Madden 12 or NCAA 12 for coach mode?

[DirtyJerz32]

Just wanted to get everyone's opinion here. I'm looking to not get pissed off, but still play. Any thoughts?

What's the pros & cons of each?

[DirtyJerz32]

I guess no body plays coach mode>

[Fieldersman99]

Pros/Cons of madden 12's coach mode:
Pros:
plays realistically
cons:
gameflow calls the oddest plays
you still have control over players (ex you can still pass by hitting buttons)
here at OS, only 1 slider set is a coach mode set (Elway7)
NCAA 12
pros: also plays realistically
you call plays, the cpu runs them
there are 3 slider sets here that support coach mode
cons:
dont know since i only have M12

[DirtyJerz32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Fieldersman99

Pros/Cons of madden 12's coach mode: Pros: plays realistically cons: gameflow calls the oddest plays you still have control over players (ex you can still pass by hitting buttons) here at OS, only 1 slider set is a coach mode set (Elway7) NCAA 12 pros: also plays realistically you call plays, the cpu runs them there are 3 slider sets here that support coach mode cons: dont know since i only have M12

Thanks for the being the first to post. I've read that you still have to kick and what not in Madden, SMH, but I do like the off-season additions and franchise mode. I got bored trying to sign kids in NCAA.

Thanks again!

[Fiddy]

just set your recruiting to auto etc..

[DirtyJerz32]

Quote: Originally Posted by Fiddy

just set your recruiting to auto etc..

I did that for my playing dynasty, but it seemed as if I never got any good classes. Usually I was in the mid pack even though I was playing with PSU.