NBA 2k15 Information Train

[RogerBlack]

Quote: Originally Posted by turty11

if melo is a 90, then these rosters are no better than any other 2k rosters.

Melo was the 2nd leading scorer all season this year 2013-14.
Ahead of Lebron James, in 3rd place.

And the year before (2012-13) .. Melo won the scoring title.

So he's been top 2 (in scoring) for 2 years straight now.

So why shouldn't he get at least 90 with those stats?

[SoAwesome]

Quote: Originally Posted by RogerBlack

Melo was the 2nd leading scorer all season this year 2013-14. Ahead of Lebron James, in 3rd place. And the year before (2012-13) .. Melo won the scoring title. So he's been top 2 (in scoring) for 2 years straight now. So why shouldn't he get at least 90 with those stats?

We're not going to take your opinion seriously. You mentioned Kawhi and Kyrie as Top 4/5 player.

[RogerBlack]

Quote: Originally Posted by kurt2134

Kawhi...?

Quote: Originally Posted by kurt2134

I agree with you on that. Honestly, I just stopped reading at Kawhi.

Quote: Originally Posted by SoAwesome

We're not going to take your opinion seriously. You mentioned Kawhi and Kyrie as Top 4/5 player.

Kwahi was arguably the best defender in the league, this year. (or top 3, at worst)
Yes, you read that right. The best defender. On the best team. THIS year. Hands down.

Spurs crushed Miami in the finals.
They didn't just beat them.
They crushed them. Literally.

In ONLY 5 games.
With 4 BLOWOUT victories.

And Kwahi's defense played a MAJOR part.

So if defense means ANYTHING in 2K15... he could possibly get a 90, or 91 rating, at least.

Unless folks are just looking at scoring, assists & rebounds, that is.
And could care less about defense & hustle.

Time will tell.

[turty11]

being the 2nd scorer in the NBA doesnt make you an overall elite player lol.

defense/passing count too

[RogerBlack]

Quote: Originally Posted by turty11

being the 2nd scorer in the NBA doesnt make you an overall elite player lol. defense/passing count too

Melo won the scoring title just a year ago.
He dropped the MOST buckets. On EVERYBODY. No Exceptions.

Then came in 2nd..... a year later.

Does that count?

Does that make him 'elite', in your opinion?

[kurt2134]

Quote: Originally Posted by RogerBlack

Kwahi was arguably the best defender in the league, this year. (or top 3, at worst) Yes, you read that right. The best defender. On the best team. THIS year. Hands down. Spurs crushed Miami in the finals. They didn't just beat them. They crushed them. Literally. In ONLY 5 games. With 4 BLOWOUT victories. And Kwahi's defense played a MAJOR part. So if defense means ANYTHING in 2K15... he could possibly get a 90, or 91 rating, at least. Unless folks are just looking at scoring, assists & rebounds, that is. And could care less about defense & hustle.

Dude, his team winning had nothing to do with his individual rating and regardless of him being a top defender, he is nowhere near a top player offensively. A rating of 90 or above means you excell in several categories. Are you seriously going to say that Kawhi is one of the 4 best players in the league?

Don't even get me started on Kyrie.

[turty11]

well. i dont feel like debating rating vs rating/ player vs player here, thats what the roster section is for.

i dont think we can ask if kawhi or these other guys are "top 4" players.

probably not, but since when does what 2k gives for an OVR dictate where someone ranks in the actual NBA

[hristi]

Quote: Originally Posted by RogerBlack

Kwahi was arguably the best defender in the league, this year. (or top 3, at worst) Yes, you read that right. The best defender. On the best team. THIS year. Hands down. Spurs crushed Miami in the finals. They didn't just beat them. They crushed them. Literally. In ONLY 5 games. With 4 BLOWOUT victories. And Kwahi's defense played a MAJOR part. So if defense means ANYTHING in 2K15... he could possibly get a 90, or 91 rating, at least. Unless folks are just looking at scoring, assists & rebounds, that is. And could care less about defense & hustle. Time will tell.

Yes I can see he defended LeBron really well.