NCAA 2014 2015-16 Roster (PS3)

[Her89Man]

Quote: Originally Posted by muckcity

Lol this might be asking for to much but can you put the in a list like mine, its easier to read lol

I'm trying lol.... dunno whats going on! Edit: I'm at work on a old computer. Will try to fix this list when I get home!

[WeWereGiants]

Quote: Originally Posted by Her89Man

Ratings are so tricky! Everyone has a different opinion of certain players. For me the top 25 RBs are: 1. Zeke Elliott - Ohio State - 95ovr 2. James Conner - Pitt - 94ovr 3. Nick Chubb - Georgia - 93ovr 4. Samaje Perine - Oklahoma - 92ovr 5. Derrick Henry - Alabama - 91ovr 6. Alex Collins - Arkansas - 90ovr 7. Royce Freeman - Oregon - 90ovr 8. Leonard Fournette - LSU - 90ovr 9. Donnell Pumphrey - San Diego State - 90ovr 10. Paul Perkins - UCLA - 90ovr 11. Jonathon Williams - Arkansas - 90ovr 12. Nick Wilson - Arizona - 89ovr 13. Dalvin Cook - FSU - 89ovr 14. Devontae Booker - UTAH - 89ovr 15. Corey Clement - Wisconsin - 89ovr 16. Shock Linwood - Baylor - 88ovr 17. Devon Johnson - Marshall - 88ovr 18. Aaron Green - TCU - 88ovr 19. Storm Woods - Oregon State - 88ovr 20. Kareem Hunt - Toledo -87ovr 21. Jordan Howard - Indiana - 87ovr (Was at UAB) 22. Kenneth Dixon - LA Tech - 87ovr 23. Marteze Waller - Fresno State - 87ovr 24. DJ Foster - Arizona State - 87ovr 25. Jarvion Franklin - 86ovr There are a ton of other guys as well that could sneak on this list: Jalen Hurd - Tennessee Russell Hansbrough - Missouri Jon Hilliman - Boston College Shadrach Thornton - NC State Tarean Folston - Notre Dame Marlon Mack - USF Anthone Taylor - Buffalo Leon Allen - Western Kentucky Aaron Jones - UTEP Elijah McGuire - UL Lafayette Kenneth Farrow - Houston Justin Jackson - Northwestern Travis Greene - Bowling Green Daniel Lasco - Cal Jacobi Owens - Air Force DeAndre Washington - Texas Tech

Reformatted for my own benefit

[muckcity]

Quote: Originally Posted by WeWereGiants

Reformatted for my own benefit

thanks big dog, i like the list, what do you guys think of both of the list, it don't matter to me, i want the best roster

[Her89Man]

Quote: Originally Posted by WeWereGiants

Reformatted for my own benefit

Appreciate it man!

[redlands2]

Great list. My thoughts and view. Pure eye test thing.

I think Booker RB at Utah is too low based on eye test. Why? Look at his team and what he able to do in 2nd best conference team depth wise in CFB with suspect QB. He is a future NFL player.

Fornette of LSU he is just as good as Collins if not better.

Cook of FSU is explosive, and an elusive running back. Should be higher on list.

Think Chubb is too high on this list. He is good but that good yet. He is not in the same league as Gurley was and their was big drop off although he looked good.

Jalen Hurd should be on this list. He will be monster impact RB next year in same line of production as Collin/Williams duo.

