Madden NFL 13 Video Interview - EA Tiburon Breaks Down Some of the New Changes

[Smoke6]

Quote: Originally Posted by CRMosier_LM

I see exactly what both sides are saying. While I am not a free-style player I REFUSE to call myself Sim basically just because Sim to me is not longer simulating the game, to me Sim is removing elements from the game that make it football because we don't agree with it or want to adapt to it. I play "realistic football" as much as humanly possible. @Roadman I know exactly where you are coming from with the Shields comment. But would the Packers drop him back to prevent something they are having problems with?!? They MOST CERTAINLY would... Or else they would lose due to refusing to adjust. @whoever That IS NFL Football, my Gameplan vs your Gameplan and who can make the correct adjustments and execute. That my friends is what football is at its basics. It happens every play, every day, every game in the NFL. Simply calling the play and expecting it to work is hogwash and NO NFL team does that or realistically expects that. But unfortunately that is what happens too often with the "Sim" community. Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk 2

I can't agree with this at all, the reason being is that we in the Sim communities try to eliminate the temptation of doing things we know fu well are broken but have very successful results kn madden regardless of the coverage.

If it wasn't for the blatant abuse of curl routes being used to achieve a first down and you are showing a pattern of relying on this most of the game, then it becomes and issue. Curl routes are not easily defendable, as there are several Sim leagues and communities who have started to ban this route.

Remember the 4 curls people were running in madden 09 out of snugs? It still happens to this day.

But its hard taking someone's word when they don't even bother indulging in the pub room games to begin with. I mean at this point Cm and whoever else doesn't play online, what what would it hurt to get online for a few hours in the play now and see for yourself?

If you still feel the same afterwards then heh, not much for me to say, but I feel a lot of people on this "its all moot" mentality don't even bother seeing for themselves. You act like we pulling stuff up out of thin air and that's not the case.

But tell me how would you feel if I just told you to just stop playing madden altogether if you're gonna come back at me with "then don't play online join a Sim group".

[sgibs7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Big FN Deal

And that's where you completely lose me and we are no longer talking about trying to simulate NFL football. Reason being NFL penalties are not enforced as a result of wins and losses, their enforcement or lack thereof impact those outcomes. Using your logic holding, face masks, false starts, late hits, roughing the passer and block in the back don't matter to game outcomes either so it's fine if they are allowed to happen in Madden too. The main thing that separates the NFL from the CFL, XFL, Arena, freestyle ball and every other brand of football, is it's rules, which include penalties. So whenever a competition or video game has a rule set not reasonably enforcing applicable NFL parameters or allows freestyle play as you put it, that's not attempting to simulate playing NFL football. Freestyle ball is it's own brand of football and that's fine but I don't understand trying to insist it somehow attempts to simulate NFL football in Madden, when it obviously doesn't.

i want madden to be realistic and IMO its pretty darn good at doing that.

i also play madden for what its worth a game. I simply just dont adhere to the same guidelines as you or others.

im not a bad person for that. im not inferior to anyone because of that. I choose to play a certain way that best fits my enjoyment of the game.

[sgibs7]

Quote: Originally Posted by rgiles36

These two posts above best sum up my feelings on the matter. On the other hand, I'm not sure why this discussion is continuing on. It's just a regurgitation of the same points with neither side giving up any ground. Someone has to wave the white flag, no? LOL

im like the energizer bunny - i just keep going & going & going hahaha

[sgibs7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Illustrator76

This is where I bow out. This line of reasoning is based off of a completely different reality than I currently live in. The day I see the Lions hot routing 5-6 defensive players, re-blitzing Defensive Tackles and nano blitzing A-gaps is the day I stop watching football. Period. I am talking REAL football strategy, not "perceived" Madden football strategy. I say this all the time, the cats that do all of this crazy BS with their plays in Madden swear up and down that they are Mike Martz or Buddy Ryan, but they aren't, nor should they ever feel that they are even close to "scheming" like those guys (I really can't stress this enough). They are borderline cheesers that take advantage of glitches and poor programming in a fundamentally broken "football" game. Nothing more.

i feel the same way when I hear "i play a legit scheme that you see on Sundays".

none of us are NFL players or coaches (there might be someone hiding somewhere thats laughing at this and secretly saying to himself, i am)

but that statement works both ways.

