If You See it on Sundays, You Will See it in Madden 10 (my review)

[boooey]

Quote: Originally Posted by bigsmallwood

Madden 10 is not only the closest that the series has ever been to replicating an actual NFL Broadcast, but it is the most immersing NFL experience available for Next-Gen.

Sorry, no offense but you lost all credibility with me in that statement.. as we all know, its the ONLY NFL game for next gen..

[bigsmallwood]

Quote: Originally Posted by boooey

Sorry, no offense but you lost all credibility with me in that statement.. as we all know, its the ONLY NFL game for next gen..

Which is why I said "Next-Gen"....

Good Day!

[bigsmallwood]

Quote: Originally Posted by Sigma4Life

I think he's saying Madden 10 is better than NFL 2K5 EXCEPT for presentation, where 2k5 is still better.

Thank You for understanding what I thought I clearly stated!

[NEWYORICAN]

Good review!...however, the presentation is still lacking IMO. They still need ways to go on the presenatation end...ways to go. 2K5 is still the KING here. It looks like the presentation is put together half-assed..I hope for madden 11, it is fine tuned

Now, for gameplay and funfactor/Arcade football,...yes, Madden is the best.!


peace

[Alliball]

Quote: Originally Posted by Ankido

I thought you did a great job until I got to this part. "presentation withstanding, madden 10 is better than NFL 2K5. Finally." I hate to burst your bubble, NFL2K still is and will be the best sports game when it comes to presentation. The fact they used ESPN to present the game was one of the most amazing things we've seen in sports game history. Why didn't Madden use ESPN or NFLNetwork to present the game? You contradict yourself when you say "Need more "defined" presentation." I thought you said M10 was better then 2k in presentation? Now you go back on your word and say they need more? NFL2K nailed it on presentation and adding more would be an added bonus. Overall very good well thought out review. I agree with you, the game is good but not what we all expected. M11 will probably be the best football game to date.

This may be the best example I've ever seen of somebody putting their foot in their mouth in the history of OS.

[bigsmallwood]

Quote: Originally Posted by NEWYORICAN

Good review!...however, the presentation is still lacking IMO. They still need ways to go on the presenatation end...ways to go. 2K5 is still the KING here. It looks like the presentation is put together half-assed..I hope for madden 11, it is fine tuned Now, for gameplay and funfactor/Arcade football,...yes, Madden is the best.! peace

I concur! It can definitely be much much better!!!

[ice23]

Great review. I know my fingers will have blisters on them all weekend from constant madden play but, it will be worth it.

[Mofficial]

Quote: Originally Posted by bigsmallwood

Patch: I know there were a few more negatives with the presentation, but I was trying to avoid comparisons with 2K5 by not saying how much better ESPN 2K5's presentation is. EA needs to patch in much more replays as well as stat overlays for the actual game being played. It would be nice to see some end of quarter highlights ala NBA 2K9 being shown as well! However, you must give credit when credit is due! Madden 10 is OFFICIAL in my book.

It's Mofficial.