Quarterback Voices in Madden NFL 10

[Cryolemon]

Quote: Originally Posted by daenius

What does generic mean?

Non-specific, i.e they'll be one (or maybe 3 or 4) for white QBs and the same number for black QBs, but no-one's real voice.

[daenius]

Thanks for clearing that up, guys!

Quote: Originally Posted by adembroski

QB voices are generic this year.

How do you know?

I compared Roethlisberger's voice in Madden with Superbowl XLIII and they sounded exactly the same.

Same goes for Brady, his real voice has been in Madden 09, and this year it sounds the same.

Plus, Ian confirmed they had to change Peyton's voice for reasons unknown...

[mmorg]

Quote: Originally Posted by daenius

Yesterday evening, I asked Ian if there was a reason why Peyton Manning's real voice wasn't in the game and he told me yes, there is and let me guess it. He didn't repy yet, but my guess was that Manning doesn't want his real audibles and dummy calls in the game, because teams could go ahead and write them down, check them with game videos and make sense of them... What do you think?

Couldn't they do that with regular game film?

[daenius]

Quote: Originally Posted by mmorg

Couldn't they do that with regular game film?

I'm not sure if you can hear it as well, I'm not familiar with game film audio quality.

I think it also depends on the stadium.
In Lucas Oil Stadium, you can hear the QB's voices even when you're watching the broadcast, because it's built in a way that amplifies their voices much more than anywhere else.

[adembroski]

Quote: Originally Posted by daenius

Thanks for clearing that up, guys! How do you know?

I'm special.































Oh, and Phil told me.

[PolkaDot]

Quote: Originally Posted by Cryolemon

Non-specific, i.e they'll be one (or maybe 3 or 4) for white QBs and the same number for black QBs, but no-one's real voice.

ROFL. What?

Now white and black QBs have different voices ?

[reyes the roof]

Quote: Originally Posted by daenius

Yesterday evening, I asked Ian if there was a reason why Peyton Manning's real voice wasn't in the game and he told me yes, there is and let me guess it. He didn't repy yet, but my guess was that Manning doesn't want his real audibles and dummy calls in the game, because teams could go ahead and write them down, check them with game videos and make sense of them... What do you think?

I would imagine that the calls for audibles and dummy calls are constantly changing, plus they have a new OC this year so that could affect all of their calls

[thecougarbear]

Quote: Originally Posted by adembroski

QB voices are generic this year.

Wait, wait, wait... why would they take out voices?