Which QB would you choose [Madden 12]

[football5680]

crompton. Better passer

[MINATAURO]

Crompton. He has a cannon for an arm.

[legenddt]

Quote: Originally Posted by KingV2k3

Actually, I beg to differ on the QB AWR asseveration... USER QB AWR determines how "smart" the CPU is when defending... Low AWR QBs face a tougher / smarter D than a high AWR QB... It's easy to test... Take a team like the Pats or Packers, set up to play with the starter, then switch to the backup and observe... More guys open / wider throw windows... Anyway: Played with Crompton for 3 seasons and I have to say, he's my ideal QB... Low AWR (challenge) and a rocket arm (96 THP?)... Throws on the run well and runs out of a rollout nicely... Since he's a "C" potential, he doesn't really progress...so that's a plus to me as well... As you get better at the game, using him, learning the plays that work best, etc...the results get better due to USER skill, as opposed to jacked progression... Best part? Crompton has no career stats, so any stats you accumulate using him are "your" stats... Haven't enjoyed a rookie / journeyman QB this much in Madden since P. Ramsey was drafted into the Spurrier era 'Skins...

I wouldn't choose the packers for that experiment, flynn has fairly high awareness. Use pats or saints.

[Kahuma]

Quote: Originally Posted by KingV2k3

Since he's a "C" potential, he doesn't really progress...so that's a plus to me as well...

This is incorrect, Crompton is a 'D' potention, not a C.

As for the OP, I typically keep Crompton on my roster and release Beck. Unless you start Beck he's useless after the first season because he always degresses.

Crompton has a nice throw on the run rating and a good arm, but I've never used him extensively and I would think Hanie would be a better option potential-wise.

But we all know OVR is nothing but a number so I would just test them out and see who plays best.

[KingV2k3]

Quote: Originally Posted by Kahuma

This is incorrect, Crompton is a 'D' potention, not a C. As for the OP, I typically keep Crompton on my roster and release Beck. Unless you start Beck he's useless after the first season because he always degresses. Crompton has a nice throw on the run rating and a good arm, but I've never used him extensively and I would think Hanie would be a better option potential-wise. But we all know OVR is nothing but a number so I would just test them out and see who plays best.

My bad!

I thought he was a "C"...

Regardless, the high THP and the fact you can run over some tacklers with this guy gives him a lot of upside, IMHO...

That and the fact that he currently has no "career stats", so he's a virtual rookie...

[jberrybasketball30]

Take Crompton, better arm

[J.R.]

Haine, better awarness and the toned down throw power works well with the accuracy. No sense in him throwing deep balls if it's gonna go too far.