Official - Is This Trade GOOD? Thread

[DieHardYankee26]

what trade exactly are you trying to do cocobee?

[amr247]

Ok guys well here is what down with my Chi-Town Bulls

My orginal trade can be seen as the first post but after a few opinions i decided i had to retrade because I saved my first trade.

my new trade is here..(Please remember i already did the previous trade.)

Bulls Trade:

Warrick - GS
Walker - GS

Memphis Trade:

Bellinelli - GS
Harrington - CHI

Warriors Trade:

Gooden - Mem
Morrow - Mem


So the Trade worked out pretty well. GS got a PF that is young, explosive, and fast. They recieved a decent outside shot from Walker.

Memphis got a post up PF in gooden and a up and comer SG Morrow.

Chi gets a great PF that orignally wanted to be traded anyway.

What do you guys think of this one?

[Ferrari997]

I guess it's good. Harrington doesn't really give the Bulls what they need as he isn't much of a post presence. He is more of a 3 pt shooting PF.

[idrisguitar]

in my mavs assoc is dampier + singleton + 2nd round pick FOR nene

a good trade?

nuggets will get a slightly better defensive presence, and i improve my offense while lowering the age of my team (the AI accepted this trade, although i didn't save it)

what do you think

[cocobee]

Quote: Originally Posted by DieHardYankee26

what trade exactly are you trying to do cocobee?

I figured it out, I had to quit my team and be another team, do the trade, quit and go back to my team. Funny thing is, Iverson didn't want to be traded! I had to force the trade.

[amr247]

Quote: Originally Posted by idrisguitar

in my mavs assoc is dampier + singleton + 2nd round pick FOR nene a good trade? nuggets will get a slightly better defensive presence, and i improve my offense while lowering the age of my team (the AI accepted this trade, although i didn't save it) what do you think

That seems like a pretty good trade...seems fair to me

[JBH3]

Quote: Originally Posted by Freezer Boy

I'd like to hear some of your opinions on a trade I'm considering. I already tried it and it works but then I turned off the game because I wasn't sure if it was realistic. Raptors get: PG Marcus Williams SG Marco Bellinelli Warriors get: 2009 1st rd pick SF Jamario Moon PG Roko Ukic SG Hassan Adams I'm the Raptors. I don't think it's too bad but I just wasn't sure if it was realistic or not.

Why would you want to give up your best perimeter defender and a #1 for another shooter when you have Parker and Kapono? Like someone else said you're giving up way too much. I don't like this deal if I'm the Raptors - at all.

Quote: Originally Posted by idrisguitar

im thinking of trading terry for a good young SG. OJ mayo seems a target because the team will gain an experienced shooter who can play point in terry and will definitely improve them in the short term. would you say this trade isa good or not? any other suggestion for a young SG. i have wright, but he is not doing so well. and green cant hit a perimeter shot at the moment.

NOT - Look...In no way would a young developing team like Memphis want to give away their future for a vet - especially one like Jason Terry - who doesn't really give them anything they don't already have or can develop.

OJ should stay put in Memphis.

Quote: Originally Posted by cocobee

I figured it out, I had to quit my team and be another team, do the trade, quit and go back to my team. Funny thing is, Iverson didn't want to be traded! I had to force the trade.

You didn't have to quit your team and do all of that. In fact I would've advised against it, since if you're playing w/ Team Chemistry on doing this throws everything out of whack.

All you needed to do was a 3 team trade, including your team, and swapping 2nd rounders w/ one of the teams.

I did the 3-team trade, but traded Willie Green to Denver for Chucky Atkins and Detroit's 2009 2nd rd pick.

In my assoc. I'm using the 'Big 3' rosters so I had Cheick Samb included from Detroit, and Denver had enough players signed to 1 yr deals to send back to Detroit to allow the trade to go thru (Smush Parker and Chris Anderson).

You would've also needed to edit Iverson's & McD's contracts; Iverson's going down and McD's going up. I made them according to what ESPN stated their 2009 salary to be, and the deals went thru w/ no problem.

[oldman]

Quote: Originally Posted by JBH3

Why would you want to give up your best perimeter defender and a #1 for another shooter when you have Parker and Kapono? Like someone else said you're giving up way too much. I don't like this deal if I'm the Raptors - at all. NOT - Look...In no way would a young developing team like Memphis want to give away their future for a vet - especially one like Jason Terry - who doesn't really give them anything they don't already have or can develop. OJ should stay put in Memphis. You didn't have to quit your team and do all of that. In fact I would've advised against it, since if you're playing w/ Team Chemistry on doing this throws everything out of whack. All you needed to do was a 3 team trade, including your team, and swapping 2nd rounders w/ one of the teams. I did the 3-team trade, but traded Willie Green to Denver for Chucky Atkins and Detroit's 2009 2nd rd pick. In my assoc. I'm using the 'Big 3' rosters so I had Cheick Samb included from Detroit, and Denver had enough players signed to 1 yr deals to send back to Detroit to allow the trade to go thru (Smush Parker and Chris Anderson). You would've also needed to edit Iverson's & McD's contracts; Iverson's going down and McD's going up. I made them according to what ESPN stated their 2009 salary to be, and the deals went thru w/ no problem.

Man that is a great idea. I have been trying to figure out how to get this deal into my association without starting all over. I am going to try this as soon as I get home as the Thunder.