McNabb, Staley, and other Eagle Ratings in Madden

[mike62474]

Quote:

---

bgeno said:
Numbers aren't everything, Mike. I agree with the poster who said Vick had no talent around him, but I also agree that him being a 95 is up too high. I say somewhere between 87 and 91. He single-handedly put that team into the playoffs. His throwing ability is getting much better and with Peerless Price, i think he can get over the 3000 yard mark for passing. Anytime a d-coordinator has to spy on a quarterback with one, two, even 3 different players, he deserves to be better than an 80 overall.

---

He didn't single handedly do it. Their defense was very good.

[nastyshoes69]

bgeno is right,numbers arnt every thing,he can turn the whole game around in just one play,thats what seperates good players from great players.and vick,he is a great player.the nfl needs more players like vick to bring eximent to the game,everyone loves to see that overtime run agiants the vikeings(makes 2 players run into each other).i think he's already established that he is know gonna be one of the elite players in the nfl.i actually think he should be rated higher than mcnabb,vick has better run ability,and if he practices his throwing the ball more,then he will defintily be better than mcnabb.