Overrated/Underrated DD Players

[SigmundFraud]

I'll start it off by saying the Grady Sizemore throwback card is a little ridiculous. It's probably the best card against right handed pitching in the game right now (yeah arod and pujols are good but Sizemore hits left handed). Don't get me wrong, Sizemore '06 was good, but the power stats they gave him are a little crazy. He didn't even hit 30 homeruns that season.

[jyoung]

So far the Yasiel Puig I pulled from my preorder packs has only been good for defense. I can't get hits with him for some reason even though he has hot zones across the entire strike zone.

[Foldzy]

regular Puig is not rated very highly as a hitter. The flashback Puig looks like one of the best RF's out there

Joe Morgan seems pretty overrated to me

[SigmundFraud]

Quote: Originally Posted by Foldzy

regular Puig is not rated very highly as a hitter. The flashback Puig looks like one of the best RF's out there

Prince Fielder is the same way. Maybe players that got flashback cards got lower base stats.

[Denzel Washington]

Sandberg's card looks pretty disappointing. Second Baseman overall is so misleading

[memphisonfire]

Quote: Originally Posted by Denzel Washington

Sandberg's card looks pretty disappointing. Second Baseman overall is so misleading

Me viewing a 2B: "Oh snap he's a 95 overall!"

After checking his attributes: "Well **** he couldn't hit water if he fell out of a boat but I'm so glad he'll never make and error and I can steal all day when he gets walked..."

After making 5 errors in a game: "That's it! I'm putting a damn catcher at second now or something because this is a bunch of bull!"

[TonyDanzaFan]

They completely Botched beltres throwback. I mean his hitting stats are ok, but Not representative of 320+ and 48 bombs. He should be way better. Also arenado should have more power and arm strength. 75 arm strength?! He should have 90+ in that area.

[SigmundFraud]

Quote: Originally Posted by TonyDanzaFan

They completely Botched beltres throwback. I mean his hitting stats are ok, but Not representative of 320+ and 48 bombs. He should be way better. Also arenado should have more power and arm strength. 75 arm strength?! He should have 90+ in that area.

Yeah I saw the Beltre card yesterday, the hitting stats are pretty laughable when you think about how insane his season was. I just don't understand why someone like Sizemore is rewarded so mightily for being good against righties only. Beltre was way better against righties than Sizemore was, but somehow his in game ratings are worse. And I'm with you on Arenado, that card all around is just not nearly good enough.