Madden NFL 10 Ratings: Top 10 by Position (ESPN Videogames)

[steelers1]

Quote: Originally Posted by tonynyy

Wow, you have the biggest anti-Patriots bias ever. Tom Brady is a greater quarterback than the Steelers have ever had (yes I know about Bradshaw, Roethlisberger and O'Donnell). He's a winner whether you like it or not, and his 50 TD season cemented him as one of the greats. In an earlier post you evaluated him based on his losses which is completely ridiculous. If I told you Big Ben deserved an 80 overall because he choked in the 2004 AFC championship game or because he didn't do anything in Super Bowl XL, would it make sense? Exactly.

I do hate me some Patriots, but...

I wasn't evaluating Brady by his losses. I was replying to a guy who was basically making excuses for Tom Brady when the Pats lost in the playoffs. Tom Brady of all QBs needs no excuses.

As for Brady being better than Bradshaw... those were different times and it was a different game back then. Bradshaw took a team from laughing stock to dynasty. Brady inherited a better team to start with. Bradshaw has 4 Super Bowl rings and will forever have a better Super Bowl record than Tom Brady. For that, I'll always argue for Bradshaw over Brady. As for Roethlisberger vs Brady, it can't be argued at this point. Ben still (hopefully) has a good 10 years left. When their careers are over they can be judged.

And I seriously hope you are kidding about Neil O'Donnell. The name alone makes any Steelers fan want to vomit.

[celg35]

Quote: Originally Posted by steelers1

I think a team that wins the Super Bowl is better than a team that doesn't regardless of their record. As for the franchises, the Pats have been the best franchise this decade for sure, but of all time obviously the Steelers have the most SBs and such.

ok and on that note who quarterbacked those superbowl wins for the patriots....brady.........the steelers qb's are spread out over 4 decades

that is what i'm saying........ i think you make some good points, but i can't agree with you on this one........sorry

some guys will come down hard on you for that...........but i can see you truly love the steelers, so i see where your paasion is coming from.

hey if its your team you should be alittle biassed, but in this forum....sometimes it is best to keep some thoughts to yourself......

[lint]

Wow this post got horribly off topic....

BRADY vs MANNING

Grrrrr.

If I remember correctly the reason we have the 5yard sissy... oops I mean touching rule is because of that rainy NE vs IND game where the Pats beat the every living tar out of the Colts WR.

Anyway... I am trying to figure out why people do not think Roddy White is better than TO

How many seasons do you have to average 1250 yards and 6.5 touchdowns to be considered good?

http://www.nfl.com/players/profile?id=WHI472686

here are TO's stats from the last two years

http://www.nfl.com/players/terrellow...e?id=OWE755129

here are Brandon Marshall's

http://www.nfl.com/players/brandonma...e?id=MAR370922

Last year Roddy was the better WR

The year before Roddy had over 1200 yards with Joey "Noodle Arm" Harrington.

TO is not all that great.

[PYA-MUSTANG86]

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Greg Jennings
3. Reggie Wayne
4. Roddy White
5. Chad Johnson (better not be Chad Ochocinco in madden)
6. Randy Moss
7. Larry Fitzgerrald
8. Anquan Boldin
9. Steve Smith
10. Marquis Colstin
11. Andre Johnson
12. Lee Evans (yeah thats right not even the best WR on his own team now)
13. T.J Houshmanzadah
14. Braylon Edwards
15. Brandon Marshall
Ok well that's 15 WR's that are better then T.O. Not in any particular order, didn't have enough time to rank em all.

[shotgun styles]

Quote: Originally Posted by tonynyy

Wow. Just Wow. Are you mentally challenged?

Wow. That was some argument you just made. I really don't know how to respond other than to say...

HEART OF A CHAMPION!!!

It's about as relevant to your statement as your statement is to mine.

[Obelysk]

Quote: Originally Posted by steelers1

I do hate me some Patriots, but... I wasn't evaluating Brady by his losses. I was replying to a guy who was basically making excuses for Tom Brady when the Pats lost in the playoffs. Tom Brady of all QBs needs no excuses. As for Brady being better than Bradshaw... those were different times and it was a different game back then. Bradshaw took a team from laughing stock to dynasty. Brady inherited a better team to start with. Bradshaw has 4 Super Bowl rings and will forever have a better Super Bowl record than Tom Brady. For that, I'll always argue for Bradshaw over Brady. As for Roethlisberger vs Brady, it can't be argued at this point. Ben still (hopefully) has a good 10 years left. When their careers are over they can be judged. And I seriously hope you are kidding about Neil O'Donnell. The name alone makes any Steelers fan want to vomit.

Regardless of how they started the 70 Steelers had far more talent than any of our teams has ever had, even more than our 2007 roster which consisted only 2 future Hall of Famers. How many did the 70 Steelers have?

[KensaiKatai]

Quote: Originally Posted by shotgun styles

Wow. That was some argument you just made. I really don't know how to respond other than to say... HEART OF A CHAMPION!!! It's about as relevant to your statement as your statement is to mine.

[nepatriotsfan]

Quote: Originally Posted by PYA-MUSTANG86

1. Calvin Johnson 2. Greg Jennings 3. Reggie Wayne 4. Roddy White 5. Chad Johnson (better not be Chad Ochocinco in madden) 6. Randy Moss 7. Larry Fitzgerrald 8. Anquan Boldin 9. Steve Smith 10. Marquis Colstin 11. Andre Johnson 12. Lee Evans (yeah thats right not even the best WR on his own team now) 13. T.J Houshmanzadah 14. Braylon Edwards 15. Brandon Marshall Ok well that's 15 WR's that are better then T.O. Not in any particular order, didn't have enough time to rank em all.

why shouldnt he be ocho cinco. they are letting him wear it on his jersey now