With the game basically out already, I decided not to do a full CD impression on RTTS (just because it would sound very lame), but there are a couple of things that I could get directly from the devs (Kirby@SCEA in particular) so I'll just post a few for records.
As mentioned in the blog and by other guys with the game already, there have been some changes to the specific goals that you get for advancement goals..... Those mainly are to remove unrealistic ones, like fielding goals (asking for a 1.000 FPCT....one error and you are done...so it's out....), pitcher no longer getting batting oriented goals, no walk-related goals, etc.
Also, under the hood, the logic has been improved in a way to alleviate the inconsistency between how you are performing on the field and not achieving goals..... like if you are tearing up as a hitter, you won't be penalized as harshly for not achieving certain goals. It's under the hood so you might not notice this clearly, but if we won't be hearing one of the most frequent complaints about RTTS in this regard (WTF the manager doing sitting me down for not doing bunting, when I'm hittin .568 with 8736 HRs before the All Star break ......... just an example), then it may be this improvement in action.
There hasn't been much AI logic changes with regard to player transaction... but you should be given more opportunities to ask for trade, for example, when the time is right (a good player in a losing team, for example).... another under the hood change. There have been a lot of brainstorming going on as to in which direction the mode is going to move ... and something like forcing a trade is also being considered ..... just mentioning this since so many guys just seem to want to play for a specific team... I like reality of having dreams not being fulfilled (yes I'm a very bitter person), so I love being traded to the Seattle Mariners when I really want to play in NYC.... but I was very impressed how receptive SCEA was to our feedback.
As you might remember, Kirby has been actively collecting feedback on the RTTS mode, and will continue to do so. Just because you haven't seen any improvement in the areas that you gave feedback for this year doesn't mean your voices have not been heard...... the devs are around here more than we think....
As the developer, SCEA still needs to balance options vs. authenticity, intention vs. customizability, etc., but once you play the mode it is very clear the RTTS mode has been reborn and there are a wide array of possibilities ahead.... very exciting. and it's basically Kirby's first year (?) effort...... how nice is that??
Personally, I really like the way the new RTTS mode recreates the baseball atmosphere... I know most people just want to quickly advance to MLB without taking much time in each game, but to make the most of the new RTTS, I urge you to play some of your most important games in your careers in fuller watch modes (all pitches, or results play...), watching how your players perform on the field around you, and from the dugout when your team is hitting. Looking at plays unfolding in front of you in that way, make you kinda remember your playing days, watching teammates, waiting for your turn.
Yes the mode highlight you better this year with the new presentations, but it's also how you perform within the context of how your teammates play that actually enhances the experience as well...... the team *needs* you to hit in this situation... but what led to that situation?? okay, down one run, and you walked after a 10-pitch at bat... now pray that your teammates follows up!
... and cheer for your teammates from the dugout! see your team's No. 1 hitter slugging one into the dusk in a minor league stadium! it's beautiful and immersive, and a very personal experinece.
... . and that's what I love about the new RTTS gameplay change this year. Kirby, once a college ballplayer himself, obviously knows how it feels like to be a player in a baseball team. I wasn't expecting the mode to evolve in this way but I'm very thankful it did! I love the new fielding camera and the dugout view so much.......... hahaha.