Gates vs Witten

[The Amaizen Blue]

Hmm Witten or Gates...

I'll take Dallas Clark

And the debate thickens lol jk

[phillysouljah]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Yeah, but he's totally unbiased. LOL.

Romo and Witten are BFF's so I guess someone named Romomentum has to defend his hero's BFF.

[shnuskis]

Quote: Originally Posted by SIMstyle

no sir, we just dont rate what isn't there. we rate the the numbers for the 2010 season. we generally take off 2 to 3 points for someone that misses 8 games or more tho (which he didnt) looking at his last 3 years i'd rate Gates a 92. A great rating. making him "play" like he does in reality by using his athleticism downfield/in the redzone could be done with animations.

We can agree to disagree a little. Thats fine. I just don't think a guy who averages 10 td's and just under 1,000 yds a year over the last 7 years and has the best 26 game stretch of his career would be rating something that isn't there. I would just give him a lower durability. But there are different ways of accomplishing the same thing with ratings.

[phillysouljah]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Amaizen Blue

Hmm Witten or Gates... I'll take Dallas Clark And the debate thickens lol jk

Dallas Clark's stats are not as impressive as I assumed. 2009 was a monstrous year but for the most part, his yardage numbers over his career haven't been that impressive. He's averaged 566 yards per season.

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Amaizen Blue

Hmm Witten or Gates... I'll take Dallas Clark And the debate thickens lol jk

I wouldn't. But I think Clark is top 3 TE and is underrated. For some reason he gets lost in the shuffle.

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

What? What does that have to do with the post you quoted?

Has everything to do with it? I was talking about a flawed individual rating with Jason Witten?

[R0M0mentum09]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

You'd have a point if Gates didn't already have a track record, and wasn't already widely regarded as the best TE currently in the league. This wasn't his first rodeo so to speak. You're starting to sound more and more like typical Cowboy fan who can't fathom the idea people think a non Cowboy is better than one of their players.

No better Pass rusher than DeMarcus Ware

There are better blocking TE's than Witten

There are better receiving TE's than Witten

There is no better OVERALL (combination of the two) TE than Jason Witten

There are better receivers than Miles Austin

There are better quarterbacks than Tony Romo

There's MUCH better RB's than anyone on our roster.


I could go on. . .

[bkrich83]

Quote: Originally Posted by R0M0mentum09

No better Pass rusher than DeMarcus Ware There are better blocking TE's than Witten There are better receiving TE's than Witten There is no better OVERALL (combination of the two) TE than Jason Witten There are better receivers than Miles Austin There are better quarterbacks than Tony Romo There's MUCH better RB's than anyone on our roster. I could go on. . .

LOL. Whatever you say.