Kurt Warner a better QB than Peyton Manning

[bkrich83]

Player A in 15 post season games is 7-8, has 22 TD's, 17 INT's. a YPA of 7.4 and a QB rating of 84.9

Player B in 10 post season games is 8-2, has 23 TD's, 12 INT's, a YPA of 8.3 and a QB rating of 97.3

Who has been the better QB in the post season?

[Scottdau]

Quote: Originally Posted by bkrich83

Player A in 15 post season games is 7-8, has 22 TD's, 17 INT's. a YPA of 7.4 and a QB rating of 84.9 Player B in 10 post season games is 8-2, has 23 TD's, 12 INT's, a YPA of 8.3 and a QB rating of 97.3 Who has been the better QB in the post season?

Oh I know player B! Any ways this is a pretty good debate. If he wins another Super Bowl he can be right up there with Manning. Once Upton a time Kurt was the best QB for a couple of years too.

[ProfessaPackMan]

But BK, "Stats don't tell the whole story because Manning had to play outside and he didn't have tall WRs like Moss and Fitzgerald. He was stuck with a slow Reggie Wayne and an old Marvin Harrison."

[z Revis]

PLAYERS PLAY DIFFERENT ON DIFFERENT TEAMS AND IN DIFFERENT SITUATIONS. Put Manning on those Rams and have him play nice and snug on his Dome Homefield turf...he'd do the exact same thing. When at home, Peyton has played amazing in the Playoffs including a PERFECT rating against Denver.

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by ProfessaPackMan

But BK, "Stats don't tell the whole story because Manning had to play outside and he didn't have tall WRs like Moss and Fitzgerald. He was stuck with a slow Reggie Wayne and an old Marvin Harrison."

So you're saying that it's not a valid argument to say that Peyton played on the road, outside in the snow and Warner played inside, on his homefield turf..inside of a dome???? If that's what you're saying, then you're insane.

[Scottdau]

Quote: Originally Posted by z Revis

PLAYERS PLAY DIFFERENT ON DIFFERENT TEAMS AND IN DIFFERENT SITUATIONS. Put Manning on those Rams and have him play nice and snug on his Dome Homefield turf...he'd do the exact same thing. When at home, Peyton has played amazing in the Playoffs including a PERFECT rating against Denver.

One should ask Faulk what he thinks.

[Jukeman]

Quote: Originally Posted by z Revis

PLAYERS PLAY DIFFERENT ON DIFFERENT TEAMS AND IN DIFFERENT SITUATIONS. Put Manning on those Rams and have him play nice and snug on his Dome Homefield turf...he'd do the exact same thing. When at home, Peyton has played amazing in the Playoffs including a PERFECT rating against Denver.

wasn't the Colts compared to that "greatest show on turf" team just a couple years ago?

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by juk34man

wasn't the Colts compared to that "greatest show on turf" team just a couple years ago?

They sure were...until they went on the road outside in the snow.