Overrated/Underrated players/teams in Madden 12

[Zastrin]

Quote: Originally Posted by WindyCityFanatic

HAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHA HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Man you got me there! I thought you were serious! Bears will have 150 yards + running the football on that thing you guys like to call a defense Cutler will CARVE those WEAK corners Our Defense will be WAY to much for Matt Ryan... they will have NO run game... the Bears just match up PERFECTLY against the Falcons because we are one of the best at stopping there best offensive attack. Everything depending on Mike Martz play calling and the Bears O-Lines play...

Oh yeah, just like Cutler did against the Packers in the play offs. Oh wait... he didnt because he lacks toughness!

But I am kidding. I am a Panthers fan, I hope the Bears beat the Falcons

[Stupendamatic]

I'll speak on the Giants since that's who I have been using....

Overrated
Shaun O'Hara - 91, not on team anymore but had to list him :facepalm:
Travis Beckum - 71, hasn't done anything to be rated in the 70's
Jonathan Goff - 79, not too bad but he should be mid 70's not near 80
Aaron Ross - 79, the way he played last season he should be lower but he has played better this pre-season
Clint Sintim - 71, should be low 60's
Zac DeOssie - 71, he is a long snapper and only plays special teams how is he in the 70's???


Underrated
C David Baas - 71, he played much better once San Fran moved him over to C last year and his rating should be reflected of that.
DE/OLB Mathias Kiwanuka - 72, I mean really?? He is a very good pass rusher and quicker then his madden rating indicates. He was robbed with this rating, easily an 83+ player when at DE.
RB Da'Rell Scott - 58, watch his pre-season highlights of his speed
LB Greg Jones and Mark Herzlich - Much better college production and pre-season performance then Casey Matthews who is rated a 71.
S Tyler Sash - 58, slap int he face to a highly productive college player who played well this pre-season.

[TMJOHNS18]

Overrated - Orton's neck beard. Sure it's amazing, but it's called a neck beard EA, doesn't take up everything. Plus, should be dynamic, and grow every game through the season.

Underrated - L Blount. Should have 199 Jump and be able to hop scotch all the way downfield.

[MileHighSalute30]

All hail the power of Orton's Neckbeard.

[Pandetta]

Quote: Originally Posted by MileHighSalute30

All hail the power of Orton's Neckbeard.

The power of the Neckbeard™ keeps Heisman winners riding the bench!

[Pared]

If you guys don't post on the topic, not only will the topic be closed, bans will be dealt.

Those that joined recently, PAY ATTENTION.

Thanks fellas.

[damien6663]

the majority of the players in madden are overated this year! Stretched ratings went down the drain and really killed the difference between a star and good player.