Quote: Originally Posted by muckcity

Me and Jack started talking the other day about making a list of the top 25 players at each position and get feed back, so the next could times i post will be a list and i would like to get some football back, it will show the players name and the rating we think he should be. TOP 25 RB 1. Ezekiel Elliot 95 Ovr 2. Nick Chubb 93 Ovr 3. Alex Collins 93 Ovr 4. Javorius Allen 92 Ovr 5. James Conner 92 Ovr 6. Derrick Henry 91 Ovr 7. DJ Foster 91 Ovr 8. Samajae Perine 91 Ovr 9. Paul Perkins 91 Ovr 10. Dalvin Cook 91 Ovr 11. Leonard Fournette 91 Ovr 12. Royce Freeman 90 Ovr 13. Nick Wilson 90 Ovr 14. Jonathan Williams 90 Ovr 15. Shock Linwood 90 Ovr 16. Kelvin Taylor 89 Ovr 17. Bj Catalon 89 Ovr 18. Kenyan Drake 89 Ovr 19. Storm Woods 89 Ovr 20. Tra Carson 88 Ovr 21. Donnel Pumphrey 88 Ovr 22. Devontae Booker 87 Ovr 23. Aaron Green 87 Ovr 24. Jarvion Franklin 86 Ovr 25. Jonathan Gray 86 Ovr THOUGHTS????

[redlands2]

Regarding recruits taken from article on SB Nation recruiting site.

The 2015 class seems to be a bit down overall compared to some previous years, like the standout 2014 crop. But teams with needs at specific positions can still find future stars.
Strengths

One of the best positions of 2015 is defensive tackle. Kahlil McKenzie (Tennessee commitment) and Trent Thompson (Georgia commitment) are top-notch prospects. McKenzie is 6'4, close to 350 pounds and not sloppily fat, which is amazing for a player of his age and weight. And both have incredible explosion relative to their size. And players the caliber of Breiden Fehoko (Texas Tech), Jacob Daniel (USC), Neville Gallimore (Oklahoma) and Tim Settle (Virginia Tech commitment) being ranked further down in the top 15 speaks to the depth of the position this year.

Cornerback is also strong this year, with Iman Marshall (uncommitted), Kevin Toliver II (LSU), Kendall Sheffield (Alabama), Tarvarus McFadden (Florida State) and Minkah Fitzpatrick (Alabama) one of the best top-five corner groups in recent memory.

Perhaps most importantly, the class is strong with quarterbacks, including Jarrett Stidham (Baylor), Kyler Murray (Texas A&M), Brandon Wimbush (Notre Dame), Josh Rosen (UCLA), Blake Barnett (Alabama), Ricky Town (USC) and Deondre Francois (Florida State). Unfortunately for teams on the East Coast, only seven of the 23 quarterbacks rated four-stars or better are from east of the Mississippi, meaning that those schools had to try to import some West Coast prospects (as Alabama did, landing Barnett from California), settle for a lesser recruit from back home, or pass on the position.


Weaknesses

One glaring weakness of the class is at running back. In 2014, six running backs were rated five-stars by the 247Sports Composite, including LSU's Leonard Fournette and Georgia's Nick Chubb. In 2015, there are just two, uncommitted SoSo Jamabo and Alabama's Damien Harris, and both are fringe five-stars.

2014 is looking like it will go down as one of the best classes of running backs in the history of college football, so comparing 2015 to it might not be completely fair, but it's still clear that the running backs for 2015 are a lesser group than what even the average year offers.
Another area where the class doesn't measure up is at offensive tackle. The 2014 class featured players like Alabama's Cameron Robinson, Florida State's Roderick Johnson and Miami's Kc McDermott, all of whom started a lot of games and played well relative to their youth. Robinson was debated as the best offensive tackle recruit of the last decade. The 2013 class had Laremy Tunsil at the top, an immediate starter for the Ole Miss Rebels.

The 2015 crop, however, is headlined by uncommitted Martez Ivey, of Apopka (Fla.), who is not on that level. Ivey is a fantastic athlete, but is 6'5, 275 and plays in a wing-T-type offense that offers him almost no opportunities to work on his pass protection. He may become a great college player, but he's not the instant-impact type found in the previous two classes.

[redlands2]

I would really interested in see how you guys rank top 25 QB

Know whoever going to be FSU QB should be 80's because of what Fisher can do with QB's as coach. Also if Kiffen is still at Bama whoever is their starter will be solid QB as well. Same rule for Baylor next QB.

[bigbob]

Muck, can you go through and redo the numbers for the freshman ratings you have? Numbers don't match up. Such as the #131 player is a 5.9, however you have that being a 5.8 guy and an overall lower.