MLB 24 The Show Greatest Teams Roster 1975-2024 V. 2

[MysterioMan007]

Quote: Originally Posted by Phantom Fighter

I know you had a reason for setting the cutoff at 75 but if there is anyway you’d consider moving it just one year that 72-74 As team (74 version to bend the rule the least) would be so amazing. If the rule is unbeatable the 75 team was still good and would be appreciated over the moneyball pretenders. If not since you’re already doing a v3 list

I picked 75 because that was the year I was born. It's basically an "in my lifetime" rule. But that 74 A's team is outstanding. I'll have to think on it. The 2002 team, I believe, is the Moneyball team portrayed in the Brad Pitt movie, so they're pretty famous as well. But i do think the 1974 team was better. I'll put one in this roster and then the other in next, though I don't know which just yet...

[bostongahden]

I'm very nostalgic with rosters as well and love making classic team sets. When I make the move to 24, I'll definitely check these out. I'm still enjoying 23 as I made all decade sets for the 70s and 80s. Thanks for your efforts.

[SashaBanksFan4Ever]

Wish 2003 Yanks and Red Sox were in here.

[MysterioMan007]

Quote: Originally Posted by SashaBanksFan4Ever

Wish 2003 Yanks and Red Sox were in here.

The 2004 Red Sox were in the first set and, unless you're just a huge fan of Todd Walker, it's pretty much the same team. I chose the 2007 team this time because they had a lot of different guys (Josh Beckett, Dustin Pedroia, Daisuke) that weren't with them in 2004 and those 2000s Boston Red Sox teams brought me back to baseball after being away for many years and made me a fan again. The Yankees are my least favorite team in history, but it seems people want the '70s nostalgia, so they will get that in this one and the 2009 team will be in the next one.

[SashaBanksFan4Ever]

Quote: Originally Posted by MysterioMan007

The 2004 Red Sox were in the first set and, unless you're just a huge fan of Todd Walker, it's pretty much the same team. I chose the 2007 team this time because they had a lot of different guys (Josh Beckett, Dustin Pedroia, Daisuke) that weren't with them in 2004 and those 2000s Boston Red Sox teams brought me back to baseball after being away for many years and made me a fan again. The Yankees are my least favorite team in history, but it seems people want the '70s nostalgia, so they will get that in this one and the 2009 team will be in the next one.

Ok, yay for 2009. Yanks my mlb team and pats nfl and Lakers in the nba.