Lol great username, I am using the Royals in my franchise even though I have no real attachment and I live in Boston. It was mainly because I love Jeremy Guthrie, but he retired after 2015
But back on topic I really don't think it's the competition. 2014 playoffs I got smashed by the Mariners and they didn't have any particularly good hitters, so I thought it was a difficulty spike. 2015 I got absolutely hammered by the Angels who did have a sick lineup, so I thought the Mariners stuff was just a weird thing like whatever they were hot. 2016 I am playing the As, who have a merely decent lineup, and they are all over everything, finding gaps, fouling everything off, etc. Waaaaaay different than playing them in the regular season.