Brett Favre + 2010 Superbowl = Greatest of all time?

[z Revis]

Quote: Originally Posted by nccomicfan

Honestly, the GOAT-in-waiting plays in an hour...right now, I still think Elway is the best ever, followed by Montana, Marino and then Farve....I do think Peyton will retire as the best without question because every record will be his by the time he's done

Depends if Favre ever leaves, if not, Favre will forever hold the records.

And for some reason, I have a weird feeling that Favre keeps coming back to keep Peyton from breaking his records. LOL.

[nccomicfan]

Let me point blank it to every one:

The greatest quarterback of all time has no business throwing the most interceptions in NFL history, period.

[Evan_OS]

Manning has a ways to go to catch up with Favre. But i believe he will finish with most of the records if not all of them (Besides the INT All-Time) Manning still has alot of years in him.

[JayBee74]

Quote: Originally Posted by metallicatz

No. And Mort could tell you the exact salinity level of the sweat on Favre's sack. Him and Trent Dilfer are two of the worst at ESPN for worshipping at the altar of Favre.

LOL-yes there are some serious Favre worshipers in the NFL media. No telling what kind of erotic fantasies dance around in the head of John Madden.

Favre is my personal favorite QB ever. That said, I don't know if winning another Super Bowl would make him the greatest of all time... Montana? Elway? Manning? Etc?

Top five qb? Sure? Number one... I dunno.

[TheWatcher]

Quote: Originally Posted by CodeBlueDude

Manning has a ways to go to catch up with Favre. But i believe he will finish with most of the records if not all of them (Besides the INT All-Time) Manning still has alot of years in him.

Peyton Manning is a better QB than Favre ever was, even at Favre's peak in the 90's. Manning is smarter, more efficient, and a better Human Being. Favre is a great player (and a jerk), but he's not in Manning's class and I don't care what numbers Favre has put up.

[raz77]

Quote: Originally Posted by Alliball

That's a gross overstatement, at the very least he's in the conversation.

He's a top 10 QB for me and maybe in the Top 5 discussion, but as far as best ever? Nope.

[TheMatrix31]

this thread is exactly why I want Favre and the Vikings to get destroyed tomorrow---even if its by the Cowboys.