Who deserves this Heisman?

[notrekane]

My friends and I get annoyed every year at the AI choosing the Heisman. More often than not, someone always gets robbed. So this year, we agreed to all vote off line. I am just curious who you guys think deserves it. Below I will list their stats:

Matt Barkley – 74.2% 5057 Yards 66 TD’s 22 INT’s -289 Rushing Yards 6 TD’s 10 Fumbles – (11 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & a turnover every 13.5 times he touches the ball) Only has 1 loss and in that loss to Oregon he had 180 Yards 2 TD's 3 INT's with 1 rushing TD (goaline QB sneak)

De’Anthony Thomas – 1691 Rushing Yards 33 TD’s 0
Fumbles 288 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops 426 Kick Return Yards 1 TD 0
Muffs/Fumbles 363 Punt Return Yards 0 Muffs/Fumbles – 2768 All Purpose
Yards 36 TD’s (14 yards every time he touches ball & a TD every 5
times he touches ball & NEVER turned ball over a single time all year
– 0 fumbles in 228 touches) - Led an undefeated Oregon Rushing attack. Biggest game was win over USC where he had 240 all purpose yards and 2 TD's.

Malcom Brown – 2182 Rushing Yards 40 TD’s 1 Fumble
327 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops – (10.5 yards every time he touches
the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & turns the ball over
once every 240 times he touches the ball) Team undefeated and biggest win came against Notre Dame where he had 160 Yards and 4 TD's.

Braxton Miller – 78.6% 2788 Yards 34 TD’s 6 INT’s
349 Rushing Yards 17 TD’s 0 Fumbles (9.5 yards every time he touches
the ball & a TD every 6.5 times he touches the ball & a turnover every
55 times he touches the ball) Undefeated record and biggest game was against Clemson where he still managed a W but only had 48 yards passing 0 TD's and -5 rushing yards 0 TD's.

Robert Woods – 114 Catches 1933 Yards 28 TD’s 6
Drops 1 Fumble (17 yards per time he touches the ball & a TD every 4
times he touches the ball and a drop every 19 times he’s thrown to and
a turnover once every 114 times he catches the ball) One loss and biggest game was loss against Oregon he had 60 yards and 1 TD.

Everyone please either respond with JUST who should win or if you have the time, rank them as you see 1 through 5. Thanks!

[mfbball04]

Quote: Originally Posted by notrekane

My friends and I get annoyed every year at the AI choosing the Heisman. More often than not, someone always gets robbed. So this year, we agreed to all vote off line. I am just curious who you guys think deserves it. Below I will list their stats: Matt Barkley – 74.2% 5057 Yards 66 TD’s 22 INT’s -289 Rushing Yards 6 TD’s 10 Fumbles – (11 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & a turnover every 13.5 times he touches the ball) Only has 1 loss and in that loss to Oregon he had 180 Yards 2 TD's 3 INT's with 1 rushing TD (goaline QB sneak) De’Anthony Thomas – 1691 Rushing Yards 33 TD’s 0 Fumbles 288 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops 426 Kick Return Yards 1 TD 0 Muffs/Fumbles 363 Punt Return Yards 0 Muffs/Fumbles – 2768 All Purpose Yards 36 TD’s (14 yards every time he touches ball & a TD every 5 times he touches ball & NEVER turned ball over a single time all year – 0 fumbles in 228 touches) - Led an undefeated Oregon Rushing attack. Biggest game was win over USC where he had 240 all purpose yards and 2 TD's. Malcom Brown – 2182 Rushing Yards 40 TD’s 1 Fumble 327 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops – (10.5 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & turns the ball over once every 240 times he touches the ball) Team undefeated and biggest win came against Notre Dame where he had 160 Yards and 4 TD's. Braxton Miller – 78.6% 2788 Yards 34 TD’s 6 INT’s 349 Rushing Yards 17 TD’s 0 Fumbles (9.5 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6.5 times he touches the ball & a turnover every 55 times he touches the ball) Undefeated record and biggest game was against Clemson where he still managed a W but only had 48 yards passing 0 TD's and -5 rushing yards 0 TD's. Robert Woods – 114 Catches 1933 Yards 28 TD’s 6 Drops 1 Fumble (17 yards per time he touches the ball & a TD every 4 times he touches the ball and a drop every 19 times he’s thrown to and a turnover once every 114 times he catches the ball) One loss and biggest game was loss against Oregon he had 60 yards and 1 TD. Everyone please either respond with JUST who should win or if you have the time, rank them as you see 1 through 5. Thanks!

im not going to vote for Barkley because those stats are unrealistic.. so i'll go with Woods

[D0GGERT D0G]

Malcom Brown

[mattrd39]

Even though I'm not an Oregon fan...
1-Thomas
2-Miller
3-Barkley
4-Brown
5-Woods

In real life, it would probably go to Miller though, playing QB at the bigger school that is also undefeated.

[utahman27]

1. Brown

2. Barkley

3. Thomas

4. Woods

5. Miller

[Wavebird99]

Quote: Originally Posted by utahman27

1. Brown 2. Barkley 3. Thomas 4. Woods 5. Miller

This, except switch Miller and Woods around.

[dingleberryfinn]

Miller then Barkley, his int's are too high for my taste.

[TryHard_Nation]

Quote: Originally Posted by notrekane

My friends and I get annoyed every year at the AI choosing the Heisman. More often than not, someone always gets robbed. So this year, we agreed to all vote off line. I am just curious who you guys think deserves it. Below I will list their stats: Matt Barkley – 74.2% 5057 Yards 66 TD’s 22 INT’s -289 Rushing Yards 6 TD’s 10 Fumbles – (11 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & a turnover every 13.5 times he touches the ball) Only has 1 loss and in that loss to Oregon he had 180 Yards 2 TD's 3 INT's with 1 rushing TD (goaline QB sneak) De’Anthony Thomas – 1691 Rushing Yards 33 TD’s 0 Fumbles 288 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops 426 Kick Return Yards 1 TD 0 Muffs/Fumbles 363 Punt Return Yards 0 Muffs/Fumbles – 2768 All Purpose Yards 36 TD’s (14 yards every time he touches ball & a TD every 5 times he touches ball & NEVER turned ball over a single time all year – 0 fumbles in 228 touches) - Led an undefeated Oregon Rushing attack. Biggest game was win over USC where he had 240 all purpose yards and 2 TD's. Malcom Brown – 2182 Rushing Yards 40 TD’s 1 Fumble 327 Receiving Yards 1 TD 0 Drops – (10.5 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6 times he touches ball & turns the ball over once every 240 times he touches the ball) Team undefeated and biggest win came against Notre Dame where he had 160 Yards and 4 TD's. Braxton Miller – 78.6% 2788 Yards 34 TD’s 6 INT’s 349 Rushing Yards 17 TD’s 0 Fumbles (9.5 yards every time he touches the ball & a TD every 6.5 times he touches the ball & a turnover every 55 times he touches the ball) Undefeated record and biggest game was against Clemson where he still managed a W but only had 48 yards passing 0 TD's and -5 rushing yards 0 TD's. Robert Woods – 114 Catches 1933 Yards 28 TD’s 6 Drops 1 Fumble (17 yards per time he touches the ball & a TD every 4 times he touches the ball and a drop every 19 times he’s thrown to and a turnover once every 114 times he catches the ball) One loss and biggest game was loss against Oregon he had 60 yards and 1 TD. Everyone please either respond with JUST who should win or if you have the time, rank them as you see 1 through 5. Thanks!

1.Brown
2. Woods
3. Thomas
4. Miller
5. Barkerly