Madden NFL 10: Fumble Meter Follow Up

[WildFan22]

Instead of tapping wouldn't it make more sense to make it like a lock picking miny game used in games like splinter cell. Instead button mashing it would actually take a little stick skill. You would rotate the sticks until the controller rumbled which ment you were touching the ball. During pile ups your blindly grabbing for the ball.

Do you think that would work?

[NYyankz225]

Quote: Originally Posted by Valdarez

Will we see any flags thrown from a pile up? Perhaps a giving him the business call? I know it's not NFL, but it's great.

Ah but this is the classic. From the NFL

[Valdarez]

Quote: Originally Posted by NYyankz225

Ah but this is the classic. From the NFL

Yeah! That's the one. That would be awesome to get the ref animation where he does the little punch and says he was 'giving him the business down there'!

[StevieTheD]

Quote: Originally Posted by WildFan22

Instead of tapping wouldn't it make more sense to make it like a lock picking miny game used in games like splinter cell. Instead button mashing it would actually take a little stick skill. You would rotate the sticks until the controller rumbled which ment you were touching the ball. During pile ups your blindly grabbing for the ball. Do you think that would work?

That is pretty much what I proposed a while ago. The movement of the sticks could emulate the frantic movement of your arms to find, grab, and tug away the ball - at least more so than button mashing.

...no one seemed to like that idea.

I like the current system but think using the sticks here could be good.

[thudias]

shaping up just fine ..and a perfect answer to a great question...