How would you rate your team in Madden 10?

[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackersFan127

I don't know, I mean yes Rodgers had a good season, but I'm still not sure about him, and with the new rating system that would mean Rodgers would be great, which he's not. While I still think Hawk is better, I wanted to bring Barnett to like a 90, but I don't want to overrate him

I think Barnett will be great in a 3-4 and hopefully Hawk will take a big step.He's been solid but rarely makes a big play.Woodson could maybe be a 95 and Kampman we'll have to wait and see.

Other than Peyton,Brady,Brees, Warner,and maybe Rivers....Who's all that much better than Rodgers?Maybe Romo,McNabb by a point or two.Palmer and Hasselbeck have to show they can come back from injuries.Pennington,Cutler....I don't know.I know it's just one season but it was a great statistical season and that's what the rating strives for.If there was a clutch rating that would be another story.I'm not willing to call him a choker by any stretch after one season.The defense was at fault mostly last year.

I pretty much see every Packers game living in Wisconsin.I'm not from Wisconsin and was a Colts fan for years.

[NFLHITMAN]

Quote: Originally Posted by Americas Team1

Dallas Cowboys- T.Romo-91 M.Barber-87 F.Jones-76 T.Choice-74 J.Witten-98 R.Williams-85 P.Crayton-81 M.Bennett-75 F.Adams-87 K.Koiser-80 A.Gurode-89 L.Davis-96 M.Colombo-85 M.Spears-76 Igor-80(havent really seen him play) J.Ratliff-87 A.Spencer-75 B.James-86 K.Brooking-83 D.Ware-98 T.Newman-92 M.Jenkins75 K.Hamlin 81 N.Folk-91 M.McBriar-97

Pretty good ratings there!

[tbuck0027]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackersFan127

I don't feel like during certain people Green Bay Packers QB Aaron Rodgers- 80 HB Ryan Grant- 82 TE- Donald Lee- 75 WR- Greg Jennings- 92 WR- Donald Driver- 88 WR- James Jones- 76 DE Aaron Kampman- 93 (I would have him at a 96-97 but he's shifting to LB) LB Nick Barnett- 88 LB AJ Hawk- 94 LB Brady Poppinga- 80 DB Al Harris- 85 ( I think he is one of the most overrated players in the league, he is not a shutdown corner by an means DB- Charles Woodson- 93 FS- Nick Collins- 90 SS- Atari Bigby- 75 (Sure he can hit, but he's not great at covering the deep pass or the run) K-Mason Corby- 85 (he's got a BEAST of a leg as far as power is concerned

Rodgers should be higher, i think around 85-87, guy was a stud this past year and will only get better(hopefully)
Thats about what i would have grant at
Jennings and Driver are good also.
Kampmann agree with everything you say.
Barnett good.
Hawk i believe you have wayyy to high. He has had alright tackle numbers but does not make plays. 86 at best. Im hoping he gets a killer instinct this year and plays vicious with the new 3-4 and Kevin Greene at LB coach this year which should play a huge role in that viciousness i guess is the word.
Woodson is good
Harris a few points higher, maybe 87, but has lost a step.
Collins was a ball hawk last year agree with the 90, hopefully it was not a fluke
Bigby you have at 75, and that may even be generous. Guy is atrocious in coverage, constantly out of postion in the run game, ocasionallly will lay a big hit 1 every 8 games. My rating would be 70.

But otherwise very solid assessment. Any comments on mine packer fans?

[adub88]

Quote: Originally Posted by gr18

QB-Peyton-99 RB-Addai-85 Hart-75 WR-Wayne-95 Gonzalez-84 TE-Clark-90 C- Saturday-90 G- Lilja-81 Pollak-78 T- Diem-86 Ugoh-82 DE-Freeney-95 Mathis-92 DT-Dawson-75 Foster-73 LB- Session-76 Brackett-85 Wheeler-70 CB-Hayden-86 Jackson-80 S- Sanders-96 Bethea-84 K- Vinatieri-88 P- Smith-81 You may have Hasselbeck a few points too high IMO. Julius Jones a few points too low. All the DT's a couple points too high. Hill is very good but I don't see him getting above 90. Wilson maybe an 82.Babineaux maybe 78.

Considering the new ratings, I think that's pretty dang accurate. Just a few key guys for the Colts

DT/DE Raheem Brock 84
FS- Melvin Bullit- 75

[PackersFan127]

I'm sorry, but Romo should be between an 88-90 in my opinion, I just do not find him to be that good.

[XtremeDunkz]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackersFan127

I don't feel like during certain people Green Bay Packers QB Aaron Rodgers- 86 HB Ryan Grant- 81 TE- Donald Lee- 75 WR- Greg Jennings- 92 WR- Donald Driver- 88 WR- James Jones- 76 DE Aaron Kampman- 93 (I would have him at a 96-97 but he's shifting to LB) LB Nick Barnett- 88 LB AJ Hawk- 94 LB Brady Poppinga- 80 DB Al Harris- 87 ( I think he is one of the most overrated players in the league, he is not a shutdown corner by an means DB- Charles Woodson- 93 FS- Nick Collins- 90 SS- Atari Bigby- 75 (Sure he can hit, but he's not great at covering the deep pass or the run) K-Mason Crosby- 88 (he's got a BEAST of a leg as far as power is concerned

fixed

[gr18]

Quote: Originally Posted by adub88

Considering the new ratings, I think that's pretty dang accurate.

Yeah,I would hope we could do something about getting a better DT and maybe get Derrick Brooks or something at OLB along with a good #3 receiver.

[NFLHITMAN]

Quote: Originally Posted by PackersFan127

I'm sorry, but Romo should be between an 88-90 in my opinion, I just do not find him to be that good.

I do know his clutch situations and stats for it should be around a 60.