Create a fighter should be able to have a higher overall rating than 58... the career mode is too long to create every guy that I want in the game...
that is the only good thing about the Super CAF - I don't even play online, but enjoy the fact that I don't have to go thru career mode each time I want to create someone.
It is too long to make the CAF you want. If you make one good one, though, copy him the week before your career is over and you can make a lot of CAFS. I have like 6 83 rating cafs from that, i wouldnt consider them super CAFS but its nice.