List of Classic Seasons & Historical Specialty Rosters MLB The Show

[The Gamer]

.Screenshot_20241231_145311_Xbox.jpg

Sent from my SM-S928U using Tapatalk

[vertman]

Quote: Originally Posted by The Gamer

On the rebrand version, I swapped Cubs and Braves, Cardinals and Marlins, Reds and Rockies, and Astros and DBacks. I wanted to have Cubs and Cardinals back in the NL East, Reds and Astros back in the NL West. Braves had to go to the NL Central with the Pirates due to limitations. The process was just swapping all the players in the player movement prior to starting a franchise. Sent from my SM-S928U using Tapatalk

Great. Thank you for the explanation.

[vertman]

Quote: Originally Posted by Armor and Sword

So I am using his non Rebrand version where you just need to rebrand Tampa and Arizona to the Brewers and Astros respectively....I explained what i did on that file in my 23 slider thread.

Got it. Thank you!

[ripcandlestickpark]

dallmanator uploaded the most recent version of his Franchise Stars roster on NYE. Just about every team looks to be full from the Majors to Class-A.

[Armor and Sword]

OP updated.

I am personally working on equipment edit for that 1991 roster. Will take me a few weeks. This is for a single season replay using CPU roster control (no injuries no trades) or post season mode.

Mr Met has begun his updated modern roster for the 2025 season. He typically updates it often so keep watching the vault into Spring training. I used his 2024 updated roster for MLB 23 for a single season franchise season and loved it.

[bostongahden]

I hope to do a greatest teams set this coming spring. I'm thinking of doing it on MLB 24 as I might pick that up on the cheap this spring. I'm going back to staying a year behind on The Show especially with the lack of improvements offered in franchise mode. I'm big into NHL 25 right now as I've recently finished a classic team edition for season play and having a blast. Best edition of the series in a while! If you are into hockey, check out my thread here on OS > https://forums.operationsports.com/f...sic-teams.html

[Armor and Sword]

Quote: Originally Posted by bostongahden

I hope to do a greatest teams set this coming spring. I'm thinking of doing it on MLB 24 as I might pick that up on the cheap this spring. I'm going back to staying a year behind on The Show especially with the lack of improvements offered in franchise mode. I'm big into NHL 25 right now as I've recently finished a classic team edition for season play and having a blast. Best edition of the series in a while! If you are into hockey, check out my thread here on OS > https://forums.operationsports.com/f...sic-teams.html

24 kicks *** Boston!!! Your NHL roster is sweet!!! And yes NHL 25 is a terrific game.

MLB 24 is now bringing the heat with classic rosters!!!! Love to see it!!!

[Armor and Sword]

Quote: Originally Posted by bostongahden

I hope to do a greatest teams set this coming spring. I'm thinking of doing it on MLB 24 as I might pick that up on the cheap this spring. I'm going back to staying a year behind on The Show especially with the lack of improvements offered in franchise mode. I'm big into NHL 25 right now as I've recently finished a classic team edition for season play and having a blast. Best edition of the series in a while! If you are into hockey, check out my thread here on OS > https://forums.operationsports.com/f...sic-teams.html

That is great to hear Boston. I have fallen head over heals in love with MLB 24 and I will also more than likely be holding back till at least the summer before I jump to 25 for a modern day franchise. There is just too many great classic rosters now I want to dive into on 24. By the summer a much better current day roster will be available for 25 than using the OOTB rosters.

I hope to see the Electric 80’s first on 24 since we don’t have any real 80’s exposure yet on 24!!!


Also if anyone knows of other really well done classics I have not listed for 24 on the OP please post here so I can check em out.