Madden 12 1st Round Rookie Ratings

[JDoze]

Quote: Originally Posted by LBzrule

Frankly I think all rookie ratings should be suspended until we hear how these guys are doing in camp. I mean if you think about it. Say a current guy on the roster is already rated 71 overall and the rookie comes in and supplants that guy. It would be a travesty to have the rookie still rated 65 overall don't ya think?

Thats where roster updates come into play

[BezO]

Quote: Originally Posted by LBzrule

Frankly I think all rookie ratings should be suspended until we hear how these guys are doing in camp. I mean if you think about it. Say a current guy on the roster is already rated 71 overall and the rookie comes in and supplants that guy. It would be a travesty to have the rookie still rated 65 overall don't ya think?

Agreed.

And I think the ratings should be fairly modest until the first roster update.

LOL at C. Newton's potential being any less than an A. Dude is the most physically gifted QB in the draft.

[LiquorLogic]

Quote: Originally Posted by BezO

Agreed. And I think the ratings should be fairly modest until the first roster update. LOL at C. Newton's potential being any less than an A. Dude is the most physically gifted QB in the draft.

Yeah, physically he's the most gifted,but given the fact that system he ran at Auburn, which was a one read and go system, we can't say that his potential should certainly be an A. Honestly, the potential grade should be hidden to the user anyway.

[Cre8]

Quote: Originally Posted by LiquorLogic

Yeah, physically he's the most gifted,but given the fact that system he ran at Auburn, which was a one read and go system, we can't say that his potential should certainly be an A. Honestly, the potential grade should be hidden to the user anyway.

Maybe potential can be user (coach) determined.

One man's Colt McCoy is another man's Peyton Manning.

Too much attention is given to OVR anyway. I think they should stick to ability ratings and SCRAP OVR totally.

[jeremym480]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

Here is how they are rated at FBGratings: 1 Cam Newton QB Panthers 71 2 Von Miller OLB Broncos 75 3 Marcell Dareus DT Bills 74 4 A.J. Green WR Bengals 72 5 Patrick Peterson DB Cardinals 80 6 Julio Jones WR Falcons 72 7 Aldon Smith OLB 49ers 68 8 Jake Locker QB Titans 66 9 Tyron Smith OT Cowboys 70 10 Blaine Gabbert QB Jaguars 71 11 J.J. Watt DE Texans 71 12 Christian Ponder QB Vikings 65 13 Nick Fairley DT Lions 70 14 Robert Quinn DE Rams 71 15 Mike Pouncey C Dolphins 67 16 Ryan Kerrigan OLB Redskins 73 17 Nate Solder OT Patriots 68 18 Corey Liuget DT Chargers 65 19 Prince Amukamara DB Giants 70 20 Adrian Clayborn DE Buccaneers 71 21 Phil Taylor DT Browns 65 22 Anthony Castonzo OT Colts 66 23 Danny Watkins OG Eagles 62 24 Cameron Jordan DE Saints 74 25 James Carpenter OG Seahawks 59 26 Jonathan Baldwin WR Chiefs 65 27 Jimmy Smith DB Ravens 65 28 Mark Ingram RB Saints 66 29 Gabe Carimi OT Bears 66 30 Muhammad Wilkerson DE Jets 68 31 Cameron Heyward DE Steelers 67 32 Derek Sherrod OT Packers 69 LOL at SEA taking a college OG to play OT when he has no foot quickness, is susceptible to the double move, doesn't change directions well at all, and plays standing straight up in pass protection!

These are my type of ratings. I might give or take away a few points here & there but, for the most part they are right on. Stretched ratings, FTW!!

[sonn]

Quote: Originally Posted by dirtysouth1295

peterson / green = best players in draft locker / gabbert = best quarterbacks i really think cam is the next BUST. only time will tell tho

Locker is hot garbage.

[DCEBB2001]

Quote: Originally Posted by Lodeus

I think those are perfect.

Quote: Originally Posted by l_XaVo7o3_l

FBG ratings are by far the most reasonable when it comes to ratings and hope one day they will be implemented correctly into madden.

Quote: Originally Posted by jeremym480

These are my type of ratings. I might give or take away a few points here & there but, for the most part they are right on. Stretched ratings, FTW!!

Thanks for the props guys! Continue to support FBGratings by getting the word out!

[brettmickey]

Quote: Originally Posted by DCEBB2001

Thanks for the props guys! Continue to support FBGratings by getting the word out!

A question on the ratings... Why is Patrick Peterson so much higher than any other prospect? It's not that I completely disagree with it, I just want to hear your take on it and know what makes him so much more superior than the rest. And 1 more question... If players in the end of the first are barely scratching 70, then what are players in the 4th-7th round rated? Thanks