cdronm]

... "for pointing out". (LOL) My bad...

[jontabs]

Yeah, biggest problem for me would be LenDale White.

82 for a starter? From a pre-dominantly running team? The stats speak for itself. Whether or not its his style, lack of sped or what not, the fact is, he should be given the rating of a starting NFL running back, and one whose team depends on greatly.

And he gets shafted by LT'S backup who hasn't done anything the past 4 years, and is going to run behind one of the worst lines in football? True he showed some flashes with one or two carries, but what does that prove? That EA can make up for Vick leaving by giving him an 88?

Barber I'd give a 90-91 but I can see why they give him a 93.

Thing is, you give barber a 93, bump up Jacobs to at least 91. Just my opinion

[texbuk84]

Mr. Barber doesnt deserve to be a 93 first of all because he is a cowgirl and secound of all he is overated. Brandon won the Super Bowl and was a great back all year with more touches and yards and his rating is lower than barbers. the people who put the rating's in must be cowboy fans.lol

[texbuk84]

Quote: Originally Posted by Ceothachosen1

barber is rated higher then clinton portis which is a complete joke call me when he carries a whole offense on his back

exactly portis is better than barber but rated lower. please explain to me the rating system in this game.