I try and make this game better by talking about and explaining all the exploits you see and why they need to be removed.

im on board with what you guys want - i just play differently then you guys do.

[sgibs7]

Quote: Originally Posted by Illustrator76

See, this is my point exactly, you are arguing with someone who either doesn't understand or care about REAL football match-ups and strategy, only what seems logical in Madden. Put Shields in center field because he is fast and will get 30 picks a year. Run support? What is that mess? What is his awareness and aptitude to play safety? What if he makes the wrong decision? Aaahhhhh, who cares, he's fast, let's go with it. Ugh. I'm out.

I user control him...so in theory his awr is 100 haha - prolly a 99 not sure im that aware

[sgibs7]

Quote: Originally Posted by therealsmallville

Probably not my business to jump in...but I'm going to do it anyway :-) (please bear with me here) Go back a few months to the Super Bowl. Last play of the game. Brady heaves it downfield, in a last ditch effort. Now, did Belichick & Brady call up that play hoping to score a touchdown? Absolutely, you hope every play turns into a TD. But another reason QB's will chuck a ball into a crowd of players is they are hoping for DPI. To get one more play, much closer to the endzone. I guarantee you the Pats were praying for DPI almost as much as they were a miraculous TD. This is part of NFL strategy. Playing against the CPU, this strategy doesn't exist for me. The way I have my sliders adjusted, I do lose games to the cpu. Often, when trailing with 10 seconds left, I'll heave one deep hoping for that DPI. It's never called, even when instant reply shows there was clearly illegal contact made by the DB. I have a buddy who laughs at me sometimes for wanting penalties. He also likes 56-7 scores and stat fests while playing as the Dolphins. My opinion, and only my opinion, is that if he wants to score 50+ every game with no penalties en route to a 16-0 season, he should go play Blitz. Give me penalties. Give me a 12-4, 10-6 season. LET ME LOSE A GAME because an AI controlled DB on my team did something stupid, putting the cpu on my 1 with a go-ahead TD. This is SIM. This is "Everything You See On Sunday". This should be Madden.

jump in whenever man - everyones allowed a voice and opinion.

what you are saying is totally valid - i was praying for a PI on that play.

i thought gronk caught it at first and i went absolute nuts and then realized that my Pats fell to the Giants once again on the big stage

[therealsmallville]

Quote: Originally Posted by sgibs7

i feel the same way when I hear "i play a legit scheme that you see on Sundays". none of us are NFL players or coaches (there might be someone hiding somewhere thats laughing at this and secretly saying to himself, i am) but that statement works both ways. I try and make this game better by talking about and explaining all the exploits you see and why they need to be removed. im on board with what you guys want - i just play differently then you guys do.

Hampering the speed of a WR with a DB on the way to the ball, and not getting flagged for it, pretty much is an exploit though.

[Big FN Deal]

Quote: Originally Posted by sgibs7

i want madden to be realistic and IMO its pretty darn good at doing that. i also play madden for what its worth a game. I simply just dont adhere to the same guidelines as you or others. im not a bad person for that. im not inferior to anyone because of that. I choose to play a certain way that best fits my enjoyment of the game.

C'mon Sgibs, don't throw out red herrings like that, no one is implying any of that other stuff, what I am saying is you are not attempting or enforcing reasonably realistic NFL game play in Madden, even though that is the alleged function of the game.

You don't have to and not doing so does not put you beneath me or make you bad peoples. However, it does mean that you are exploiting a game that is alleged to be designed to attempt to emulate NFL football, when you intentionally do not do so.